What do the bag ladies think?

[novelsituation]

My wee sister has a significant birthday coming up, and I'd love to treat her to a really nice leather bag.

I've spotted this one online at John Lewis, and would love some opinions. Has anyone seen it / got one in real life?

www.johnlewis.com/231425980/Product.aspx?SearchTerm=Whistles+evelyn

I saw this tan one in Jigsaw as an alternative :

www.johnlewis.com/231425980/Product.aspx?SearchTerm=Whistles+evelyn

Which do you prefer?

OOps

Jigsaw one:

www.jigsaw-online.com/fashion/1001457/J14474/accessories/bags/zip-satchel-with-fold-over-front-

I love that Jigsaw one.

I love the tan one too.

Jigsaw one is lovely.

another vote for Jigsaw here, don't like the handles of the whistles one. what a lovely idea for a gift!

Like the Jigsaw one, I have the MN favourite Lucia which is similar, lovely grainy leather....here

Jigsaw is fab.

Thank you all - seems I've got a clear winner!

I have a Jigsaw leather bag and it's still beautiful a year or two & lots of use later. Well worth the price imo.

jigsaw one

Definitely the Jigsaw one, it's lovely.

Jigsaw. It's lovely!!

Ive had my eye on the Jigsaw ne for a while.