Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Am I a crazy wife?

208 replies

Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 11:56

My DH was filling me in on his day - he mentioned a new co-worker (they are both new to the job) he has mentioned this person a few times. More than anyone else if I'm honest, without needing prompting. I looked her up on social media. I not going to lie, I was a bit peeved off that she wasn't ugly lol ..I know - I shouldn't have!

I asked him if she was good looking and he said no! But having viewed her profile I wasn't convinced. I'm not jealous that another human being is good looking/attractive etc if he had of said meh she's not ugly I would have left it there.

What annoyed me was when I kept probing for answers he replied "she's above average' then he said he would score her a 6/10.

I'm definitely not saying my DH is going to or would ever cheat on me but I'm feeling a little bit jealous! Am I justified or just mad?

OP posts:
Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 12:52

MerryAquaKoala · Yesterday 12:48

No. You’re not ‘ridiculous’ or ‘mad’ or ‘crazy’ or ‘silly’ or ‘a mug’ or ‘childish’ any of the other things nasty posters have written on this thread. One incoherent particularly nasty poster even says ‘they’d run a mile from you’. Don’t listen to them. Key board warriors. We’re all human, don’t worry about it. Hopefully he’ll stop waffling about her then you can both carry on as you were. Trust your gut though - spidey senses don’t lie x

Edited

In this case they really didn't lie... Thank you for such a lovely response. Just annoyed he didn't admit it freely that's all

OP posts:
Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 12:55

KnickerlessParsons · Yesterday 12:12

You're being ridiculous - you can't vet every woman your DH interacts with at work.

I work in a heavily male dominated sphere - DH has never once asked me if I find any of the men attractive.

If he did ask you was someone was attractive, would you lie and say no or would you be honest and simply say... They're a good looking person. Imp that doesn't mean you're wanting to cheat or have a wondering eye. We're able to tell if someone is well put together or not and it definitely doesn't mean you would cheat or your partner would think you would cheat

OP posts:
Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 12:58

Firesidechatter · Yesterday 12:11

There is no way you'd have accepted him saying she was above average . You struggle with jealousy and insecurity . Your behaviour isn't ok. Get help

He did say she was above average.... That isn't the issue. My issue is he was honest in the first place and it's something we can normally speak freely about.

OP posts:
GarlicNothing · Yesterday 12:59

he has mentioned this person a few times. More than anyone else if I'm honest

Slightly odd replies, imo. Mentionitis is a thing, and so is instinct - if instinct is the subconscious application of many barely-noticed cues. Husbands very rarely find unattractive colleagues living rent-free in their heads; it's always a 'very nice' woman who happens to be physically appealing. You aren't wrong or mad to have observed this development.

That said, there isn't much you can do about it. Perhaps Ms Mentioned is an especially interesting, entertaining or skilled team member. Or perhaps he's got a bit of a crush.

You probably should start to worry when he stops mentioning her at all, while spending more time away from home and/or putting more effort into his appearance. Unless that happens, assume it's just that her arrival's a welcome change to the daily monotony - and change the subject whenever her name comes up.

Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 12:59

Autumnishere1 · Yesterday 12:25

This sounds really childish, rating people on their attractiveness out of 10 🙄. It sounds insecure to look them up to be honest

I didn't rate anyone out of 10

OP posts:
Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 13:03

ImOnlyMakingPlansForNigel · Yesterday 12:21

So after asking him the first time if he thought she was attractive, he said yeah, actually she’s def above average… you then would have said ok, great to know, what’s for dinner? Conversation closed.

The guy is in a no-win situation and you’ve pushed and pushed to get something from him.

If you trust him, there’s no woman that could start working with him that you would be concerned about.

is she good looking?
I suppose so but I don't care
Ok what's for dinner

Reasonable enough

I can never take out against my DH for someone else being good looking.. but I can have an expectation of complete honesty

OP posts:
Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 13:06

Parky04 · Yesterday 12:27

If he answered "yes, she is very attractive". What would you have said then? Probably "more attractive than me?". Whatever his answer was, it would have been wrong! You have insecuritie issues!

He didn't say she was very attractive, he said she was above average. I don't think he thinks she's very attractive but I am annoyed he gave me two different answers - which was my issue...

OP posts:
VimesandhisCardboardBoots · Yesterday 13:06

Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 13:03

is she good looking?
I suppose so but I don't care
Ok what's for dinner

Reasonable enough

I can never take out against my DH for someone else being good looking.. but I can have an expectation of complete honesty

but I can have an expectation of complete honesty

Again, I ask the question, why?

He doesn't have to tell you absolutely everything that goes on in his head. It's none of your business whether he finds someone else attractive or not. It's frankly none of your business.

The only thing that matters is whether or not he's faithful to you. Anything beyond that is part of his own private mental life, and you're not entitled to know the truth.

Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 13:08

dontwanna123 · Yesterday 12:36

Really childish and insecure. Does your dp ask you about every man you interact with.

You've completely missed my point. This isn't about interacting with people ... It was going back on what he said... Not being honest in the first place.

OP posts:
JohnnyMcGrathSaysFuckOff · Yesterday 13:09

Yeah but colleagues can stick out in your mind for lots of reasons. I am forthright and assertive at work. I have a leading voice in meetings.

I am quite sure none of my male colleagues find me attractive 😆

But they are likely to remember me as someone buzzy, warm etc.

If he mentioned her in connection with work, it's odd to me that you assume it's about attraction.

It's pretty obvious that his avoidant behaviour was because you were badgering him, looking her up etc.

Autumnishere1 · Yesterday 13:11

No but you kept probing for answers as you said and he came back with she is a 6/10 , which is what I meant sounds childish. You aren't crazy, that word is thrown around far too much,, but it does sound insecure if you have immediately started looking online to see what she looks like

Nighttimenoise · Yesterday 13:13

If he's got mentionitis then I would be a little bit wary but I wouldn't keep badgering him.

Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 13:13

ForTipsyFinch · Yesterday 12:41

I don’t think it’s unreasonable your curiosity pricked up if he’s mentioning her unprompted. But asking him to rate his colleague out of ten looks wise is pretty silly.

I DID NOT ask him to rate anybody.... That was him

OP posts:
TheLastSilverSaint · Yesterday 13:17

If he’d said ‘Yes, she’s beautiful’ we all know you would not have reacted well. You’re already stalking the poor woman on social media and quizzing him about her. You’re lying to yourself if you think you’d have been fine with it if he’d agreed she was good looking.

I feel sorry for your partner who was in a no-win situation. And if my boyfriend started looking up my male colleagues and quizzing me on how attractive they were, I would be running for the hills.

Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 13:17

VimesandhisCardboardBoots · Yesterday 12:51

Why are you owed an honest answer though?

Its a really stupid question to ask your partner, the only reason to ask him that is because you want to catch him out in some way or another. It's a fairly shitty thing to do to someone you supposedly love.

When you share your life with someone I think honesty is at the core of that! It's not always good, bad, pretty etc but its honest. Honesty is so important.

OP posts:
Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 13:19

Autumnishere1 · Yesterday 13:11

No but you kept probing for answers as you said and he came back with she is a 6/10 , which is what I meant sounds childish. You aren't crazy, that word is thrown around far too much,, but it does sound insecure if you have immediately started looking online to see what she looks like

Fair enough ... But I didn't ask for that! I'm just nosey, I did admit from the start that I shouldn't have but curiosity killed the cat

OP posts:
Hopefulsalmon · Yesterday 13:19

If a woman posted that her husband had acted like you the words controlling and coersive would have appeared in replies by now.

Shmee1988 · Yesterday 13:20

Have you considered that talking freely about James/Paula down the road being attractive is a bit different to saying it about someone you will be in close proximity with for 40 hours a week? Maybe he didnt lie to be dishonest, possibly just to protect you and your potential anxiety. Me and my partner could walk past someone in the street and he could say 'she is very pretty' for example and I wouldn't really be phased. I think I may feel just a tad different if he was saying it about someone he spent the majority of his week with. Do you see what I mean? You probed, you asked a silly question and got an answer you didnt like.

Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 13:21

TheLastSilverSaint · Yesterday 13:17

If he’d said ‘Yes, she’s beautiful’ we all know you would not have reacted well. You’re already stalking the poor woman on social media and quizzing him about her. You’re lying to yourself if you think you’d have been fine with it if he’d agreed she was good looking.

I feel sorry for your partner who was in a no-win situation. And if my boyfriend started looking up my male colleagues and quizzing me on how attractive they were, I would be running for the hills.

She is good looking - it's a fact! Why lie? That was my point

There is no problem with people being good looking and yes you can say someone is good looking it doesn't mean you're going to chase after them or cheat!

OP posts:
Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 13:23

Shmee1988 · Yesterday 13:20

Have you considered that talking freely about James/Paula down the road being attractive is a bit different to saying it about someone you will be in close proximity with for 40 hours a week? Maybe he didnt lie to be dishonest, possibly just to protect you and your potential anxiety. Me and my partner could walk past someone in the street and he could say 'she is very pretty' for example and I wouldn't really be phased. I think I may feel just a tad different if he was saying it about someone he spent the majority of his week with. Do you see what I mean? You probed, you asked a silly question and got an answer you didnt like.

It was the first answer I didn't like! Not the honest one because I can't actually argue with the honest one. She is lovely looking. Tat wasn't the issue

OP posts:
ForTipsyFinch · Yesterday 13:23

Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 13:13

I DID NOT ask him to rate anybody.... That was him

Ok sorry I must have misread I thought YOU asked him.

BillieWiper · Yesterday 13:24

That's bizarre..how would you like it if your partner forced you to grade all the men you've ever met out of 10 and if he thought they were deserving of a higher score act like you're some cheating haridan?! Absolutely bonkers and he should leave you. Unless you stop doing it now.

UnoriginalPoster · Yesterday 13:28

You do sound a bit unhinged, to be honest.

VimesandhisCardboardBoots · Yesterday 13:33

Purplehairdontcare35 · Yesterday 13:17

When you share your life with someone I think honesty is at the core of that! It's not always good, bad, pretty etc but its honest. Honesty is so important.

On most things, I agree with you. But you can't police someones internal thoughts like that.

I got home from work last week and DP said she was making fish for dinner. I really didn't fancy fish, but it was already being cooked and so I just said "Lovely". Was I being dishonest there?

By your logic, I should have told her that I didn't want fish and that I wouldn't enjoy it. But what would be the point? It's not going to change anything, the fish is already being cooked, all it's going to lead to is a slightly awkward atmosphere. So what exactly is the point of telling the truth.

Or, if you want an example about attraction. As far as I'm concerned, the most beautiful celebrity in the world is Karen Gillan. Tall, leggy, redhead, she's pretty much the definition of my "type". I find DP utterly beautiful, but she is definitely not my "type". She's short, blonde, a little stocky. She's also quite insecure about my looks. So as far as DP knows, I think the most beautiful woman in the world is Florence Pugh. And it's true, I do find Florence Pugh very attractive, but its because she reminds me of DP, rather than because she's my type.

It's a harmless little lie, told because it makes DP feel better about herself. I could be absolutely honest with her, but what would be the point, how would that make our lives better?

Your partner may have lied, but he lied about something you have no absolute right to know about. Absolute honesty isn't required in a relationship, in fact I think it makes for quite a controlling relationship. You're a couple, you're not an unholy merging of two minds into one. He's allowed his own private inner life and thoughts, seperate from you.

redskyAtNigh · Yesterday 13:33

You are obsessed with this. You asked him if he thought his colleague was good looking and he said "no". He then said he thought she was 6/10.

How are those two answers materially different? 6/10 to me is a bit better looking than average - not something I'd consider "good looking".

And if I'd known you'd gone hunting for a picture of my colleague on SM, I'd be a bit careful how I replied to you as well.
The reason he is probably mentioning her a lot is because they started at the same time, are thrown together a lot and will have some of the same experiences. Same way as I mention my colleague who started at the same time as me and he is not good looking and also extremely dull. But he gives me a bit of a benchmark to measure my job starting experience, which is why I mention him.