Do I need leather?

[TrillianAstra]

Plasticy but I like the shape better

Leather but I'm not so keen on the band around the top - but they do come in wide which might be good for my calves.

Er, my point was "what do you think?"

I really like them, would definately buy them.

Which ones do you like best or think would be better?

Chocolate ruched leather

Definitely the leather ones...gorgeous.

The leather ones,you wont regret it but you might in 6 months time if you buy the plastic ones.I,ve got a pair of Next leather boots that are 4 years old and still going strong.

Plastic footwear is just sweaty and nasty

But I like the top of the plastic ones better... it's a nicer shape.

No-one knows where I can find a nice leather version of those do they?

Have you tried ALdo? I don't know what uk stock is like but I bought the leather version of the next boot a few months back. (I'm in the UAE) They do tend to roll out the best sellers year after year.

These look a bit like it - good tip.

Now I have to decide if that shape is worth the extra £30 over the Next ones.

Eugh no, don't buy plastic boots, really not worth it

I think they are the ones I have, defo worth extra 30 pounds, they will last so much longer. Check out the us web page, if they have a sale in there it will mean the uk is due a sale soon too!

It's an extra £50 over my original thought of "I like those boots but they are plastic"

The plastic ones are nicer - you know, leather boots are nice but if you want waterproof, go for plastic every time.