Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

DH unable to move forward after my affair

332 replies

Jax42 · 11/11/2026 09:16

We have two pre school children, I went out on a Christmas work do and met a man. We swapped numbers and I left it at that. Months later, I felt disconnected with DH, we were arguing and I wanted an escape. I contacted the other man and we met for drinks, planned to have sex but I couldn’t go through with it, I felt too guilty. We ended everything, all communication and only recently I’ve told DH about it. It’s been a week and he is constantly berating me, asking in depth questions then still being intimate with me. I understand, but it’s constant, almost every conversation he points towards the fling. We are arguing more than ever. I’ve realised where I went wrong and I’m going to seek therapy for my issues but that’s not enough for him, he is constantly punishing me. Will it get better in time? I’m just looking for some advice.

OP posts:
ThreadGuardDog · 11/11/2026 11:15

SandyCastles · 11/11/2026 11:11

Yes it seems it is normal response, but at what point does OP have to appease these 'needs' in him? Some of this advice is turning my stomach.

I think it is very dangerous to advise a woman in an unhappy relationship, that she needs to 'suck it up' while he is using her for sex and emotionally abusing her. Putting aside her indiscretion for a moment, none of us know the real backstory here, and if he has always used sex/emotional intimacy as a weapon of control in their relationship.. it is very common in marriage.

Just think about it is all I'm saying, OP should not feel like she has to be his emotional beating post or sex object just to make him feel better because she has done wrong, there are other ways of working through breaches of trust in a relationship.

Absolutely this.

Purplecatshopaholic · 11/11/2026 11:16

Op, you fucked up. And you double fucked up by telling him. Plus he may not be believing you when you say you didn’t do anything physical. You need to give him time, and actively show him you are willing to change and commit to your marriage. Be aware it may not be enough to save this.

gamerchick · 11/11/2026 11:18

I don't understand why you told him though? You haven't fucked about. He's not going to believe you haven't.

Are you bored in your marriage and just want 'something' to happen? Getting your head turned is usually a symptom of marriage problems. Those problems are still there.

You need a proper heart to heart about the real issues. Not stir the pot to get a dopamine hit because you're bored.

HollaHolla · 11/11/2026 11:18

It's not helpful, but I just keep thinking, 'folks are already having Christmas do's?!'

Anyway, yes. You've fucked up, and you and your husband will need to decide if you want to try and work through this. Also, you're both still pretty young. It's going to be a long slog of a marriage, if you are struggling now. Might be worth thinking about what it is you both really want for the next 30, 40, 50 years.... Sounds like you need to do some work, together, and seperately. Can you see/speak to a therapist through your GP, or even your work employee assistance programme? (We have that option for 6 sessions, and doesn't have to be work based. Workplaces recognise that outside factors can have an effect on you at work too.)
Hope you manage to work your ways through this.

wishingonastar101 · 11/11/2026 11:18

I think the planning is worse than if you got drunk and shagged someone.

LastChristmasI · 11/11/2026 11:21

It's been a week!
5 years on and I still struggle a lot because DH did similar- and he absolutely busted a gut to make amends including paying for counselling for both of us separately and together

ThreadGuardDog · 11/11/2026 11:28

MagpiesAndJays · 11/11/2026 10:32

So despite it being at the back of your mind for months, you expect him to drop it in less than a week. You told him to make yourself feel better but won't own that this is all a mess of your own making. He can take as long as he needs to decide if he wants to stay married to you, knowing that this is how you react to difficult spells.

Does ‘taking as long as he needs’ include using her like a sex doll one minute and wanting to rake over the ‘affair’ and berating her the next ? Because I don’t buy into the whole ‘hysterical bonding’ tripe. It’s abuse and it doesn’t matter what she has and hasn’t done, it’s unacceptable.

worreidaboutdpnow · 11/11/2026 11:28

Strange you'd tell him something that didn't happen. You were obviously trying to hurt him and provoke some kind of reaction. How cruel. Just leave him and do him a favour.

CostelloJones · 11/11/2026 11:30

It has only been a week he’s still probably processing all of this - what did you expect to happen “ok love, never mind” and never mention it again?

It Reads very much like you are minimising your actions and trying to lay the blame elsewhere. It doesn’t matter what state your relationship was in - you made poor decisions and you need to be responsible for them without deflecting.

Honestly if my DP had done the same I would go nuclear

MrDirtyBear · 11/11/2026 11:30

Sounds like he's now deeply hurt and insecure. The intimacy will be a factor in that, trying to reconnect and possibly even demonstrate that you don't need to go out for a Big Kahuna Burger when there's plenty of frozen burgers in the freezer and fresh burger buns.

He needs counselling and support, as do you, however if I were him I'd consider you wholly untrustworthy and move on, and based solely on what you've posted more than a bit self absorbed.

But no, its not likely to magically just get better, and certainly not on its own. It will change, he's probably going to not want to be with you once its sunk in that he doesn't really trust that you didn't go through with it. He's going to assume there's something lacking in him, rather than than lacking in you.

Co-parent and live separate lives, or put your shoulder to the wheel and work through therapy together. But it will never be the same again. Well done you eh.

OneDogTwoCatsHalfaDH · 11/11/2026 11:31

LastChristmasI · 11/11/2026 11:21

It's been a week!
5 years on and I still struggle a lot because DH did similar- and he absolutely busted a gut to make amends including paying for counselling for both of us separately and together

Exactly! Thinking he should be over it in a week is ridiculous.
And I don't know why everybody has jumped to him "punishing" OP by going over and over it.
Chances are he is just trying to grt to grips with it mentally, emotionally and physically. You are no longer the woman he knows and trusts, he will have to come to terms with you being a totally different person to him.
Give him time, as much as he needs. If you really want to continue in the relationship it will take a lot of work from both of you, there's no quick and easy fix to this.

ThreadGuardDog · 11/11/2026 11:31

worreidaboutdpnow · 11/11/2026 11:28

Strange you'd tell him something that didn't happen. You were obviously trying to hurt him and provoke some kind of reaction. How cruel. Just leave him and do him a favour.

It did happen though. OP actually arranged a date with this man and went on it. The fact that it didn’t end in sex is neither here nor there - that was the intention. I can well imagine this playing on OP’s mind and being blurted out during an argument. There’s clearly something very lacking in the marriage and without more context we don’t know what, or how much responsibility OP or DH each need to take for whatever is wrong.

PumpkinPieAlibi · 11/11/2026 11:31

HollaHolla · 11/11/2026 11:18

It's not helpful, but I just keep thinking, 'folks are already having Christmas do's?!'

Anyway, yes. You've fucked up, and you and your husband will need to decide if you want to try and work through this. Also, you're both still pretty young. It's going to be a long slog of a marriage, if you are struggling now. Might be worth thinking about what it is you both really want for the next 30, 40, 50 years.... Sounds like you need to do some work, together, and seperately. Can you see/speak to a therapist through your GP, or even your work employee assistance programme? (We have that option for 6 sessions, and doesn't have to be work based. Workplaces recognise that outside factors can have an effect on you at work too.)
Hope you manage to work your ways through this.

It seems like it's from last year's Christmas, as some months passed before she contacted the other man.

Growlybear83 · 11/11/2026 11:31

whatever did you expect? You broke your husband’s trust - you arranged to meet the man with the intention of shagging him, whether or not you went through with it. Presumably there was some type of physical contact with the other man before you decided not to go ahead? If my husband had told me something like this, he would never spend another night under the same roof as me, so I think you’re quite fortunate that your husband hasnt chucked you out.

MagpiesAndJays · 11/11/2026 11:32

ThreadGuardDog · 11/11/2026 11:14

Where have I said that ? Unmet needs in a marriage count for both partners equally - but here we’re talking about the female partner’s needs. OP has already said she’s identified the problem she had and is working on it in therapy, and yet he’s still punishing her. Yes it’s early days, I agree, but he needs to sort himself out because a cycle of needing sex followed by cruel rejection will be damaging in itself.

You quoted a theory ‘Hysterical Bonding’ which has been widely discredited due to in the inherent misogyny and medicalisation of a normal response to being betrayed. And which actually makes no mention of what OP has reported - which is her DH cycling between wanting sex and then rejecting her. It’s punishment however you dress it up.

Speaking of discredited theories. Unmet needs has been discredited as justification for cheating except by cheats. Infidelity is always a choice, and other options are always available.

Call hysterical bonding trauma bonding or a panic response if you prefer. It exists as a phenomenon in both men and women, regardless of what anyone calls it.

No one should be having sex they don't want. If he won't take no for an answer, they have even bigger problems than they already do. However, wanting more sex, being conflicted, emotions all over the place are all entirely within the normal range at a week since disclosure.

Fupoffyagrasshole · 11/11/2026 11:32

HoldMyWine · 11/11/2026 09:46

This! It’s all on you Op.

just cus you have little kids doesnt mean you cant go out - in fact it would be easier for me now than ever to have an affair cus i never go out with my husband anymore as one of us is minding the kids while the other goes out

Anyway the op didnt have an affair

I think give her a bloody break - shes been a parent since around 18 and is only 23 - she missed out on a lot of freedon as a result and settled down very young

shes probably only with this guy because they have kids - maybe she doesn't want to be with him anymore and thats fine - this was a wake up call that she isn't happy

OP you don't need to settle for your husband - you can break up and share the kids and live your own life!

ThreadGuardDog · 11/11/2026 11:34

MrDirtyBear · 11/11/2026 11:30

Sounds like he's now deeply hurt and insecure. The intimacy will be a factor in that, trying to reconnect and possibly even demonstrate that you don't need to go out for a Big Kahuna Burger when there's plenty of frozen burgers in the freezer and fresh burger buns.

He needs counselling and support, as do you, however if I were him I'd consider you wholly untrustworthy and move on, and based solely on what you've posted more than a bit self absorbed.

But no, its not likely to magically just get better, and certainly not on its own. It will change, he's probably going to not want to be with you once its sunk in that he doesn't really trust that you didn't go through with it. He's going to assume there's something lacking in him, rather than than lacking in you.

Co-parent and live separate lives, or put your shoulder to the wheel and work through therapy together. But it will never be the same again. Well done you eh.

It will change, he's probably going to not want to be with you once its sunk in that he doesn't really trust that you didn't go through with it. He's going to assume there's something lacking in him, rather than than lacking in you.

So in the meantime OP is just expected to accept an abusive cycle of him wanting sex one minute and berating her the next ? If he can’t control his behaviour then he should leave while he decides what to do.

whatsit84 · 11/11/2026 11:36

Why did you even tell him, what were you hoping to gain?

HelloDenise · 11/11/2026 11:36

FKAT · 11/11/2026 09:22

Why did you tell him and what did you expect would happen?

You have a job and 2 pre-school children - maybe grow up and focus on them for a change instead of getting dick.

She didn't get any.

faithfultoGeorgeMichael · 11/11/2026 11:37

What he is doing is called "hysterical bonding" you see it all the time on here when women are devastated by their husbands affairs but play pick me and are intimate then regretful. It is a natural process for him to go thru. Poor man.

Samysungy · 11/11/2026 11:37

You do not get to decide on how he feels and when he should stop feeling what he feels or if he should stop feeling what he feels.

This is called...a consequence.

MrDirtyBear · 11/11/2026 11:37

ThreadGuardDog · 11/11/2026 11:34

It will change, he's probably going to not want to be with you once its sunk in that he doesn't really trust that you didn't go through with it. He's going to assume there's something lacking in him, rather than than lacking in you.

So in the meantime OP is just expected to accept an abusive cycle of him wanting sex one minute and berating her the next ? If he can’t control his behaviour then he should leave while he decides what to do.

You are reading a lot into that OP, based presumably on your own prejudices.

I'm absolutely not saying that the OP has to accept any abusive cycle, theorised by you or in reality. If that's what you got from it then you need to get chatgpt to summarise it for you.

TheLarch · 11/11/2026 11:38

ThreadGuardDog · 11/11/2026 11:28

Does ‘taking as long as he needs’ include using her like a sex doll one minute and wanting to rake over the ‘affair’ and berating her the next ? Because I don’t buy into the whole ‘hysterical bonding’ tripe. It’s abuse and it doesn’t matter what she has and hasn’t done, it’s unacceptable.

Strongly suggest you know absolutely nothing about affairs and their aftermath. Have you ever come across the concept of intrusive thoughts? Because that's what happens after someone blows your world apart, hence the questioning. It's an awful thing to want to be close to someone and reclaim your old relationship (the sex) but then be doing the washing up and then suddenly remember how a week / month ago they'd said they were off to the gym but were instead probably hiding in their car to whisper plans of hotels and shagging to someone else. It's actually a form of PTSD. Please stop victim blaming. And the OP should leave her husband. If she's had enough after a week, she clearly doesn't care enough about him to do the hard work of rebuilding their life. Let him go and find someone who actually loves him and doesn't just jump on someone else's dick the minute life gets a bit challenging.

OP, you are trying to hide from your guilt by deflecting and blaming him for an 'unreasonable' response. If you want to rebuild, do some reading. Accept blame, because at the end of the day, this is all on you. What did you expect to happen? How would you have felt if your husband had come home one day and said 'I was planning to shag Jane from accounts but changed my mind at the last minute - hope that's ok and we can never speak of this again?'

waterrat · 11/11/2026 11:39

Thinking if I was in your DH's shoes - I would be the same.

Are you not considering joint therapy?

BerryTwister · 11/11/2026 11:40

Every time you have an argument he'll worry that your way of coping with it will be to find another man to have sex with. He'll be terrified of disagreeing with you, in case it turns into a row.

Imagine how it would feel to live like that OP.