Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Is there a point in attending this math class? GCSE year 11

27 replies

Yellowtreesandorange · Yesterday 14:32

DC said he hates his math class. Too much distraction and noise and the teacher isn’t a good fit. He finds it overwhelming. 3 other parents I have spoken to have confirmed the unsuitability of this teacher.

These are the classes.

Foundation bottom set
Foundation middle set. DS is in this one
Higher maths: Good teacher
Higher maths: Good teacher

Head of maths says there is no other option and he can’t move DS.

I am considering removing him from
current maths class as it is causing DS lots of stress and do private tutoring instead.

OP posts:
TokyoSushi · Yesterday 14:37

Is this just in a regular school? I don't think that you can remove him...

Yellowtreesandorange · Yesterday 14:45

TokyoSushi · Yesterday 14:37

Is this just in a regular school? I don't think that you can remove him...

Not exactly a regular school but not private either.

It is causing lots of stress and impacting others subjects. DS is happy with the other subjects but maths is normally first thing in the morning so not a good way to start your day with a stressful class.

OP posts:
angelcake20 · Yesterday 14:47

Where do you expect him to go instead? Schools don’t just let students drop out of classes and provide supervision for them elsewhere. It’s fine to get tutoring for him but a student will not be moved to an inappropriate set just because they don’t get on with the teacher.

noblegiraffe · Yesterday 15:05

You don’t have any power to ‘remove him’ from a timetabled lesson. If the class are poorly behaved you can ask the school what additional measures they are putting in place to support the teacher.

Yellowtreesandorange · Yesterday 15:08

He will be at home and start in second lesson

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · Yesterday 15:14

The school would be within their rights to mark that as truancy, and it would mess up his attendance as he’d skip morning registration. Surely his maths lesson isn’t always first period?

Can you work with the school to find a better solution than him bunking off school?

MiddleAgedDread · Yesterday 15:17

Will it not go down as unauthorised absence if he misses registration before 1st lesson?

LumberPainJackie · Yesterday 15:18

He needs to still go to the lessons and you also pay for the tutoring. This is what usually happens, he still has to attend or be marked as absent.
You don't want the council fines.

Oliveoy · Yesterday 15:18

Yellowtreesandorange · Yesterday 15:08

He will be at home and start in second lesson

Those will go down as unauthorised absences then, and it won't be long before you're fined. A school isn't going to allow a child to miss teaching for a core GCSE

WhosGotTheKeysToMyBimma · Yesterday 15:25

Get a tutor and tell your DS the only way he's getting out of this maths class is if he bucks his ideas up and the head of department puts him forward for higher tier.

You can't bring him to school late every day.

clary · Yesterday 20:23

I agree with others, the school will not allow you just to send him in late every day. You say he is in GCSE year so I assume England or Wales; what kind of school is it, if not "regular"?

Also is maths really the first lesson every day? Overall I don’t think it’s a great idea anyway in terms of his maths progress. I would suggest first contacting the school to discuss what it is doing to support the class, and talk about how your son can make more progress. Don’t say the teacher is unsuitable (that’s not for you and other parents to decide). It’s very challenging for schools to recruit maths teachers so maybe they are not the best, but I am sure with a discussion things can improve.

passtheMSGdon · Yesterday 20:30

The quality of the maths teachers is a matter of +- one grade. The quality of the parent is +- three grades.

stichguru · Yesterday 20:54

This won't work. Maths is a core subject. If he is being educated in school he will have to be in Maths. If he isn't he will be in big trouble for truanting from lessons. If it was an optional GCSE, he could perhaps drop that subject and be allowed to work elsewhere in those lessons, but Maths is core, he will be missing an essential, compulsory part of school, which will get him into massive trouble unless he leaves school completely.

Hatty65 · Yesterday 21:01

I'm intrigued as to how 3 parents can 'confirm' the unsuitability of a teacher.

I mean, bearing in mind they are unqualified to do so and haven't observed any of the lessons, it's a confident statement to make...

And no, you can't decide to remove your child from a core subject. He's sitting the foundation paper presumably because he isn't considered capable of a higher one. He needs all the lessons he can get. By all means employ a private tutor in the evenings in addition if you think it will help.

ChillyNGrateful · Yesterday 21:05

Seems like a lot of roadblocks for what is a reasonable request. In a perfect world he could attend the library.

Greenfingers37 · Yesterday 22:08

What message are you sending him by saying he can just bunk off Maths every day? Sometimes kids just have to suck it up. He’s only got a few more months of teaching to go-it would be madness to pull him out now and risk being fined for all those unauthorised absences.
My son struggled with Maths, had a series of supply teachers and hated it so in the January of Year 11, we had him tutored once a week. It was enough to get him a grade 5.
Trust me, he doesn’t want a resit-the pass marks for these are dire!
Take control-you’re his parent, not his mate.

TurquoiseDress · Yesterday 22:14

I’d get him a maths tutor sorted out to support him and ensure he does attend the Maths classes at school- he can’t just drop out of then altogether, sorry but that just sounds bonkers!

justasmalltownmum · Yesterday 22:34

I would be bombarding the school on how they are supporting the teacher, fixing the behaviour, helping my child

gonoodleoodle · Yesterday 22:38

Doing this tells him he doesn’t have to do things he doesn’t like. Bad idea.

XelaM · Yesterday 22:46

So I totally get this OP, as my daughter's Maths teacher in Y10 was an actual joke and that whole set's attainment completely tanked and behaviour was awful. The only way out was to do well in tests to try to get moved to a higher set. That's what my daughter fought to do. Her final GCSE grade was a 7, but she still says that Y10 was pretty much a wash-out so she probably could have achieved higher if not for the awful teaching/class. I would get your son a tutor to try to get him to move sets to a better teacher.

MrsHamlet · Today 05:13

ChillyNGrateful · Yesterday 21:05

Seems like a lot of roadblocks for what is a reasonable request. In a perfect world he could attend the library.

And do what? Supervised how?

Cardhey · Today 05:19

FFS. He needs to suck it up.

SoftIce · Today 06:58

Adults can vote with their feet when faced with awful behaviour at work every day. Unfortunately children cannot. It may be a wake-up call to the school if you withdraw him from the lessons citing bad behaviour management. But more likely they'll just expel him eventually.

If you do decide to send him in late, give us an update. I'm curious to know how it pans out.

BestZebbie · Today 16:01

If this is an online school that technically counts as home Ed then you can withdraw your kid from that lesson, but you might also just be able to get them switched to a different teaching slot. If it is putting them off maths and you can arrange and afford a 1-2-1 tutor, why not - the ‘school’ is effectively just a group tutoring wrapper anyway.

Yellowtreesandorange · Today 16:17

Thank you for the opinion.

I don’t agree with the suck it up attitude. I learned the hard way at work and ended in burnout.

I think you need to speak up and take action if something isn’t working for you. How awful that kids don’t have a saying and have to accept everything adults say or do.

Anyway. I had already withdrew him from the class for two weeks. DS finds it over stimulating and I don’t think is a good start of your day and impact other lessons if you start stressed.

The school has come with a good solution so he doesn’t miss lessons.

OP posts: