Looking for a soft eye liner in a charcoal colour.

[TracyK]

My Autograph eyeliner is almost finished and now they don't do it anymore. It was a twisty up thin crayon with a smudger at the other end.
I got Avon glimmersticks - a black and a grey - neither I like!
Any others out there that are darker than grey but not as dark as black, smudgeable and long lasting?

i am always on the look out for a charcoal pencil. I like Cosmetics a la carte in fog
www.cosmeticsalacarte.com/product/_/143/powder-liner/

or Nars have a grey but it is a bit too blue

No 7 have one in brown but it is more of a grey brown with a tiny amount of shimmer

Is the Fog quite a dark grey. It looks a bit light on my screen.

Is that the one in the pot Ruby? I didn't get on with that it emphasised my linesy eyelids!

Maybe I put it on too thickly. Maybe I'll get the girl at the counter to give it another go in another colour - I have black mauve.

The Topshop eye crayon is excellent - v soft and twist up and cheap. You can order it online.

Ah yes. That is true.

I quite like Rimmel ones - not too hard or too soft.

I have a benefit one

I have a Bare Escentials one in dark navy - I might see if they do charcoal.

Charity - is the Topshop one a shimmer or were you agreeing with Ruby re shimmer=crepey.

Just put a but of black mauve on my hand - yes tis a bit of sparkle in thee and also v black - maybe just too dark for my old eyes.

Rimmel used to be excellent for this but that was many many years ago. Still worth a go though, as they're cheap.

I have this one. I actually got it free with Red magazine a few months ago but it's one of the best eyeliners I've ever used.

It's more silvery grey than dark grey though.

hmm - think it might be too light grey bunjies.
I wonder why I didn't get that eye liner with my Red subscription - though I do remember getting a body shop eyeliner one month. It is hard as a blooming rock though!

www.barrym.com/kohl-pencils - available in dark grey. Doesn't come with a smudger, I use a separate smudgerer! Can buy it at SuperDrug.

bourjois no. 73 gris ingenieux is fab. charcoal grey. lasts well.

Clinique do something like glimmersticks which are good and come in lots of nice deep colours, can't remember what they are called sorry but soft and smudge - able and last well, look online to see if they your colour?

Tracey the cosmetics a la carte is a dark grey. Universally flattering, soft but long lasting