Please or to access all these features

Scotsnet

Welcome to Scotsnet - discuss all aspects of life in Scotland, including relocating, schools and local areas.

Scotland's buses to be brought back into public control.

32 replies

Needacalminginfluence · 17/10/2026 20:42

I've just seen John Swinney's announcement about this.
I'm a non car owner and rely on buses. I live in an area where Stagecoach currently have the monopoly. In the 10 years I've lived in the town the service has deteriorated substantially in frequency. And the buses ability to run to the scheduled timetabled time is often farcical. For a town the size of the one I live in the service is totally inadequate.
I just hope bringing the buses back into public control improves things.

OP posts:
Needacalminginfluence · 22/10/2026 17:54

Well @User58291 and @Terrribletwos I don't think the Scottish Government has the monoply on messing things up and wasting money by any stretch of the imagination. It's an accusation that can can be pointed , not only at most governments, but most organisations in every walk of life
And when it comes down to it I trust the Scottish Government with bus passengers best interests a damn sight more than individual bus companies driven only by the profit motive.

I'm glad the Government is at last making the right noises about bus provision and i hope it translates into an improvement. Because things are pretty dire atm. And i'm certainly giving the Government chance to see what they can do in the matter.

OP posts:
User58291 · 22/10/2026 18:55

Well, @Needacalminginfluence . I'm very keen for the buses to improve, as my DC and I use the buses and we're in a crap bus area, as I mentioned. You're right that the Scottish Government doesn't have a monopoly on messing things up. But many other organisations manage not to mess absolutely everything up, and would in fact have to shut down if they did, with everyone losing their jobs. Scotgov seem to be extremely relaxed about throwing taxpayers' money away (fight in the courts to keep 2 violent murderers in the women's prison, which at a guess was not a high priority for Scottish people - just one example).

Let's hope they do better with the buses than with the ferries and the roads.

One question - does anyone know what research they did that led them to the decision to charge tourists less for a bus ticket than a Scottish resident is charged? When British people visit EU countries, we're charged massively more than EU citizens for museums and so on. Here, many of those things are free, and now non-Scots are getting subsidised bus tickets. Subsidised by us as taxpayers.

Needacalminginfluence · 22/10/2026 19:08

User58291 · 22/10/2026 18:55

Well, @Needacalminginfluence . I'm very keen for the buses to improve, as my DC and I use the buses and we're in a crap bus area, as I mentioned. You're right that the Scottish Government doesn't have a monopoly on messing things up. But many other organisations manage not to mess absolutely everything up, and would in fact have to shut down if they did, with everyone losing their jobs. Scotgov seem to be extremely relaxed about throwing taxpayers' money away (fight in the courts to keep 2 violent murderers in the women's prison, which at a guess was not a high priority for Scottish people - just one example).

Let's hope they do better with the buses than with the ferries and the roads.

One question - does anyone know what research they did that led them to the decision to charge tourists less for a bus ticket than a Scottish resident is charged? When British people visit EU countries, we're charged massively more than EU citizens for museums and so on. Here, many of those things are free, and now non-Scots are getting subsidised bus tickets. Subsidised by us as taxpayers.

They arent proposing to charge tourists less.
I'm in an area that already has the £2 cap and the drivers don't differentiate between tourists and residents! As I understand it the £2 cap is to be expanded to all areas and it will apply to tourists and residents alike.

I do agree that the Ferries issue has been absolutely dreadful.

OP posts:
Lovingapeacefulgarden · 25/10/2026 09:13

My local council bought buses and took over a lot of local routes and school buses a few years ago. Its a far better service. Stagecoach used to run services in my area which rarely turned up. Eventually they stopped the service for that area due to lack of use (nobody could use it because it wss so unreliable). The council took.over the service and its reliable and now well used. The council are making a profit on theae routes and reinvesting the money whilst locals now have a reliable service so its a win win.

User58291 · 25/10/2026 11:53

Lovingapeacefulgarden · 25/10/2026 09:13

My local council bought buses and took over a lot of local routes and school buses a few years ago. Its a far better service. Stagecoach used to run services in my area which rarely turned up. Eventually they stopped the service for that area due to lack of use (nobody could use it because it wss so unreliable). The council took.over the service and its reliable and now well used. The council are making a profit on theae routes and reinvesting the money whilst locals now have a reliable service so its a win win.

That sounds great - here's hoping that happens in our area. It's not rocket science that if buses often don't turn up people are going to stop using them. That may mean that they've had to give up a job, or not accept a job opportunity. It's all about reliability and sensible scheduling.

Needacalminginfluence · 25/10/2026 14:07

That's a really positive story @Lovingapeacefulgarden
Is that down in the Borders? I remember reading about the council intervening there to save bus routes. I see Highland Council has also bought at least one route from Stagecoach.

OP posts:
Lovingapeacefulgarden · 25/10/2026 14:48

Needacalminginfluence · 25/10/2026 14:07

That's a really positive story @Lovingapeacefulgarden
Is that down in the Borders? I remember reading about the council intervening there to save bus routes. I see Highland Council has also bought at least one route from Stagecoach.

Its Highland council region. They have expanded the services all over the city and now run school services. Its so much better. I would never have used a bus before but do now

New posts on this thread. Refresh page