Just discovered an eye make up remover - Oil of Olay, it's in a white tube and £1.50 in Tescos atm.
It's a cream so very similar to removing your eye make up with Liz Earle's Cleanse and Polish. I used a warm muslin cloth instead of cotton wool and it's really really effective (I wear LOADS of waterproof mascara!)
In fact I prefer it to C and P as Liz changed the formula a while back and I haven't forgiven her yet 