At the risk of sounding like a feauture from My Guy circa 1987 
I got into a makeup rut - wore variants of the same thing (always used to wear darkish eyeshadow, black liquid eyeliner, blusher and never wore lipstick just a sheer juicy tube)
Decided to do something different - just used a very sheer coppery eyeshadow, no eyeliner at all, just mascara. Kate Middleton eyebrows, with highlighter under brow and on top of cheekbones, just a bit of bronzer and corally lipstick.
I look completely different, and look younger and (dare I say it) rather pretty. Is strange to wear liptick, I haven't worn it since I was a teenager really, hopefully I don't look like Cruella De Vil.