Does anyone know where I can get a nice chunky eyeliner crayon?

[headfairy]

not one of those thin hard kohl eyeliners but a nice chunky soft one, in something like a dusty brown or a dark grey. I've looked everywhere. I did find one in Boots but it was mega cheap, and I've discovered why. It only lasts about four seconds before it's all rubbed off.

Benefit do a good chunky one.

Eyeko do too.

oh thanks I'll check them out.. I walked past the Benefit counter in Boots today to

I've been meaning to start a thread on the same thing - I need a navy one.
Any others?

Topshop have some chunky crayons in their own brand make up range that are nice (I got a nice pewter grey colour). Otherwise Barry M or Urban Decay?

I remember years ago Body Shop used to sell fab powder eyeshadow chunky pencils (and I know it was years ago, as that was when Barbara Daly put her name to it!)

Moomin, body shop was where my love of chunky eye crayons began, I had a fab pewter Barbara daly one for years, I eked out every last scrap!

Ooh, Pixi do a pewter coloured chunky one. Think it's called silver black or something yep, and there's a couple of sellers on ebay doing them for only £3.15 with free postage. (They are normally £12) Haven't used it myself but Pixi stuff is generally quite good. Got to be worth a punt.

Oh lovely, I've had a look and it looks fab. I think I'll give it a go, esp as its so cheap.

I second barry m