Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Breach of court due to child disclosing at school.

8 replies

theseyounglions · Today 18:16

Hi all,
my nine-year-old son came home from school yesterday early he was due to be with his dad this weekend arrangement is court ordered. He disclosed at school that his dad punched him in the chest 4 to 5 times in October half term school obviously got in touch with social care social care are happy that he was looked after well with me immediate risk was eradicated. Dad has been informed and obviously didn’t see him this weekend. I have to make an application to court on Monday. I’m going to use a solicitor. One of this is a really dark question to ask but has anyone experienced this before? It clearly is child abuse. His dad is definitely very emotionally abusive. He really hates seeing his dad he is a massive bully. That was the reason we left him nearly 7 years ago.
has anyone got any idea of what will happen now? It all went through cafcass before. My son has gone full circle he’s hated going to see him for years but now he absolutely doesn’t want to even speak to me on the phone which I completely understand. Not that he was ever that keen. I had to make him. I can see his stomach drop when his dad calls. I understand the manipulation he’s capable of.
Can anybody advise what might happen here if I had a magic wand he wouldn’t see him again because he hates it. He cries on the morning in the evening before he has to go.
It is of course with the authorities now we are waiting for the police to come round to speak to both of us. I’m pretty sure I lost faith in most of the system but obviously need to have faith in the system. I feel like it probably would be best if he didn’t see him anymore, but I know that that doesn’t happen and he has rights to see his son. I think he might be arrested. When legally you have to force a child to see their dad it’s hard enough but surely after this something will change? I’m tired of forcing him to go, is it likely that they ignore this and just still force the court order? The protectiveness is really starting to kick in, especially when he was deemed safe by the court years ago.
His father is obviously really panicking, but it’s not really my place to make him feel better. He’s even given me his girlfriend’s phone number and where she lives, which is very much the last straw for him. I don’t know. I just wondered if I could have any advice here if anyone has experienced anything like this thank you and have a great weekend.

OP posts:
Boreded · Today 18:21

Really sorry you are going through all of this.

Personally, given the safeguarding concerns and the fact that the police and social services are now involved, I would withhold contact pending urgent legal advice and an application to vary the court order.

There is a reasonable excuse defence for breaching a Child Arrangements Order, and protecting a child from a credible risk of physical abuse could certainly be relevant.

I’d also make sure your son understands that he can express his own wishes and feelings. Give him access to the internet and let him look up things like “what can I do if I don’t want to see my dad?” so he understands that his voice matters and that he can speak to professionals about how he feels.

At nine, he doesn’t have an absolute legal right to refuse contact, but nobody should be physically forcing a frightened child to go. His wishes, his distress and the reasons behind them are all relevant to the court’s decision.

Most importantly, don’t assume his father has an automatic right to see him regardless of what has happened. He doesn’t. Your son’s welfare comes first.

theseyounglions · Today 18:28

Thank you for your reply. I think he will use his voice, it’s so hard he says things like “what’s going to happen to my dad”. Hopefully he does use his voice. I’m just so worried about the court saying he still has to go. It’s madness. I think I have to speak to social care on Monday too, or maybe just wait seeing as their advise was to apply to court. Can’t believe we are here again. Waiting for the gods on high to direct us.

OP posts:
daffodilandtulip · Today 19:13

My children were physically hurt during contact. Court said I made it up, cited parental alienation and threatened to remove the children if I kept reporting things.

WaveyGodshawk · Today 19:32

Your poor son, I'm so sorry you're going through this.
I'm not in UK so don't know how helpful my experience would be. But I can really relate to how you're feeling, and I hope that the courts recognise the harm being caused to your son by contact with his father. Definitely use a solicitor and also maybe contact Women's Aid, they were so helpful to me even though it was my dc experiencing the brunt of the abuse through contact.
Good luck Flowers

Boreded · Today 20:08

daffodilandtulip · Today 19:13

My children were physically hurt during contact. Court said I made it up, cited parental alienation and threatened to remove the children if I kept reporting things.

But so as not to scare OP, it is clear that this is true as the son disclosed to school and has visible, observable reactions to his dad and anything related to him.

Boreded · Today 20:23

theseyounglions · Today 18:28

Thank you for your reply. I think he will use his voice, it’s so hard he says things like “what’s going to happen to my dad”. Hopefully he does use his voice. I’m just so worried about the court saying he still has to go. It’s madness. I think I have to speak to social care on Monday too, or maybe just wait seeing as their advise was to apply to court. Can’t believe we are here again. Waiting for the gods on high to direct us.

I know it’s not technically ok to tell your child how to avoid going to his dads, and I will maybe get flamed for it, but ultimately your son’s safety is more important…so I’m going to say it anyway.

He needs to say:

My dad has punched me in the chest before. I am frightened he will hurt me again today. I am not safe going with him. I am refusing to leave with him. Please call the police because I believe I am in immediate danger. Please don't leave me alone with him.

Pumpkinsaregrowingnicely · Today 20:27

If your ds hasn't got a mobile phone he needs one now.
IF he has to go he needs to be able to ring you. Stash a tenner if he needs get an Uber to get home.

whippersnapper55 · Today 20:44

Did your son disclose this to his teacher? I would gather as much evidence as you can & stop any contact, including phone calls until you have spoken to the police and sought legal advice. Your son is clearly not safe with his father.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread