I've used most of the ones you mentioned didn't think they were anything special, and havent bought them again. Currently i use the benefit boing with the no7 pen over the top, making sure i've used a eye cream underneath so the skin doesnt look dry.
I watch alot of you tube videos and read make up blogs and notice that the bobbi brown concealer with the powder and the clinique airbrush one are mentioned alot....i did use these a couple of years ago but can't remember much about them and i didn't replace them when they ran out....but i am tempted to give the clinique one another go seeing as its mentioned so much.