Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

DH unable to move forward after my affair

332 replies

Jax42 · 11/11/2026 09:16

We have two pre school children, I went out on a Christmas work do and met a man. We swapped numbers and I left it at that. Months later, I felt disconnected with DH, we were arguing and I wanted an escape. I contacted the other man and we met for drinks, planned to have sex but I couldn’t go through with it, I felt too guilty. We ended everything, all communication and only recently I’ve told DH about it. It’s been a week and he is constantly berating me, asking in depth questions then still being intimate with me. I understand, but it’s constant, almost every conversation he points towards the fling. We are arguing more than ever. I’ve realised where I went wrong and I’m going to seek therapy for my issues but that’s not enough for him, he is constantly punishing me. Will it get better in time? I’m just looking for some advice.

OP posts:
Blackcat2026 · 12/11/2026 07:03

ThreadGuardDog · 11/11/2026 20:10

Yes. She did. He wants sex one minute and then the next wants to discuss the situation and berates her for what she did. That’s abuse.

Is it fuck! He's trying to 'move on' and struggling. He still needs time to process.

ThreadGuardDog · 12/11/2026 07:05

TheLarch · 11/11/2026 21:43

Nope - it really is a common trauma response after affairs. He's not abusing her; he's just traumatised by her sh*tty actions and alternately trying to make it better so he hurts less, then being revolted by his actions. Poor man.

https://chumplady.com/the-pick-me-dance/

I’m fully aware that it’s a common trauma response but that doesn’t make it any the less abusive in this situation and the way OP is describing it. It’s early days - only a week, and he needs time to sort out his feelings, but if the sex isn’t consensual, or OP feels guilted into it, then one of them needs to move out temporarily while they sort it.

ThreadGuardDog · 12/11/2026 07:08

Blackcat2026 · 12/11/2026 07:03

Is it fuck! He's trying to 'move on' and struggling. He still needs time to process.

So you’d be happy for your daughter to be treated like this ? Yes, he needs time to process things, but that doesn’t give him carte Blanche to treat OP like shit whenever he feels like it. The need for sex is an accepted trauma response - the swinging between wanting sex and the berating of the cheater is not. It’s abusive and if OP is not consenting or feels in any way pressured into the sex then one of them needs to leave until they sort themselves out.

pilates · 12/11/2026 07:14

I expect he is wondering if you did actually not sleep with the man. It will take time for him to gain trust again as you did have intent.

Newbutoldfather · 12/11/2026 07:56

@ThreadGuardDog ,

‘I’m fully aware that it’s a common trauma response but that doesn’t make it any the less abusive in this situation and the way OP is describing it. It’s early days - only a week, and he needs time to sort out his feelings, but if the sex isn’t consensual, or OP feels guilted into it, then one of them needs to move out temporarily while they sort it.’

I don’t really get what you are on about here. There is nothing abusive about struggling with trauma.

You are inferring for some reason that the sex is non consensual to make your point when the OP has not in any way stated that. Might she feel ‘guilted’ into it? Maybe. It still doesn’t make it abusive.

I strongly suspect that, if the sexes were reversed (in every way), you would think the woman was abused by her husband who set up a sex date (even if he didn’t go through with it), however much she guilted her husband into sex.

Cheating (or even making a connection and thinking about cheating) really messes with people’s emotions. There is nothing to stop the OP removing herself from the situation if she isn’t happy about it.

Newbutoldfather · 12/11/2026 08:01

As ever, these threads get extreme responses.

The OP is to be blamed for her actions but sympathised with as a human being who made one (relatively small) mistake.

She is young and had children young. Any 23 year old is going to be flattered by attention if in a humdrum marriage where sex has been put to one side. And she had the sense not to go through with it.

With time and, if they both want it, the marriage can continue and grow stronger, especially with counselling.

Isitchristmasyettt · 12/11/2026 08:05

OP how your husband is feeling right now is completely normal. He’s allowed to ask questions, be angry, be confused.

What you have to remember here is at that exact time when you were messaging that person, planning to meet up and have sex with them, your husband was also going through that detachment with you in your relationship too - and despite that he hasn’t been in touch with another woman.

It’s a new reality for him to get his head around. It’s been a week. What he will wonder now, is the next time you go through a rough patch, is that it, will you be contacting someone else for sex?

There’s no timeline on grief - which is essentially what this is. He will be grieving what he thought your relationship was. He will be unsure of what it is right now.

You say that you told your husband about it - was that because you were being honest with him? Or because you were forced to?

sandrapinchedmysandwich · 12/11/2026 08:06

Blackcat2026 · 12/11/2026 07:03

Is it fuck! He's trying to 'move on' and struggling. He still needs time to process.

Exactly this. It is in no way abuse. The op does not seem to be being coerced in any way shape or form. Her dp is trying to regain some sort of closeness for reassurance while seeking answers and quite rightly feeling strongly about the ops actions

Askmehowiknow2021 · 12/11/2026 08:10

You appear to have absolutely zero idea of what your husband is currently going through. You demonstrate a total lack of emotional intelligence and self awareness as is common in people who choose to do this.

It has been one week since you destroyed his reality. He is now questioning EVERYTHING he thought he knew about you and everything that has happened in your relationship.

You say you didn’t shag this man? How does your husband know that? Because you tell him? Like you told him you’d be faithful? Like you told him some pack of lies to enable you to meet this man for sex in the first place? I’m 100% certain you didn’t say to him “just nipping out darling, there is a man I fancy getting my leg over with, you don’t mind do you”? No, you lied.
You need to understand that your words mean less than nothing now, you’ve lost all credibility. This will take YEARS for him to recover from, if ever. And you are moaning about a week? Buckle up, this is a direct consequence of your own choices. If you don’t like it, leave.

TheFriendlyPotato · 12/11/2026 08:31

Jax42 · 11/11/2026 09:45

To the person who said I should focus on my kids, I infant do all the home admin, housework and raising the children plus working part time. So please do not ever question me as a mother. Yes I was a shitty wife in that moment, I fully regret it.

I suppose I wanted to know if this had ever happened to anyone else and if they moved forward? I have been open ever since, I’ve let him go into my phone and I am not being secretive at all. I just don’t like keep reliving it everyday or multiple times a day, it was just drinks but I understand the intention was there to have sex. I could never do this again, I was an idiot.

You dont like reliving it daily yet that is the karmic consequence of your actions. The learning is dont do things that will later make you feel guilt.

As for the answer, you can only wait. I suspect he will probably take months or years to get over it (if he does).

Many men not only feel the pain of the action, but their whole manliness is questioned when a partner strays. Plus, if he hasnt got much else outside of the family that'll be far harder.

I would be surprised if he isnt questioning everything he knows about you. Intention trumps action. Going to meet the person with intent of sex is far more serious IMO than a drunken kiss in a club. Expecting him to get over it in a week suggests you dont understand at all.

If he was a woman on here, many would be telling him to leave and never look back.

I hope you have learnt the value of faithfulness and loyalty. Every action has a short or long term consequence. For him, it is totaly broken trust in you. For you, it is guilt. You cannot escape the guilt by hoping he will get over it. You must own the guilt as created entirely by you.

All the best and good luck.

AHippoTookAnApricot · 12/11/2026 08:38

I'm not surprised he's unable to move on. While you may not have physically cheated, the intent was there, and I don't think it's possible to underestimate how much you have betrayed his trust.

What's more, from the tone of your posts, you don't appear to have shown much contrition. You just think he should get over with it quickly, even though he's still coming to terms with this massive bombshell?

Ultimately, your relationship is probably doomed. Very few couples are strong enough to survive infidelity, and, with respect, I don't sense you are one of them. Rather than healing, this situation will probably just become a festering wound. He'll forever be doubting you, and suspecting you of cheating again, because you've demonstrated that you were already willing to once, and that is unforgiveable for most people.

Do yourselves both a favour and part ways. Let him meet someone who actually values him, and you can have as sex with as many men as you please without feeling any guilt.

MaidOfSteel · 12/11/2026 10:19

SandyCastles · 11/11/2026 13:52

If you both decide you want to try to repair things, you’ll just have to suck up his ways of expressing the hurt and betrayal he feels and work hard to prove yourself to him. Even then, it might not happen.

Yes, keep appeasing his needs, having sex with him whenever he wants and meekly accepting his berating and punishments the rest of the time until he feels better.

No, Op does not have to put up with constant abuse.

If his questioning, berating, anger and frustration is being directed at her as constantly as she says it is, you do realise he will be doing that in front of their pre-school aged children don't you?

I wasn’t encouraging, you know! But we see it so often in here, many women do stay. It’s not what I’d do but plenty will.

Go and berate elsewhere.

MaidOfSteel · 12/11/2026 10:21

ThreadGuardDog · 11/11/2026 13:46

Are you actually suggesting that it’s OK for him to use OP for sex to comfort himself one minute and then berate her the next for what she did ? Seriously ?

Edited

No. I wasn’t suggesting that! DFO.

As you well know, we see it every day on here, plenty of women stay for any number of reasons. You berating me is like him berating the OP.

LiberteLynx · 12/11/2026 16:30

Anyone that can move on from learning of their DH/DW’s affair after only one week is likely already checked out of the relationship and having their own affairs. Yabvu OP.

You cannot judge whether he can or cannot move on from your affair after only one week.

moderate · 12/11/2026 16:31

Will it get better in time?

Yes. A week is nothing. His world has been turned upside down. He doesn't yet know whether there's more to come (most cheaters trickle-truth).

he is constantly berating me, asking in depth questions then still being intimate with me.

Look up "hysterical bonding". It's not uncommon.

moderate · 12/11/2026 16:34

I see a lot of posters on here have never experienced hysterical bonding. I suggest to them that they don't pontificate on something they know nothing about.

moderate · 12/11/2026 16:40

ThreadGuardDog · 11/11/2026 10:57

Then he needs to realise that it’s not the sex that will prevent her running off, it’s whatever she felt was missing in the first place. Wanting more sex and alternating that with constant berating and picking over what’s happened is a recipe for disaster. It seems more like he’s taking advantage of her guilt when it suits him and continuing to punish her in the meantime.

Edited

You've mis-read "Go and read about hysterical bonding" as "Blame the victim and project your own warped worldview onto the situation".

moderate · 12/11/2026 16:42

HollaHolla · 11/11/2026 11:18

It's not helpful, but I just keep thinking, 'folks are already having Christmas do's?!'

Anyway, yes. You've fucked up, and you and your husband will need to decide if you want to try and work through this. Also, you're both still pretty young. It's going to be a long slog of a marriage, if you are struggling now. Might be worth thinking about what it is you both really want for the next 30, 40, 50 years.... Sounds like you need to do some work, together, and seperately. Can you see/speak to a therapist through your GP, or even your work employee assistance programme? (We have that option for 6 sessions, and doesn't have to be work based. Workplaces recognise that outside factors can have an effect on you at work too.)
Hope you manage to work your ways through this.

Pretty sure it wasn't this year's Christmas do!

moderate · 12/11/2026 16:42

ThreadGuardDog · 12/11/2026 07:08

So you’d be happy for your daughter to be treated like this ? Yes, he needs time to process things, but that doesn’t give him carte Blanche to treat OP like shit whenever he feels like it. The need for sex is an accepted trauma response - the swinging between wanting sex and the berating of the cheater is not. It’s abusive and if OP is not consenting or feels in any way pressured into the sex then one of them needs to leave until they sort themselves out.

Edited

The need for sex is an accepted trauma response - the swinging between wanting sex and the berating of the cheater is not.

Tell us you know nothing about trauma without telling us.

Cantthinkofausernamethatsuits · 13/11/2026 22:13

You're complaining after a week and think he's punishing you? How do you think he feels learning you went and met another man to have sex with him?How incredibly selfish you are. You're lucky he hasn't left you. But, as it has only been a week, he might decide to leave you. I hope it does get easier. For him that is. You sound awful!

JulietteRoche · 13/11/2026 22:14

You deserve it. What are you doing to ensure him that this won't ever happen again?

BeanBurgers · 13/11/2026 22:14

Why on earth did you tell him

ThreadGuardDog · 14/11/2026 16:54

moderate · 12/11/2026 16:42

The need for sex is an accepted trauma response - the swinging between wanting sex and the berating of the cheater is not.

Tell us you know nothing about trauma without telling us.

Oh trust me I do. Doesn’t mean I have to blindly condone abusive behaviour - which this is. The need for sex for reassurance absolutely is a trauma response. The swinging between that and berating the partner and asking for details repeatedly is not.

ThreadGuardDog · 14/11/2026 16:58

moderate · 12/11/2026 16:40

You've mis-read "Go and read about hysterical bonding" as "Blame the victim and project your own warped worldview onto the situation".

Nope. Haven’t misread at all. Not blaming the victim at all. Hysterical bonding has pretty much been discredited in therapy circles - of which I am a part. Trauma bonding is an absolutely solid pyschological theory. It does NOT and has NEVER supported swinging between wanting sex for comfort and reassurance, and berating the perpetrator of the affair, or whatever you want to call it. It’s abusive.

ThreadGuardDog · 14/11/2026 17:03

MaidOfSteel · 12/11/2026 10:21

No. I wasn’t suggesting that! DFO.

As you well know, we see it every day on here, plenty of women stay for any number of reasons. You berating me is like him berating the OP.

Sorry if I’ve misjudged but plenty of posters here are quoting ‘hysterical bonding’ as an excuse for the way DH is treating OP. It’s not a thing. It was shot down as a theory some time ago but still seems to be alive and well on MN. He doesn’t have to stay. The decision is his as the injured party. But staying to punish the OP for what she has done isn’t an option. It doesn’t solve anything. If he can’t come to a decision now - which is entirely understandable as it’s only been a week - then one of them should leave while they sort things out.