your opinions on these boots please?

[vinegarpuss]

www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0051T81EM/ref=asc_df_B0051T81EM5723636/?tag=googlecouk06-21&creative=22110&creativeASIN=B0051T81EM&linkCode=asn
or
www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B004JHO6AA/ref=asc_df_B004JHO6AA5723636/?tag=googlecouk06-21&creative=22110&creativeASIN=B004JHO6AA&linkCode=asn

sorry for the long links

I prefer the first pair, like the buckles, a bit more to them than the second pair.

thank you, they are my favourite too. I have also found these on Javari - as you can probably tell I am looking for wide calf boots!

www.javari.co.uk/Ravel-Womens-Harlequin-Knee-Boots/dp/B00508VQLE/ref=dp_sbs_6?fromPage=sims&asins=B004WK65EO,B005G1YB1C,B005EF7KWC,B0052QLP1A,B004WK62NS,B00508VQLE,B0055AVATA,B004ISYC1I,B004JHPQWW,B0051T7YU4,B005DD5EC8,B0053A9Y6S,B0055ARMJC,B003ZSJ28A,B005VY3R0K,B00567EJSG,B004JHRNQO,B00567EJY0,B003UTUHZQ,B0056X8NG4&contextTitle=Customers%20interested%20in%20this%20item%20also%20viewed...#__asin%3DB0055Y0XAI%26ref%3Ddp_sbs_8%26pageCode%3Dd

I like the shape of the 1st ones best.

If you do a space then a word after the link but before ]] these then your link will come up with the word you put as the link.

So do [link.com boots] with two of the [ of course then it will just come up as boots

thank you - my links are taking over the page and I could not work out how to fix it

I like the 3 rd pair, I think the detail in the leather trim makes them look more expensive!

Like the Ravel ones.

3rd pair.

1st or 3rd for me. 3 very slightly wins.

I've got wide calves. (46cm) and I'd go for the second pair, lovely as the first and third are. They would be more slimming and elongating, because they have a slight heel, are more structured and narrower at the ankle.

I've found the Hobbs Jamie to be the most flattering I have ever had, and they are v similar here?

I like the first link, I have some similar and they are lovely. Look a bit plain under trousers but generally i wear with leggings so thats Ok

2nd pair. They are classic.

First pair are ok, very casual but, to me a wee bit 2002-ish, though. Sorry!

3rd pair are nice but, if they are your only winter boots you are limited in your day-to-day looks.