Please, please, please... help me decide between these boots

[lissieloucifer]

I need a pair of brown boots to wear with my thick tights/minidress/waistcoat combo's. they have to be flat, I dont do heels and they have to be the right shade of brown. they also have to be cheap. we are seriously skint and these will be a christmas present from dh. been on fleabay and found four pairs that i like

these

these

these

and these

I have skinny ankles and quite bowed calves, so tight ones are out of the question.

which ones shall i get? or none?

I hate the last ones but like the rest of them, maybe the first pair the best? However if you met me you might not take fashion advice from me!!!

The second pair are lovely.

thanks, i really like all of them. the bonus with the last ones is that they will be really warm and wont be too loose round the top iykwim.

the first ones are woolly inside (toasty) and the other two pairs are qute simillar and lovely.

The 3rd ones are my favourite

Its between 2 and 3 for me...

i tried on a gorgeous pair in debenhams today with sheepskin collar but they were £60 [hsad]

2, 3 and 4 are my favourite, i like the fact that the zip only goes half way up. this means a better fit for my type of leg.

I like 4 the best. Also quite like 2 & 3 but not so keen on the first pair.

I think 2 would be my favourite but 1 an 3 look fine.
Dislike number 4

I like 3.

2 are my fave but 3 quite nice too.
Don't like 1 or 4 at all.

number 2 or 3 for me. hard to choose between those 2, really depends on your style.

2 are my favourite.

so number 2 seems to be the favourite...

Ooooh, number 3 are fab

Number 2. Would have gone for number 3 but I think leather is better than synthetic.

1 or 2 look great. Don't like 3 or 4 at all.

Oh actually 3 IS quite nice - I just think it's a strange colour of brown.

ok, i think i/we have decide on number 2. i do really like number 4 and think they will bequite flattering to my leg shape, but 2will be just that bit more versatile.