Bobbi Brown Ultra Nude Eye Palette & Urban Decay Naked 1 & 2

[Housewife2010]

I've managed to cancel my Shesaid 6 month subscription, so I've got my £50 back & I'm getting urges for a nude eye palette.
Does anyone have the BB or the Urban Decay Naked 1 or 2? Any recommendations? I've been using the BB Shimmer Wash in Fawn for the last 5 years (I got it for my wedding day!) & I love it. Due to my DS I've not had chance though to go into town to look at the palettes. - He hates Tesco, make-up shopping in John Lewis would send him over the edge!

Housewife2010, I have The Naked Palette 1 - alright, possibly a bit on the shimmery side, I think they're only 2 or maybe 3 matte shades. The Too Faced nude eyes palette - nice, wearable, not amazingly fabulous and the Sleek nude palette - possibly the most useful of the 3, matte and neutral shades-arama.

i have BB stonewashed nudes and shimmer nudes (for about 5 years - like you got them for my wedding)
I love them but my fave shades are running out too so interested in this.
I find I like shimmer shadows for daytime too - so the shimmer doesnt bother me
The shimmer wash in fawn is lovely - there s a mac one that s similar I got to replace mine as it was nearly gone - i can look it up if you like.....
(i find BB shimmer shades more subtle than MAC, which i think are more pigmented, so prefer BB for daytime.)

I have naked palette 1; I do use it almost everyday, but I am a little bit more dramatic with my makeup.

Thanks for your comments. I think I'll have to go into town on my DS's nursery day & have a look. I don't do anything too dramatic with my eye makeup & don't actually need any more makeup - but I want it!