Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Am I overreacting, or is my marriage reaching a breaking point?

64 replies

Momoftwo38 · 12/11/2026 03:08

I'm looking for honest, unbiased advice because I'm genuinely struggling with my marriage, and I've recently started thinking about divorce.
My husband and I have been married since 2017, and we have two children. He is a good father and good husband, I always say he is my partner in crime.

Before meeting him, I was in a two-year relationship involving cheating, manipulation and dishonesty. That experience affected me deeply, and I've struggled with trust ever since. My husband knows about my past.

Recently, something happened that completely unsettled me.

A woman liked one of my husband's Instagram stories, so I asked him if he knew her. He told me he didn't know her. I asked him to unfollow her, and he did.

However, afterwards, I noticed that he was following her business pages and had liked several of her business posts across different social media platforms.

When I asked him whose business page it was, he told me he didn't know and that a friend had asked him to follow it to support the business.
Something didn't sit right with me, so I looked at the comments and recognized that the woman from the original Instagram story was commenting from her personal account.
I confronted him again, and this time he admitted that he knew her.

He explained that several years ago (2011 we didn't know each other back then), she had been sexually abused by his cousin, who had threatened to share her intimate pictures. My husband said he helped her get out of that situation and even broke his cousin's phone. According to him, she made him promise never to tell anyone about what happened because she didn't want her story exposed (in my country you can be k* by your parents or brothers because of that.)

He said he avoided telling me because he felt that revealing the situation would be betraying her confidence. He also said he was simply following and supporting her business, and that there was nothing romantic or inappropriate between them.
I can understand wanting to protect someone's privacy, especially given what she experienced. I'm not upset that he helped someone in a vulnerable situation.

What I struggle with is how he handled the situation.
He initially told me he didn't know her. Then he gave me another explanation about a friend asking him to support a business. I only got the truth after recognizing her comments myself.

My husband's perspective is that he has nothing to hide and a like to a perfume product dosen't mean you love someone. He reminds me that I have access to his Instagram and Facebook accounts, that we have pictures of ourselves together on his profiles, and that he has never hidden the fact that he is married. I also have message notifications activated, and I have never seen any messages between them and that the women was married.

He says that if he had anything inappropriate to hide, he wouldn't be so transparent about his accounts or giving me his phone when I ask. He feels that he has done nothing wrong because he was protecting someone's privacy but that he understands why i'm hurt, he was very calm about the whole situation.

I can acknowledge that my past has affected my ability to trust. I don't want to project someone else's actions onto my husband, and I don't want to become a wife who constantly checks likes, followers and social media activity. His social media are only his friends and people he knows.

But I also feel that trust is about more than having access to someone's phone. It's about being able to believe what your partner tells you.

I feel like I trust him halfway, and then I remember that he looked me in the eyes and denied knowing someone he actually knew. I feel betrayed, I wanted him to be honest and tell me that he knows her from his cousin that's it!

We've been married for almost nine years and have two children. I don't take divorce lightly, but this situation has made me question our relationship.
Am I overreacting? Given everything I've explained, would you consider his reasons understandable, or do you think he should have handled things differently? Is this something I should be able to move past, or is the damage to my trust something more serious?

OP posts:
Dery · 12/11/2026 07:27

I think you are pushing your marriage to breaking point by your surveillance of your husband which sounds really oppressive. It wouldn’t be okay if he was doing this to you and it’s not okay you doing this to him. Given your behaviour, it’s not surprising he initially lied to you. You’re punishing your husband for things done by a previous partner and using them as an excuse for behaviour which is actually abusive. Please seek therapy.

TraitorOrFaithful · 12/11/2026 07:37

OP, I think you are overreacting here. It may be worth talking to a therapist about your trust issues?

MarilynMerlot · 12/11/2026 07:43

Dery · 12/11/2026 07:27

I think you are pushing your marriage to breaking point by your surveillance of your husband which sounds really oppressive. It wouldn’t be okay if he was doing this to you and it’s not okay you doing this to him. Given your behaviour, it’s not surprising he initially lied to you. You’re punishing your husband for things done by a previous partner and using them as an excuse for behaviour which is actually abusive. Please seek therapy.

Agreed, this is flat out controlling and if the situation were reversed you would be being advised to leave your abusive partner.

OneHazelBird · 12/11/2026 07:50

A woman liked one of my husband's Instagram stories, so I asked him if he knew her. He told me he didn't know her. I asked him to unfollow her, and he did.

Sorry OP but this is extremely unhealthy and wrong.

He absolutely should not have lied but he’s in a controlling relationship and sometimes people need to lie to protect themselves.

I think you need to work on your own issues first.

Mosaic80 · 12/11/2026 07:57

I think reasonable to find the lie upsetting no matter what the reason and to work through that with your H. I don’t think this should be marriage ending and think it can be worked through. Is he apologetic that he lied and understanding of your upset? Taking some accountability would be important for me (despite the issues at play - he should have just told you, it’s not like you’re going to tell anyone given the stakes involved).

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 12/11/2026 08:02

Mosaic80 · 12/11/2026 07:57

I think reasonable to find the lie upsetting no matter what the reason and to work through that with your H. I don’t think this should be marriage ending and think it can be worked through. Is he apologetic that he lied and understanding of your upset? Taking some accountability would be important for me (despite the issues at play - he should have just told you, it’s not like you’re going to tell anyone given the stakes involved).

If my DH asked me who a man was who liked a post and told me to unfollow them I would not tell him on principle. It's outrageous behaviour

Notonthestairs · 12/11/2026 08:06

Mosaic80 · 12/11/2026 07:57

I think reasonable to find the lie upsetting no matter what the reason and to work through that with your H. I don’t think this should be marriage ending and think it can be worked through. Is he apologetic that he lied and understanding of your upset? Taking some accountability would be important for me (despite the issues at play - he should have just told you, it’s not like you’re going to tell anyone given the stakes involved).

I think you have to put the lie in the context of a partner that has notifications set up to monitor SM activity.
That said it was wrong to lie and he would have been better to explain from the start. Not convinced the Op would have accepted the explanation however.

DozyDumpling · 12/11/2026 08:24

This is a you problem.

DiNozzoComingBack · 12/11/2026 08:30

The fact that you monitor his social media and phone is a huge red flag. You are being very unreasonable and need to.take a step back and deal witj your own insecurities..

secretrocker · 12/11/2026 08:32

Yes you are overeacting and sound very controlling.

Pedant61 · 12/11/2026 09:09

I don't even know what social media my husband has (nor he me), let alone checking the likes. You are completely overreacting, OP, and it's absolutely fine for your husband to be in touch with female friends and acquaintances.

Sassylovesbooks · 12/11/2026 09:14

I couldn't be with someone who had access to my social media accounts, my phone and then scrutinised who I interacted with online. It's suffocating, emotionally draining and controlling behaviour.

I've been with my husband 20 years, in all that time, I have never asked for access to his social media accounts, or his phone. If I couldn't even trust him with the bear minimum, then I wouldn't have a relationship.

You need to seriously look at yourself here and get some support for your own issues. Your husband has been extremely accommodating over your insistent to allow you access to his social media accounts and phone. In a healthy relationship, this shouldn't need to happen at all.

If your husband had explained from the start, would you have accepted that explanation? My feeling is that you wouldn't, because in essence, no amount of reassurance or explanations would ever be enough. In short you don't fully trust your husband, and it wouldn't matter what he says or does to please you.

Billy47 · 12/11/2026 09:26

I dont like that he lied to you. He could have just said its someone he knows that asjed him to support her business page. He didn't really heef to go into the revenge porn stuff. You dont need to know everything about everyone.

I think you'd benefit from individual counselling to work onbyour past trauma. I also think some couple councelling would help. You can discuss how your past experiences are impacting your current relationship.

I wouldn't divorce him based on that lie. He's human and on that occasion he got it wrong.

wildnwilde · 12/11/2026 09:32

This is a you problem op . When you have been hurt it's understandable but you are being unfair to DH . Get some resources and work on yourself. I used to be like you. I'm now in relationship with a man I trust completely. I wouldn't even bar a eyelid at this . Your making your husband pay the price for your exes sins

AnneLovesGilbert · 12/11/2026 09:39

I can’t imagine being this interested in my husband’s social media, I just don’t care. You went looking for trouble, blaming a past relationship isn’t a good enough excuse. It’s not okay to be this obsessed with your husband’s behaviour when he hadn’t given you any reason not to trust him. I can see why he lied, which I’d usually judge harshly, because he knows what your reaction is and it’s disproportionate and controlling. To even think about divorce suggests you’re looking for reasons to sabotage your marriage. Why?!

OMGDidYouSayThat · 12/11/2026 09:47

I think there are a couple of things going on here, the first thing that's a problem is that you find it hard to trust people, not your fault and unfortunately for any of us that have been cheated on in the past it does underlying damage that's not easy to repair, it's ok to be on your guard a bit and you probably always will be.

The second issue is the way he dealt with the situation, some would say he deliberately hid the truth, and he did, but did he have good reason to is the question, like he said he's transparent, you have access to his social accounts etc.

Would i give him another chance if he'd been cheating or sexting, absolutely not.

Would i throw away a 9 year marriage because he followed someone on social media, again, absolutely not.

Would i tell him i felt betrayed and highlight the importance of honesty, absolutely i would.

Bogofftosomewherehot · 12/11/2026 10:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

OrlandointheWilderness · 12/11/2026 10:19

I’m sorry but you are controlling here. He’s done nothing wrong, I understand completely why he lied given the potential severity of this woman’s situation and you have forced him to expose this. That’s not fair. You don’t trust him at all.
i don’t have any access to DH social media, or he mine. We are ‘friends’ on FB (he doesn’t use it much though) but I wouldn’t have a clue about his activity. I don’t particularly care tbh, I suspect it would be endless tractor videos or history!!

CinnamonBuns67 · 12/11/2026 10:29

I wouldn't be impressed with the lie OP, it certainly will make you feel it's not as innocent as he says. Have you considered getting some therapy for betrayal trauma? Or even just looking some information on it so you can understand what your brain is doing?

If it is innocent as he says and he's told a lie simply to avoid an argument (which whilst isn't great people tend to do it) then it's not something I'd get a divorce over unless it became a pattern of behaviour.

GumyBand · 12/11/2026 11:58

I think people are being rather hard on OP.

Instagram can be a hotbed of cheating opportunities. There are actually a lot of accounts on there with therapists explaining how the use of Instagram and the endless following and liking, especially by men, is harmful to a marriage or intimate relationship.

In a marriage, one is perfectly entitled to look at what your spouse is doing online. There should not be secrets. Sure, a certain level of privacy. But if two do not wish to become, in the proper sense of a marriage, then don't lie and don't conceal things that may upset your spouse. If you're like that, then stay single. Absolute trust is only built on absolutely trustworthy behaviour.

All these people jumping on here going on about trust and OP being abusive? Really? Then put yourself in her shoes.

The fact is her spouse DID lie about it and he had no need to lie. She probably has some level of cognitive dissonance going on, which is not a nice place for the brain, body and nervous system to be.

Personally I would find it odd that he said he didn't know her initially. He had zero need to lie and the entire story he told sounds like a lie too.

leopardandspots · 12/11/2026 13:21

Personally I would find it odd that he said he didn't know her initially. He had zero need to lie and the entire story he told sounds like a lie too.

I agree. Why can’t people just be transparent. My partners always know where I’ve been socialising etc, who I’ve looked up on social media because I chat about it.

secretrocker · 12/11/2026 14:49

leopardandspots · 12/11/2026 13:21

Personally I would find it odd that he said he didn't know her initially. He had zero need to lie and the entire story he told sounds like a lie too.

I agree. Why can’t people just be transparent. My partners always know where I’ve been socialising etc, who I’ve looked up on social media because I chat about it.

Zero need to lie apart from a controlling wife he monitors his social media clicks.

Boomer55 · 12/11/2026 16:03

Best you move on from the past.

dh280125 · 12/11/2026 17:58

If things are as you say they are, and there is not reason to doubt them, then you are over reacting. Get therapy.

socialbatteryisdead · 12/11/2026 18:04

Overreacting. If the roles were reversed people would be saying it’s controlling and LTB