Quick - it's in my basket, opinions please

[Sunnysider]

I really need a Mac - and wanted a shortish one. Don't normally look in Per Una but I thought this looked nice?

Mac

I love a mac, but this one is screaming Per Una at me. Do they do free returns and delivery? If so, I'd get it and see what it's like on, but it might be awful.

No. Frumpy.

I like it looks classic and tailored.

Take it out. You can do better.

I think the collar looks really clunky....but otherwise it is ok. Ok mind, not amaze balls

nicer

Looks cheap and frumpy.

Horrible. Sorry.

eeeww, sorry, looks bland, beige and frumpy, not at all chic, you surely can find prettier or funkier ones than that?

yellows is gorgeous. And I don't even like Macs.

asos quality is a bit crap though,

I don't like it sorry. Have you tried Zara & Mango?

Thanks all - that's why I asked, just wasn't sure. I would have been disappointed if i'd got it.

Yellow -do like it better but think I would be better with single breasted as I am double breasted enough already iykwim

also...asos have a great photographer and throw alot of money on the shoots, the styling etc to cover up for their not so great quality. I would put them on a par with Primark for wear/fit/fabric quality.

How about this

Much more stylish, and endorsed by 40 bum lady here

sorry - just seen you want single breasted. I also have rather, ahem, large norks, but I still get a double breasted mac. I think single breasted looks odd in the case of macs.

It's true that Asos quality isn't always great, but I had a mac from there that was really well cut and lasted ages.

iamcovered that is a classic mac, lovely.