Help me decide

[bubbles4]

Which of these two coats would you have

this or this,have both in my house both are returnable but cant decide which one,so thought I would ask MN.

oooh I like both, but the M&S parka a little more than the superdry one

They are both v. different.

2nd one is more country walks and the 1st one more townie.

where and when do you plan to wear them?

for me, the superdry one has too many big pockets and unless you are a skinny 8 or a 10 i think it would look v. bulky.

The superdry one is a proper wax jacket and thats what I originally wanted (dog walking etc) but its a bit too short ,the M&sS one is longer but looks to me like its a glorified mack but will keep me drier in the rain,ds2 says the M&S one,ds3 the superdry one,dd just rolled her eyes and muttered not another coat and DH just said whichever you thinks best so think I will have to let ds1 decide because I cant make my mind up.

lol @ not another coat

if you can afford it, Barbour have some very fashionable stuff ( online) that are similar but they are closer to £200.