Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Should I question the teacher about Y13 d's biology current working at grade?

18 replies

coffeerevelsrule · 14/11/2026 09:06

I have never done this even when dc have told me the grades on their reports don't match what they've been told/grades they got for tests. I'm a teacher myself and assume teachers have their reasons and different methods of deciding on working at grades so as long as there are no major issues I've seen no need to delve deeper. However, with university applications on the horizon ds obviously needs to know where he stands at this point.

He's been given a current grade of a C this term, and it says autumn prediction is a B, so he has missed that. I don't know whether the predictions sent to UCAS are these autumn predictions or whether they could be changed, presumably downwards in ds's case, which would be a problem. DS says they have done two tests this term and in one he got a C (he says mid or low, so I'm assuming low) and in the other a B, one mark off an A. He also says 'everyone' was awarded a couple of extra marks for that one when they got the tests back and he found 4 potential extra marks but was not awarded any of them.

DS thinks the teacher dislikes him. There is some evidence for that (much as I'm resistant to the idea) because last year he was given a D for classroom conduct even though he was adamant there was one occasion he and his friend had to be told to stop talking and his friend was given A for conduct. I know this sounds like bollocks but DS has never been in trouble in school. I did ring the teacher on that occasion because I would make DS's life hell if he was pissing about in his A levels but I was not really impressed with the teacher. He basically admitted it was a one off occasion and also said he thought DS had been shocked by a recent test score and had expected to do better and basically implied he was arrogant. But DS had scored an A - the class had been told no one could get an A star at that point so, no, he hadn't expected to do better - he worked bloody hard to get the A and was absolutely delighted with it. The teacher was taken aback when I told him DS had got an A and didn't know what to say. He obviously hadn't checked his data before ringing me back and seemed to have an assumption that DS had done worse than he had, which didn't impress me.

Anyway, back to the working at grade of a C. DS asked the teacher how it was arrived at and he said it's an average of all the grades so far from the end of unit tests. But this dooesn't seem right - DS got two Ds right at the start of the course, then everything since has been a B or an A - they seem to do around 2 tests per half-term. In the summer mocks he got a B, which was again one mark off an A. He was given a working at grade of a B in the summer. In a separate but related matter, they have to get UCAS references from all teachers in their school and DS has seen the biology one and the teacher has written that he gets grades A-C. Now for a reference, why mention one C? Seems petty to me (DS is not applying for biology courses either). It does seem this teacher always sees the worst in him.

I probably sound like 'that' parent here I'm really not. DS does feel despondent and a bit hard done by, which I have tried to help him put in perspective. His friend got a C in the same test he did and she normally comes top of the class. She has been given a working at grade of an A star. DS certainly doesn't expect that obviously but it seems her C has been written off as a blip and his has become his new grade. More importantly, the universities he's looking at have entry requirements of AAA - BBA, so if biology is really lower then he needs to look elsewhere - we well as working hard, which he really is. His other grades are an A star and an A this term.

Would you raise this with the teacher? We do have parents' evening coming up, but they're online and cut off after 5 minutes so I would have to do it separately.

OP posts:
FruAashild · 14/11/2026 09:13

I don't think you'll lose anything by discussing it with the teacher. Our school said UCAS grades were 'possible performance on best day' grades and they are higher than their 'predicted grades'. Terminology may vary. So it might be that his UCAS grades are still OK. You won't know till you check.

noblegiraffe · 14/11/2026 09:17

Your DS is in Y13 and should be approaching the teacher himself to ask what his UCAS predicted grade is and to request it be increased if necessary.

If the outcome of that discussion isn't helpful, then you can get involved.

Sherararara · 14/11/2026 12:45

Y13? You shouldn’t be doing anything fgs.

coffeerevelsrule · 14/11/2026 14:29

I get DS needing to take responsibility, which is why he has asked how the grade has been arrived at, and I agree he should also ask about the predicted grade too, though I'm worried he won't push for a fuller picture and will just ask for it be be increased which could backfire if the teacher does so undeservedly.

I don't get this weird MN thing about having no involvement with kids' lives past a certain point. I'm a teacher and get parents of Y13s making enquiries and think nothing of it. We still have parents' evenings for a reason.

OP posts:
12345change · 14/11/2026 18:58

UCAS predicted are suppose to be aspirational. Your son also has a right to see his UCAS reference.

Ask them to explain what his predicted grade is and how they got to that. I would guess his predicted grade and current will be two different grades.

FruAashild · 14/11/2026 22:49

Your son also has a right to see his UCAS reference.

At my kids sixth form the subject teachers each write a short reference but the final version is produced either by the form tutor or, for the Oxbridge /medicine /vet /dentistry students by the specialist careers teacher.

ALineInTheSand · 15/11/2026 07:45

Given you've already had a negative interaction with the biology teacher, is it worth asking for a meeting with the Head of Year instead who will hopefully be able to be more objective (and will also hopefully have your DS's best interests at heart)?

Advocating for your offspring to get the best shot possible at fair grades for their UCAS form is normal parental behaviour, imo. Even if Y13 pupils have turned 18 (which most haven't by this point in the year) there is still a teacher / pupil dynamic which most pupils will respect and which makes it difficult for them to challenge these kinds of decisions.

Piglet89 · 15/11/2026 08:19

coffeerevelsrule · 14/11/2026 14:29

I get DS needing to take responsibility, which is why he has asked how the grade has been arrived at, and I agree he should also ask about the predicted grade too, though I'm worried he won't push for a fuller picture and will just ask for it be be increased which could backfire if the teacher does so undeservedly.

I don't get this weird MN thing about having no involvement with kids' lives past a certain point. I'm a teacher and get parents of Y13s making enquiries and think nothing of it. We still have parents' evenings for a reason.

@coffeerevelsruleit is not a “weird Mumsnet thing”. It’s the fact that, in general, a lot helicoptering goes on for kids these days. For instance, our building contractor told us a mother phoned him to tell him her 17 year old son who was labouring for him couldn’t come to work as he was sick. The kid’s at work now: he needs to take responsibility himself!

When such young people hit our workplace (an office environment) they sometimes have no clue how to behave because they’ve been babied and cosseted.

Octavia64 · 15/11/2026 08:24

Fine to speak to teacher.

i used to be a teacher and there were definite processes for working out predicted grades and averaging tests that were across the whole of year 13 and not set by the individual teacher.

email in and ask for an explanation.

in particular there are distinctions made between current working at grade (what they would get if the exam were today) and predicted grades (what they expect him to get in the exam based on where he is now).

fluffythecat1 · 15/11/2026 08:32

My son is in Y12 and I got in contact with his sixth form teacher last week because he had been given an E grade for one of his subjects. The other two were B and C and he achieved a 7 for this subject at GCSE. The teacher replied saying that she had entered the grade incorrectly and that it was actually a C. No harm in communicating with them to support your son’s progress and to clarify any issues.

maudelovesharold · 15/11/2026 08:46

Sherararara · 14/11/2026 12:45

Y13? You shouldn’t be doing anything fgs.

Y13 is 17/18. Do you really think you shouldn’t be helping your 17/18 yr olds navigate a problem which could affect their future, if not dealt with accurately and fairly? Can’t you imagine that it might not be easy even for parents to insist that teachers check their own work, let alone expecting the students to do it? We’re not talking about dropping a couple of marks on a spelling test or calling in sick. Predicted grades will have an effect on uni offers.

noblegiraffe · 15/11/2026 09:07

I've had loads of conversations with 17/18 year olds in the last month about predicted grades, and zero parents contacting me.

redskyAtNigh · 15/11/2026 12:31

coffeerevelsrule · 14/11/2026 14:29

I get DS needing to take responsibility, which is why he has asked how the grade has been arrived at, and I agree he should also ask about the predicted grade too, though I'm worried he won't push for a fuller picture and will just ask for it be be increased which could backfire if the teacher does so undeservedly.

I don't get this weird MN thing about having no involvement with kids' lives past a certain point. I'm a teacher and get parents of Y13s making enquiries and think nothing of it. We still have parents' evenings for a reason.

The "weird MN thing" is because next year this 17/18 year old will be at university and the university won't talk to you. So in preparation for that, he needs at least to start with a proper discussion with his teacher with you stepping in if he doesn't get a sensible resolution.

You are worried that he won't have the conversation in the way that you would. Well, that's part of learning how to manage these conversations.
if you want to talk beforehand about how to handle the conversation. Firstly he needs to think about what he wants to get out of it. A UCAS predicted grade of a B and understanding of how to improve his current "working at" grade? Then he can think about how to ask questions to get answers.

LewishamTeacher · 15/11/2026 13:49

I have a DC in Y13 and was contacted by the school about their predicted grades, not the other way around. This school doesn't go for the 'highest possible grade on the best possible day' often mentioned on here but instead, uses the results of the Y12 exams for early applicants and the recent mocks for everyone else.

Anyone wanting to submit an early application - but who isn't applying for Oxbridge/medicine - is unable to negotiate a different grade, even if they undertake additional assessments etc. The head of sixth form who called me wanted to be sure I was aware of that as my DC had apparently been told their biology teacher was going to predict a higher grade than their summer exam mark because of subsequent assessments.

I don't agree with the school's approach and for my DC it's meant there's one uni they won't apply to as a result but until I was phoned, all discussion had taken place between my DC and the teachers.

12345change · 15/11/2026 16:06

noblegiraffe · 15/11/2026 09:07

I've had loads of conversations with 17/18 year olds in the last month about predicted grades, and zero parents contacting me.

Same here.

Although that does not mean it never happens. I can probably count on my hands the number of times I've had emails or telephone calls from parents about this in the 25 plus years I've been doing this.

I suspect that teachers who are fair and provide good evidence as to why they are predicting a particular grade do not get phone calls. In this case it seems to be unclear to both the parent and the pupil. Hence, nothing wrong in getting in touch in my opinion.

coffeerevelsrule · 15/11/2026 17:22

redskyAtNigh · 15/11/2026 12:31

The "weird MN thing" is because next year this 17/18 year old will be at university and the university won't talk to you. So in preparation for that, he needs at least to start with a proper discussion with his teacher with you stepping in if he doesn't get a sensible resolution.

You are worried that he won't have the conversation in the way that you would. Well, that's part of learning how to manage these conversations.
if you want to talk beforehand about how to handle the conversation. Firstly he needs to think about what he wants to get out of it. A UCAS predicted grade of a B and understanding of how to improve his current "working at" grade? Then he can think about how to ask questions to get answers.

I don't know why people are so obsessed with this. I have a older child at university and am well aware of the need for them to build independence. Actually I did speak to the university on their behalf last year about exam concessions. It was very simple and just required the young person to send an email giving permission for them to speak to me, which they did and were very helpful.

I think my OP makes clear DS doesn't have the best relationship with this teacher and has already asked him how the grade was arrived at and didn't really get a satisfactory response. What is the point in parents being emailed reports if the students are now young adults and it's nothing to do with us what their grades are?

I think I'll mention it at parents' evening right at the start and then get back in touch if it isn't resolved in that conversation, although DS says he has also confided in his tutor about it and he has offered to speak to the other teacher so DS is considering that too and I'll go with what he decides. I don't think he's too old to have a bit of support in this.

OP posts:
CurlyKoalie · 15/11/2026 18:17

Why don't you both arrange to go and see the teacher together so that your son and you hear the same information. Like you, I was always sceptical when my children tried to justify low scores by blaming " clashes of personality with the teacher" or " mistakes in grading"
Ask to see the print out of your son's grades so you can see why he is getting the grade he is. Go in with a neutral mindset rather than an " avenging parent"
Listen to what his teacher says. Discuss it with your son and the teacher together.
You don't mention how your son did in year 12?
Is this a new issue or did he struggle in year 12 too?
A level biology is a lot harder than GCSE . The language is harder and much more precise and some of the concepts and recall are quite challenging.
Some students who coasted through GCSE do ok on Year 12 because it is similar to GCSE in many ways but struggle with the the harder biochemistry concepts in Year 13.
Some students struggle with the level of English language on the longer answers. Some simply don't understand it.
Some are too busy socialising to put the time into the considerable point of rote learning.
You need to find out which category your son falls into to try and come up with a plan.

coffeerevelsrule · 15/11/2026 20:14

Thanks @CurlyKoalie but I did say DS got a high B (1 mark off an A) in his mock at the end of Y12. He got off to a rocky start with two Ds early in Y12 but then got Bs and As for all the other tests they did. The C suggests a dip and is therefore concerning but I can't work out whether it's based on one test, which the teacher denies but the maths doesn't corroborate it being an average as he claims. Or is he being cautious as they approach the end of the course? But that's not necessarily helpful, especially if he was being generous last year as well- it's just creating a false picture.

DS was a bit lazy at GCSE but ended up with a 7, which disappointed him. He's said from the start biology is his hardest subject (others are psych and a language) but he's definitely working hard. He's summer born and I think he's matured so much from Y11 to now - he's like a different kid. He just needs to know where he stands.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page