Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Higher or Foundation

13 replies

mrsconradfisher · Yesterday 22:07

Sorry I know there must be a million threads about this but just after some advice. DS has always found Maths challenging, pure number he is confident with but anything beyond that is hard going. He is in the 2nd set out of 3 however the school is split in 2 so 3 sets each side. He is definitely at the bottom end of that set. However he has a fantastic teacher who gets DS in a way no other teacher has and I’m reluctant for him to move sets as the bottom set is full of children with massive behaviour issues and he wouldn’t cope, he has ASD.

We thought he was aiming for a 6 on the higher paper, predicted a 6. Got a 4 in Y10 mocks on 1 paper that they sat. . However they have had their proper mocks this week and he has just shut down completely and says he cannot remember anything. I contacted a tutor in a bid to try and help him and he assessed him tonight and has basically said DS doesn’t know anything he needs to sit the higher paper. Genuinely don’t know what to do, I knew he found maths hard but no one has ever said he was struggling that much. He needs a 5 to stay at 6th form.
Obviously won’t get mocks back before Christmas and will speak at parents evening but I’m torn with asking for him to stay in the set he is in with a teacher he works well with but clearly he won’t be able to access that much of the higher paper or move down to bottom set and sit the foundation paper but he won’t cope in that class. DS doesn’t think he would be allowed to stay in that set and sit foundation.
Mocks finish on Friday so over weekend he is going to sit a Foundation paper and see what he gets. Genuinely think there should be a Middle Paper, must be so demoralising to sit a paper that you can’t access most of.

OP posts:
Octavia64 · Yesterday 22:21

Ex maths teacher.

the higher/foundation decision can be really tricky for students who are capable of both.

foundation is easier by miles but you need to get lots of it right to get a 4. The slow start with easier questions can really help confidence in some students though.

final decisions on foundation or higher don’t need to be made until well after Christmas.

some schools for students that are unsure will get them to sit a foundation paper and a higher paper in mocks and see which one they do better on.

most schools would be very reluctant to allow someone to change sets at this point in year 11. The teacher knows them and they know the teacher.

the class he is in is probably focusing on what is called the “crossover” topics. These are the topics that are at the end of the foundation paper (so grade 4/5 questions) and the same questions are at the start of the higher paper. So if he stays where he is they’ll be doing topics relevant to both papers.

it’s quite likely they’ve finished the syllabus by now and are onto revision.

clary · Yesterday 22:25

DS doesn’t think he would be allowed to stay in that set and sit foundation.

This is a key question and one I suggest you raise with school. If the only objection to the F tier paper is that he would have to move sets, a bid to allow him to stay (especially as a move would be disruptive to anyone at this stage – less than six months till exams start (as I see @Octavia64 also says) might be what you need.

He can gain a 5 on the F paper as I imagine you know. My subject is MFL not maths, but in MFL if you are looking at a likely grade 4/5 then there is no doubt IMHO you should sit the F paper, and I imagine it's the same for maths.

I agree that it must be demoralising to sit a paper you cannot do most of (grade 5 on H paper AQA this year was just over 40%) tho that said, DD got a lazy 6 and says that it was not an issue. But then she was pretty pragmatic about her maths GCSE (probs could have done better but not fussed about it so focused elsewhere). I think that if you are trying your absolute best at a paper and most of it is out of your reach, then yes, that must be tough.

ETA: Oh just seen who the OP is! hiiiiiii in a Loughborough way. Hope your older DS is still enjoying it :)

mrsconradfisher · Yesterday 22:27

Octavia64 · Yesterday 22:21

Ex maths teacher.

the higher/foundation decision can be really tricky for students who are capable of both.

foundation is easier by miles but you need to get lots of it right to get a 4. The slow start with easier questions can really help confidence in some students though.

final decisions on foundation or higher don’t need to be made until well after Christmas.

some schools for students that are unsure will get them to sit a foundation paper and a higher paper in mocks and see which one they do better on.

most schools would be very reluctant to allow someone to change sets at this point in year 11. The teacher knows them and they know the teacher.

the class he is in is probably focusing on what is called the “crossover” topics. These are the topics that are at the end of the foundation paper (so grade 4/5 questions) and the same questions are at the start of the higher paper. So if he stays where he is they’ll be doing topics relevant to both papers.

it’s quite likely they’ve finished the syllabus by now and are onto revision.

Thank you, that’s helpful. They definitely haven’t finished the syllabus that I do know. The parallel class have but DS’ class have done 1 topic since they started back in September so are quite a way behind which I don’t think is helping. His teacher teaches very very slowly which is good for DS but not great to go into a mock not having learnt much of the paper.

OP posts:
Tickingcrocodile · Yesterday 22:35

What does he want to do afterwards. My DD is autistic. Was always good at maths, in the top set but missed a lot of school. She took the higher paper up to year 10 mocks but got so worried about it and lacking in confidence that we asked for her to switch to the foundation paper. For her this was definitely the best decision. Personally I thought even the foundation papers seemed quite hard! She gained a lot of confidence and easily came out with a 5. She didn't need higher than a 4 for maths though to do her sixth form subjects.

mrsconradfisher · Yesterday 22:35

clary · Yesterday 22:25

DS doesn’t think he would be allowed to stay in that set and sit foundation.

This is a key question and one I suggest you raise with school. If the only objection to the F tier paper is that he would have to move sets, a bid to allow him to stay (especially as a move would be disruptive to anyone at this stage – less than six months till exams start (as I see @Octavia64 also says) might be what you need.

He can gain a 5 on the F paper as I imagine you know. My subject is MFL not maths, but in MFL if you are looking at a likely grade 4/5 then there is no doubt IMHO you should sit the F paper, and I imagine it's the same for maths.

I agree that it must be demoralising to sit a paper you cannot do most of (grade 5 on H paper AQA this year was just over 40%) tho that said, DD got a lazy 6 and says that it was not an issue. But then she was pretty pragmatic about her maths GCSE (probs could have done better but not fussed about it so focused elsewhere). I think that if you are trying your absolute best at a paper and most of it is out of your reach, then yes, that must be tough.

ETA: Oh just seen who the OP is! hiiiiiii in a Loughborough way. Hope your older DS is still enjoying it :)

Edited

Hi Clary!! He is absolutely loving it, he’s in 3rd year now and is staying to do a Masters. Doesn’t seem possible, all that stress over trying to get in. It was definitely worth him trying again to get to Loughborough though as he has got so much from being there. He coaches one of the BUCS teams and he also got a coaching job at Derby to get a foot in the door. Never had all this stress about Maths with him!
Id have absolutely no issue with DS2 doing the Foundation if he could stay in the same set. I’m interested in what he actually gets on the F paper as he has never sat one so that’s next on the list to do. It’s the decision over not being to access most of the paper but still scraping a 5 or being able to do most of the paper but having to get such a high score to get a 5.

He is def sitting the F French paper…I did the reading paper with him last week to prove a point! (I did French A-level many moons ago!). I got 10 more marks than him, he was not impressed!!

OP posts:
mrsconradfisher · Yesterday 22:40

Tickingcrocodile · Yesterday 22:35

What does he want to do afterwards. My DD is autistic. Was always good at maths, in the top set but missed a lot of school. She took the higher paper up to year 10 mocks but got so worried about it and lacking in confidence that we asked for her to switch to the foundation paper. For her this was definitely the best decision. Personally I thought even the foundation papers seemed quite hard! She gained a lot of confidence and easily came out with a 5. She didn't need higher than a 4 for maths though to do her sixth form subjects.

He wants to be a physio or sports therapist. But I think he’ll probably need to start with a Foundation Year at Uni potentially. He has the best work ethic but just isn’t as academic as his older brother. He has confidence and people skills by the bucketload though!
He gets extra time and doesn’t usually get bothered by exams but he has been really concerned these past few weeks. Think it’s a combination of not finishing syllabus and realising he just can’t access most of the paper.

OP posts:
clary · Yesterday 22:40

@mrsconradfisher ah very impressive from you on the French GCSE :) yes the F paper is much more accessible.

I’m glad to hear DS1 is still enjoying himself at Luffers. Cannot believe he is in year 3 already! My DS has finally graduated with his masters in the summer. I don't think he wanted to leave (and in fact his gf is still there so I think he is still to be spotted on campus haha).

Tickingcrocodile · Yesterday 22:43

Confidence and people skills will doubtless get him further in the long run than a 6 in maths.

mrsconradfisher · Yesterday 22:47

Tickingcrocodile · Yesterday 22:43

Confidence and people skills will doubtless get him further in the long run than a 6 in maths.

Thank you, honestly I have 2 boys that are the complete polar opposites of each other. One is very academic, focused and driven but is quiet and reserved.
DS2 finds some academic stuff really hard but can walk into a room and just talk to people. He refs at the weekends and is not phased at all by what anyone thinks of him. Even more impressive that he is autistic.

OP posts:
Trwkaw · Yesterday 23:52

Have to say i agree re just being h or f papers. Because the higher is now just too hard!
i feel it does allow demonstrating the skill and then harder versions. Just straight in on too tricky.
my dc is y10 and didnt do as well on recent test. Their school look like teacher up to apr y11.

Have him do practices of the older f and higher papers and go over the errors.

i find the homeworks are too easy comparatively so mine isnt getting enough practise at the level of q on the papers.

labradorservant · Today 03:07

I would ask school about moving paper but not class. Say everything you’ve said here. Suggest he spends anytime on topics in class he won’t need to
cover doing revision/past questions. Even offer to provide these if a problem for the school.
Also find out when the exam entries need to be done by the school. In a way maybe the later you leave it the less likely he’ll move class….
there are also lots of you tube exam and question videos. Would this help his confidence in the meantime.
My son should have moved to foundation French. He hated it and just about scraped a 4. I think had he done foundation he may have tried and got that 5. It must be really off putting when the last few questions on the maths paper are for the grade 8/9 pupils.

mrsconradfisher · Today 07:46

labradorservant · Today 03:07

I would ask school about moving paper but not class. Say everything you’ve said here. Suggest he spends anytime on topics in class he won’t need to
cover doing revision/past questions. Even offer to provide these if a problem for the school.
Also find out when the exam entries need to be done by the school. In a way maybe the later you leave it the less likely he’ll move class….
there are also lots of you tube exam and question videos. Would this help his confidence in the meantime.
My son should have moved to foundation French. He hated it and just about scraped a 4. I think had he done foundation he may have tried and got that 5. It must be really off putting when the last few questions on the maths paper are for the grade 8/9 pupils.

Thank you. He has been doing loads of YouTube videos and past papers, the issue is because they haven’t even been taught half the stuff yet he is almost working blind. He can obviously teach it to himself but teaching yourself those harder topics when you already find maths challenging is quite a big ask. We have now got a maths tutor so he’s also going to teach him topics but he has some ms y gaps it’s hard to know where to start.
Really good point about leaving it late though, my thought was moving to F early to try and take some pressure off but that won’t work if he needs to move class so will have a chat with school.

OP posts:
mrsconradfisher · Today 07:59

Trwkaw · Yesterday 23:52

Have to say i agree re just being h or f papers. Because the higher is now just too hard!
i feel it does allow demonstrating the skill and then harder versions. Just straight in on too tricky.
my dc is y10 and didnt do as well on recent test. Their school look like teacher up to apr y11.

Have him do practices of the older f and higher papers and go over the errors.

i find the homeworks are too easy comparatively so mine isnt getting enough practise at the level of q on the papers.

Thank you. Yes there seems to be no middle ground does there? Thing is DS isn’t terrible at maths, in his books he is getting the work mostly correct. They do EDI for homework and he doesn’t particularly struggle with that either. I know it’s no real comparison but he did ok in his SATS, got 107 I think for maths. Whereas the majority of the bottom set have found maths a challenge their whole school life (I work in his old primary school) so DS doesn’t seem to fit there but the H paper is definitely too much for him.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page