Please or to access all these features

Scotsnet

Welcome to Scotsnet - discuss all aspects of life in Scotland, including relocating, schools and local areas.

Aberdeen RI - "wicked recklessness"?

23 replies

Stormontadvisor · 19/11/2026 22:34

A consultant surgeon at the hospital in Aberdeen is whistleblowing. He says that
"dozens of patients died needlessly, including two who died after being given the wrong operation." Apparently the families of those two patients were never told that they had been given the wrong operations.

The consultant surgeon is calling for a public enquiry and a police investigation into potential corporate homicide.

He says he has previously written to First Minister John Swinney, former first minister Humza Yousaf and former health secretaries Michael Matheson and Neil Gray, but says he has been repeatedly ignored.

He says that there's "a deep-rooted culture of denial, arrogance and incompetence."

https://www.scotsman.com/health/whistleblowing-surgeon-calls-for-criminal-probe-of-aberdeen-hospital-slaughterhouse-9361050?

OP posts:
WearyAuldWumman · 19/11/2026 23:48

Bloody hell. That's awful.

TheExcitersBlowingUpMyMindNSoul · Yesterday 01:06

Time to expose all NHS. Scotland cover ups
And there's plenty of them.
Top marks to the whistle blower
bringing this to light .I dare say the situation isn't unique and confined to ARI.

Stormontadvisor · Yesterday 10:57

“Catastrophically, the operating theatre he worked in at times could be described as a slaughterhouse, which killed through incompetence and negligence, whilst not giving a damn for accountability.”

"Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay asked Mr Swinney if he had any concerns about going to ARI for surgery himself.
Mr Swinney replied: “I wouldn’t have concerns because we have clinical professionals who are undertaking good work in the NHS across the country.
“I think we should have confidence in them to undertake their roles and I would encourage people to be confident in the delivery of NHS services in Scotland, and specifically in NHS Grampian.""

OP posts:
RaraRachael · Yesterday 11:17

My daughter works there and is leaving soon due to the stress of being one of the few competent people in her department and having extra work piled on her as a result.
This is in a department which can very easily turn into a life or death situation.

EvelynBeatrice · Yesterday 11:31

It’s terrifying. I know another whistleblower who has not worked again due to managerial malice. He also tells of criminal breaches of the so-called duty of candour.

I think it’s getting to the stage that we need to record all interactions with medical professionals and film every surgery!

EvelynBeatrice · Yesterday 11:33

And I’m furious with Swinney. If he wasn’t told then those who were and didn’t pass it on need disciplining or sacked. If kids being put at risk and countrymen and women dying aren’t his priority, what is? He’ll be fine of course. The first minister is likely to receive reasonable medical treatment.

TheExcitersBlowingUpMyMindNSoul · Yesterday 12:19

RaraRachael · Yesterday 11:17

My daughter works there and is leaving soon due to the stress of being one of the few competent people in her department and having extra work piled on her as a result.
This is in a department which can very easily turn into a life or death situation.

Thats awful that your daughter is having her hand forced due to poor practices and conditions.

Ohitsnicehere · Yesterday 12:27

I’d like to say I’’m surprised but I’m not really, I think there is more to come out about ARI.

Stormontadvisor · Yesterday 12:42

RaraRachael · Yesterday 11:17

My daughter works there and is leaving soon due to the stress of being one of the few competent people in her department and having extra work piled on her as a result.
This is in a department which can very easily turn into a life or death situation.

Do you have any idea of why there is so much incompetence? What the causes are?

OP posts:
Stormontadvisor · Yesterday 12:44

The arrogance and sense of there being no accountability is an interesting one. Does it mean that the clinical staff feel protected by senior management and that senior management feels protected by the Scottish Government (higher echelons of the SNP)?

OP posts:
EvelynBeatrice · Yesterday 14:21

Stormontadvisor · Yesterday 12:44

The arrogance and sense of there being no accountability is an interesting one. Does it mean that the clinical staff feel protected by senior management and that senior management feels protected by the Scottish Government (higher echelons of the SNP)?

It’s worse. The effective nationalisation of the Scottish police and alleged politicisation of the prosecution service ( e.g. strange delays in the whole Sturgeon/ Murrell / SNP finances investigation and reporting) doesn’t lead one to have confidence that there would ever be any criminal investigation or sanction.

I suspect that there’s a toxic culture at the hospital and that those who are not themselves toxic go along with it or lose their jobs. It only takes a certain number of bad actors in authority before the balance tips and professionalism and decency come way below reputation and convenience.

RaraRachael · Yesterday 15:07

Stormontadvisor · Yesterday 12:42

Do you have any idea of why there is so much incompetence? What the causes are?

They are basically so desperate for staff. It used to be that you had to have at least 2 years' experience to work in this department but now they've got newly qualified nurses who just don't know what to do. Lots of nurses from abroad but quite honestly if it wasn't for them, the place couldn't function.

Also Dr Gray's in Elgin is in a pretty dire situation so they get a lot of patients who should be treated there, which just adds to the stress.

RhannionKPSS · Yesterday 15:26

Remember this scandal and all the others at the next election, and the council elections next May

seahorsessky · Yesterday 15:35

Why do we put up with this? A friend from a different country said that after waiting in AE (not in Aberdeen, but UK) said we have a real cheek to call another other country third-world.

Stormontadvisor · Yesterday 18:33

EvelynBeatrice · Yesterday 14:21

It’s worse. The effective nationalisation of the Scottish police and alleged politicisation of the prosecution service ( e.g. strange delays in the whole Sturgeon/ Murrell / SNP finances investigation and reporting) doesn’t lead one to have confidence that there would ever be any criminal investigation or sanction.

I suspect that there’s a toxic culture at the hospital and that those who are not themselves toxic go along with it or lose their jobs. It only takes a certain number of bad actors in authority before the balance tips and professionalism and decency come way below reputation and convenience.

Patients and families need to sue. But it seems that there's a lot of lying and hiding of evidence going on. And patients and families need to complain to the professional bodies. And more people need to whistleblow. I get that it's extremely difficult, but how can you have a professional job in healthcare and do nothing when you see patients dying unnecessarily, due to incompetence?

OP posts:
EvelynBeatrice · Yesterday 18:48

Stormontadvisor · Yesterday 18:33

Patients and families need to sue. But it seems that there's a lot of lying and hiding of evidence going on. And patients and families need to complain to the professional bodies. And more people need to whistleblow. I get that it's extremely difficult, but how can you have a professional job in healthcare and do nothing when you see patients dying unnecessarily, due to incompetence?

The NHS destroys evidence in a completely shameless way! Sadly, all you can do is get your own evidence. Copy all records, record everything, have an independent witness … ask every single nurse and doctor’s name and title - write everything down.

EvelynBeatrice · Yesterday 18:54

seahorsessky · Yesterday 15:35

Why do we put up with this? A friend from a different country said that after waiting in AE (not in Aberdeen, but UK) said we have a real cheek to call another other country third-world.

Yup. I’m amazed that other European countries don’t advise against travel here on the basis that it’s anyone ‘s guess if you ‘ll get treated in time in an emergency. People need to wake up. Yes the wealthier can always buy private care, but that won’t help them in an emergency when we all rely on the NHS. Im not aware of any private A & Es though I suppose there may be some in London.

Sulainthesky · Yesterday 19:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Stormontadvisor · Yesterday 19:49

British people are very lethargic. It takes an awful lot to get us to go out and protest about things. We just seem to put up with everything. And you can multiply that by a hundred in Scotland, because the only thing that matters to lots of people come election time is Indy. I think these politicians are laughing at us behind our backs, knowing that they can get away with anything.

People are discussing this Aberdeen scandal on Facebook. Someone complained that discussing it was making Scotland look bad...

OP posts:
WearyAuldWumman · Yesterday 21:06

Someone complained that discussing it was making Scotland look bad...

That is the kind of thinking that exists in despotic regimes. I hope someone told them that.

I'll add that I'm pro-Indy, but left the SNP because of the arse that they've made of so many things.

Sulainthesky · Yesterday 21:21

You see it on social media all the time. Some people go to the ends of the earth to defend the SNPs indefensible acts. It’s appalling.

Cazziebo · Yesterday 21:46

I’m watching this with interest. My late sister was the victim of medical negligence at ARI. Intensive care unit was manky - blood on the walls, no soap or sanitiser in dispensers, the staff told me they bought soap and shampoo themselves as there were never any supplies. Following the incident the medical staff urged us to sue the hospital, who agreed to settle immediately. She had PTSD from 3 weeks in an induced coma, mobility issues from the negligence and then developed a life limiting condition that couldn’t be proved beyond doubt to be related to the negligence.

We/I should have fought harder. Supporting a relative who is a completely changed person because of such an awful experience, and supporting that relative’s children who no longer have a mother they recognise, takes so much energy and brain space it is difficult to find the time to also fight the system. Interestingly, the surgeon involved was retired for medical reasons very soon after the “incident” and in later appointments we often found ourselves in the same waiting room as other patients of the “retired” surgeon who developed related complications.

The sick are an easy group to exploit.

MrsAmaretto · Yesterday 22:00

Between this and the HIS inspection report, I’m amazed the UK press isn’t all over NHS Grampian? Then you have whatever is going on with the massive overspend and delays at the Baird Family Centre?

I’ve four family members working in Grampian and they say the rumours of bullying by the CEO downward is also an issue. No point whistleblowers going to INWO either, they don’t do anything.

Ultimately all NHS Scotland boards are micromanaged by the Scottish Government and there is no independent regulation. Scottish Gov representatives sit on every recruitment panel of every executive director. The Scottish government is running the NHS into the ground and not holding directors and boards accountable.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread