Please or to access all these features

Scotsnet

Welcome to Scotsnet - discuss all aspects of life in Scotland, including relocating, schools and local areas.

The "independence pact"

260 replies

Sunnnyday · 15/09/2026 23:09

I'm surprised no-one's started a thread on this, so here goes. The leaders of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have signed a Joint Memorandum of Understanding and have called on the UK Government to start preparing for constitutional change.
Listening to the BBC on this, there is currently no majority in favour of splitting from the UK in any of the devolved nations, though Scotland is closer to it than the other two. It's a matter of those who are currently in government being in favour, rather than their populations being in favour. So is this no more than a publicity stunt?
And should any referendum on such a huge issue, which, regardless of your viewpoint, will cause enormous contention, upheaval and disruption over many years, be on a majority vote basis? Have we learnt anything from Brexit?
I'm also confused as to why the leaders of Scotland and Wales are apparently confident that their countries would be swiftly welcomed into the EU, and how they would manage a hard border with England.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
celticnations · 04/11/2026 15:08

@Murley Unless the energy companies are nationalised 😉

Murley · 04/11/2026 15:08

celticnations · 04/11/2026 14:58

The Union as it is does not work. Only London & the SE profit. Think Hunger Games & the Districts feeding The Capitol (sic).

That is why Westminster under Burnham is finally having coffee put under the noses to wake up to that fact.

Devolution is here for good. And there will never be a Conservative, LibDem, Green or Reform FM. Only SNP or Labour. So the drive for more devolution is strong.

What are you on about? The SE and London are the ONLY areas of the UK that earn more in taxes than they spend. Scotland as part of the UK massively benefits from the redistribution of this wealth to us and other regions, to us via the Barnett formula. We would be far poorer if we left the UK. London and the SE lose massively from being part of the UK.

So the exact OPPOSITE of what you say is true.

Murley · 04/11/2026 15:12

celticnations · 04/11/2026 15:08

@Murley Unless the energy companies are nationalised 😉

Edited

How are you planning to fund that?

celticnations · 04/11/2026 15:27

Murley · 04/11/2026 15:12

How are you planning to fund that?

A feasible but contentious route is compulsary purchase. The legal wrangling would be hideous but...

Bonds & Debt Issuance.

Wealth Fund eg new & existing oil & gas stream revenues.

Loans.

Holyrood could follow the Irish after their War of Independence from Britain ie the Shannon scheme sort of thing.

It is the infrastructure that is costly (90 billion?), the customer facing architecture is not (sub-1 billion).

Moot point really as Westminster also holds energy as a "reserved matter". Of course it would 🙄

Smokeywater · 04/11/2026 15:34

Murley · 04/11/2026 15:05

Which areas of high tourism traffic in Scotland are covered in windfarms? I can’t think of many. Scotland is a great place to build onshore windfarms as it’s windier than England and we have large tracts of land of low intensity use. Offshore windfarm licences earn the Scottish government a fair bit of money. Windfarms bring jobs to Scotland and help boost their green credentials.

But no the electricity generated does not belong to the Scottish government so they won’t be selling any to rUK!

I'm in the SW zero industry except tourism - dozens of colossal wind turbines and it might be acceptable if there weren' hundreds of more applications to build them in the pipeline. Perthshire had huge pylons built across avery beautiful area which attracts many tourists. But who cares - it's the central belt that has the SNP MSPs so we don't count. A bit like England where all that really matters is the SE.
And they don't bring in jobs - once they are built (the last builders in the region were Portuguese) there's no jobs. Likewise PV panels - built then that's it - unless maybe windowcleaners???

Murley · 04/11/2026 15:47

celticnations · 04/11/2026 15:27

A feasible but contentious route is compulsary purchase. The legal wrangling would be hideous but...

Bonds & Debt Issuance.

Wealth Fund eg new & existing oil & gas stream revenues.

Loans.

Holyrood could follow the Irish after their War of Independence from Britain ie the Shannon scheme sort of thing.

It is the infrastructure that is costly (90 billion?), the customer facing architecture is not (sub-1 billion).

Moot point really as Westminster also holds energy as a "reserved matter". Of course it would 🙄

So Scotland has a deficit of about 12% currently. It’s proposing Indy which will immediately cut its funding by 10-15%. It’s putting a border up with the market it sends 60% of its exports to and it’s trying to fund the reserves of a new central bank and yet you think anyone on the planet would lend to them?

And why would Scotland bankrupt itself trying to do this? It makes no sense. England can quite happily access cheaper energy from the continent.

I’m no fan of the prospect of an independent Scotland, but the Scottish government doesn’t seem to be either. We hear not a word from them about how they think they can make Indy work, and leave Tim Rideout and his batshit bonkers currency ideas to take the stage, making the idea of Indy look farcically stupid. I wish the Scottish government would admit there are no sunlit uplands in a post Indy Scotland and get on with dealing with the real issues facing Scotland, affecting all of our lives like education and healthcare, both of which are in a diabolical state and no one seems to want to deal with.

celticnations · 04/11/2026 15:48

Under the current devolution framework, control over electricity, gas, and oil markets is reserved exclusively to the UK Parliament in Westminster. However, upon achieving full independence, the Scottish Parliament would inherit all sovereign legislative powers, enabling it to pass its own laws to forcibly buy out corporate assets, infrastructure, or supply lines.

Wow. I did not know that that could be done tbh. Thought that it was pure theory.

Westminster forcibly took over multitudes of private companies engaged in coal, electricity & gas (?) apparantly between 1946-8. Clement Atlee instigated it.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 04/11/2026 15:49

Murley · 04/11/2026 15:08

What are you on about? The SE and London are the ONLY areas of the UK that earn more in taxes than they spend. Scotland as part of the UK massively benefits from the redistribution of this wealth to us and other regions, to us via the Barnett formula. We would be far poorer if we left the UK. London and the SE lose massively from being part of the UK.

So the exact OPPOSITE of what you say is true.

London benefits from the UK in much the same way Edinburgh benefits from being a hub within Scotland itself.

It's true that London and SE England are the two most productive and prosperous "regions" of the UK, but they only do that because they are hubs within the UK itself. It's entirely wrong to imply that the UK is "propped up" by them, because the reality is more that they are focal points for the wealth produced by the UK as a whole, and hence where the UK's wealth is focussed.

Similarly, Scotland is the third most productive "region" beside London and SE, so if you want to make the argument that London and the SE "subsidise" the UK, then the same is true of Scotland, in that as the third most productive region it "subsidises" every single other part of the UK which is not London and the SE of England.

We would be far poorer if we left the UK

Well no. We'd be far poorer if we left the UK and everything else, including spending and government priorities, remained exactly as they are right now with Scotland still being part of the UK, but this isn't necessarily what Scotland becoming independent means, even though pro-Union positions invariably imply it is.

It really makes you question how such a resource-rich country can be mismanaged for so long that "you'd never cope on your own" is suggested with a straight face for maintaining the status quo, i.e. sticking with the long-term mismanagement which caused this apparent predicament in the first place.

celticnations · 04/11/2026 15:50

NI is doing very well out of her EU UK border. One foot in each camp.

Went back a month ago - place is bustling!

Smokeywater · 04/11/2026 15:53

That's probably because Ireland is booming

celticnations · 04/11/2026 16:15

@Smokeywater Just checked - "frictionless trade has supercharged agri-business eg dairy" plus no barriers to goods movement.

An independent Scotland would have a 96 mile land border with England, true but, a big but there are only 3 major routes north-south. 'Twixt Carlisle & Berwick there's only the A68(?).

Easier to monitor.

celticnations · 04/11/2026 16:25

@Murley The UK is classed internationally as being the single most "hypercentralised" western country. To the economic detriment & political disenfranchise of all areas outwith London & the SE.

This has to an extent been an accident of history (eg Londinium) but also monarchical design & political will.

Forget politics for the moment. Everyone in the UK should have the same opportunities & empowerment but they do not. I agree that the Central Belt has emulated Westminster & the SE and that is not good.

An American political commentator this morning on BBC Radio Scotland made a good point re individuals, businesses & towns should reach out to their international equivalents and trade. Forget relying on the big centres & big politics.

Murley · 05/11/2026 12:48

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 04/11/2026 15:49

London benefits from the UK in much the same way Edinburgh benefits from being a hub within Scotland itself.

It's true that London and SE England are the two most productive and prosperous "regions" of the UK, but they only do that because they are hubs within the UK itself. It's entirely wrong to imply that the UK is "propped up" by them, because the reality is more that they are focal points for the wealth produced by the UK as a whole, and hence where the UK's wealth is focussed.

Similarly, Scotland is the third most productive "region" beside London and SE, so if you want to make the argument that London and the SE "subsidise" the UK, then the same is true of Scotland, in that as the third most productive region it "subsidises" every single other part of the UK which is not London and the SE of England.

We would be far poorer if we left the UK

Well no. We'd be far poorer if we left the UK and everything else, including spending and government priorities, remained exactly as they are right now with Scotland still being part of the UK, but this isn't necessarily what Scotland becoming independent means, even though pro-Union positions invariably imply it is.

It really makes you question how such a resource-rich country can be mismanaged for so long that "you'd never cope on your own" is suggested with a straight face for maintaining the status quo, i.e. sticking with the long-term mismanagement which caused this apparent predicament in the first place.

London and the SE make so much money because of the City of London being in it. It’s a vast tax generator. They are the ONLY regions that earns more in tax than they spend. So Scotland currently ‘makes a loss’ - spends more than it earns. What would Indy Scotland do to combat that? How would they do things differently if they had powers over every single policy? How would this make living in Indy Scotland a good thing?

We don’t hear anything like this. No projections, ideas, plans, financial estimate. Nothing. And that’s why the majority remain to be convinced that Indy it the answer.

celticnations · 05/11/2026 20:27

@Murley True.

But neither is maintaining the "Union" the answer.

Murley · 05/11/2026 20:52

celticnations · 05/11/2026 20:27

@Murley True.

But neither is maintaining the "Union" the answer.

Why not? Scotland would be a MUCH poorer nation if it left. MUCH poorer.

Smokeywater · 06/11/2026 07:12

There are fewer people of working age on out of work benefits in the rest of the country than in London - believe it or not - so London might be paying most of the tax via it's financial services but it is also taking a big whack of the benefits - excusable if you were a rural area but London???

celticnations · 06/11/2026 20:00

Murley · 05/11/2026 20:52

Why not? Scotland would be a MUCH poorer nation if it left. MUCH poorer.

The Union no longer works hence the drive by Burnham to extend power locally. And yes, that includes the SNP devolving & not centralising.

Leadership #101: Delegate.

Let Westminster deal with macro issues like War & Sanctions.

Let us Celts & English cities deal with trade & investment.

Murley · 07/11/2026 08:45

celticnations · 06/11/2026 20:00

The Union no longer works hence the drive by Burnham to extend power locally. And yes, that includes the SNP devolving & not centralising.

Leadership #101: Delegate.

Let Westminster deal with macro issues like War & Sanctions.

Let us Celts & English cities deal with trade & investment.

But the SNP MSPs are - I hate to say it - shit. There isn’t a braincell to rub between them. They’re all total morons. Take that woman who was in charge of transport who didn’t understand that Transport Scotland was a government department. Thick as mince. Take Jenny Gilruth. Angry as much as she’s devoid of intelligent opinion. And she’s finance minister! And her predecessor thought FFA would be a good idea. How thick can you get????

Each and every one of the posters on this board has more intelligence than the average SNP MSP. Why would we want to give them more money? why? They’re total melts. They never do ANYTHING to change Scotland for the better. They’re totally incapable of doing anything. None of them have ever run a business or worked in finance. None of them have ever invested anything. And yet you think they should be given powers of trade and investment? Sheesh!

THATS that problem with Scotland today

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 07/11/2026 18:33

Murley · 07/11/2026 08:45

But the SNP MSPs are - I hate to say it - shit. There isn’t a braincell to rub between them. They’re all total morons. Take that woman who was in charge of transport who didn’t understand that Transport Scotland was a government department. Thick as mince. Take Jenny Gilruth. Angry as much as she’s devoid of intelligent opinion. And she’s finance minister! And her predecessor thought FFA would be a good idea. How thick can you get????

Each and every one of the posters on this board has more intelligence than the average SNP MSP. Why would we want to give them more money? why? They’re total melts. They never do ANYTHING to change Scotland for the better. They’re totally incapable of doing anything. None of them have ever run a business or worked in finance. None of them have ever invested anything. And yet you think they should be given powers of trade and investment? Sheesh!

THATS that problem with Scotland today

👏 👏

Shit is being kind.

celticnations · 08/11/2026 13:17

I think a fair few politicians are "thick as mince".

Boris Johnson
Liz Truss
Nigel Farage
Les Neanderthal
Ben Habib
Richard Tice
Sammy Wilson

In fact most of the Covid-era Conservative & Unionist Party, UKIP, Reform & the DUP.

IQ of a flip flop.

Sunnnyday · 08/11/2026 13:42

Smokeywater · 04/11/2026 15:34

I'm in the SW zero industry except tourism - dozens of colossal wind turbines and it might be acceptable if there weren' hundreds of more applications to build them in the pipeline. Perthshire had huge pylons built across avery beautiful area which attracts many tourists. But who cares - it's the central belt that has the SNP MSPs so we don't count. A bit like England where all that really matters is the SE.
And they don't bring in jobs - once they are built (the last builders in the region were Portuguese) there's no jobs. Likewise PV panels - built then that's it - unless maybe windowcleaners???

The Scottish government can't even be bothered to issue the national planning guidance it promised to local councils, to assist them in making planning decisions about AI data centres.
It's allowing big American business to take over Scottish land to build huge data centres, which will use vast amounts of electricity. They will not run only on recycled energy, and will no doubt have aggressive contracts which give them priority when electricity is in short supply. So Scottish citizens can expect power cuts and increased electricity bills. Just the one very large (almost the biggest in the world) AI data centre planned for the south of Scotland will use as much electricity as 2 million houses, apparently.
We won't have enough electricity to sell it to England. We won't have enough electricity for our own people.
Scottish politicians don't have the will or the ability to deal with companies like Google. They will eat us for breakfast, and we will never be able to get rid of them.

OP posts:
Murley · 08/11/2026 16:01

I think we need to ask why so few intelligent people want to become MSPs. Apologies, SNP or Green MSPs. Surely there are intelligent nationalists out there? I challenge anyone to come up with an example of any nationalist politician showing any intelligence. Take this weekend. John Swinney has spoken out - after Labour suggested no more licences for oil should be granted in the North Sea - to voice his outrage at this. Despite the SNP all voting against drilling in the North Sea this is September. Do they think we are complete idiots? YES!

EricTheHalfASleeve · 08/11/2026 16:17

Yet apparently if Scottish independence occurs we will magically have new, different, better politicians, not just more SNP eejits.
Presumably they are being specially breed in the bowels of Holyrood, like Sauron's orks.

Murley · 08/11/2026 21:05

celticnations · 08/11/2026 13:17

I think a fair few politicians are "thick as mince".

Boris Johnson
Liz Truss
Nigel Farage
Les Neanderthal
Ben Habib
Richard Tice
Sammy Wilson

In fact most of the Covid-era Conservative & Unionist Party, UKIP, Reform & the DUP.

IQ of a flip flop.

Agree. Matt Hancock ffs! Matt Hancock! Liz Truss was embarrassing too, clearly just put up so that financiers could tell her and Kwazi what they wanted their budget to be, they make a killing and the lettuce woman is ridiculed for ever more. Then we have David Lammy who thinks trans women can grow a cervix, and that god awful Zara Sultana who talks of nothing but Gaza, Samantha Niblett who is a total idiot and Jeremy Corbyn the terrorist sympathiser.

But the SNP (and Greens) have no redeeming MSP or MPs whatsoever. None of them are in any way intelligent. And that would be fine if they got things done, but they hand all of our taxes out in freebies to the workshy and unwarranted pay rises and sit back and watch public services fail. And people are daft enough to vote for them because they claim to be working towards Indy, and they do nothing. Nothing at all, apart from daft stunts like this ‘pact’ which means nothing and changes nothing. And the needle returns to the start of the song and we all sing along like before…

Murley · 08/11/2026 21:09

EricTheHalfASleeve · 08/11/2026 16:17

Yet apparently if Scottish independence occurs we will magically have new, different, better politicians, not just more SNP eejits.
Presumably they are being specially breed in the bowels of Holyrood, like Sauron's orks.

Why would any one of any party of any intelligence look at the economic and social wasteland that Indy Scotland would leave trailing in its wake and think of getting involved? They’d get the heck out to a country that could afford to have functioning public services. They’d leave the SNP to sort out their own mess. They made their bed, they can lie in it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread