Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Was I right to say I didn’t want to get married?

22 replies

lemonadecar · 15/08/2026 09:51

I was in a coercive control marriage for over a decade. One of the worse ones, in that he was a decade older, lovebombed me and made me get married within 6 months of meeting, then abused me. Apart from that I’ve lived a normal life— nice long term university boyfriend before that and normal friends/job. I’m not an unstable person and that was an abomination. I have two children from the marriage.

Now I’m in a relationship with someone really lovely. He’s my age, has no kids, lives separately. We’re cautious and kind and have been together for two years. He asked me if I wanted him to propose (he is quite a factual person!) and I said no. My finances are set up in a delicate balance post divorce in relation to the kids, and it would be unnecessarily complex. I said we could maybe do it if we bought a house together once my kids had grown up. He agreed and we moved on. He had one long relationship before me where they were engaged but didn’t marry.

But now I’m wondering if it was the wrong choice. I’m admittedly scared of marriage and feel traumatised by my previous one. But am I missing a trick not to marry this man I have chosen and love?

OP posts:
PinkLady1979 · 15/08/2026 10:01

You are right to say no to getting married if you don’t want to and it is as simple as that. Noone can really tell you if you are right or wrong, it is up to you. Not wanting to be unhelpful but onkybyiu vsn say if yiu want to marry hin, past trauma or not.

Dozer · 15/08/2026 10:04

Given you have DC and he’s not their father the legal & financial matters are really important, even when your DC are adults and don’t live with you. Wouldn’t decide about moving in with him or marriage before fully investigating that.

category12 · 15/08/2026 10:04

Depends.

If you're intending to leave your estate to your dc, it's probably simpler if you don't marry. (Although there's talk of laws changing regarding unmarried couples living together.)

If you buy a home together, would you want him to get your half of it if you died, or would you want your kids and get it (and will you want to ensure he doesn't have to sell up and leave the home?)

All boring and unromantic financial stuff that needs to be considered, sadly.

GreyCarpet · 15/08/2026 10:07

You are right to say no to getting married if you don’t want to and it is as simple as that. Noone can really tell you if you are right or wrong, it is up to you.

Opened the thread to say exactly the same thing.

And now I'm going back to read your post

And, no, you're still not wrong.

Besides, its not a permanent decision. You might decide you feel differently in the future and that's ok too.

Minasama · 15/08/2026 10:09

This didn’t feel right to you and so it is ok.

However I think you should talk with him and explaining that your issue is with marriage currently and not with him because some people will not see the point in continuing with a relationship if marriage has been ruled out. It sounds as if your life would not be better without him in it?

Catza · 15/08/2026 10:09

Nobody can answer it for you. Although, at this stage in life I don't see what marriage adds to your relationship.
I am very protective of my finances for various historical reasons and I am not happy with the idea that someone can put a claim on my assets. Granted, I can't see my current partner doing that but you don't really ever fully know the person. So I am quite clear in my mind that I will never marry. Every now and then, I think it would be lovely to make a formal commitment but these are passing thoughts. In all honesty, I am not even convinced I'd want to live with someone again.

Elieza · 15/08/2026 10:17

id want to be sure he understands your reasoning and knows how happy you are with him just now. so he appreciates youre not planning on splitting up.

whippersnapper55 · 15/08/2026 10:20

I think it's absolutely fine to say you don't want marriage. I know people who have been in a happy relationship for decades ,not married and don't live together! If you're still together in years to come, you may feel differently and that's ok too. Just enjoy the loving relationship you've got for now ☺️

Dozer · 15/08/2026 10:31

You’re focusing on the emotional side of things when in your situation cohabitating and marriage are also about financial / legal / housing, and IMO in your situation the latter should be the higher priority.

INeedAnotherAlibi · 15/08/2026 10:39

No YANBU. I’ve been with DP for 3 1/2 years and wouldn’t accept a proposal at this point. Our DC are still young (ranges teens to junior school age), I wouldn’t want to try and blend families (both of our exes have moved forwards with someone else and the DC have had to navigate that).
He asked you a practical question of ‘Do you want me to propose?’ and you said ‘No’. He didn’t ask you and you said no.
He didn’t ask if you ever wanted to get married again and you said no. He asked if you wanted him to propose..I think he was checking where you were at? You might feel differently in the future but right now, you don’t want him to propose and that’s absolutely fine!

lemonadecar · 15/08/2026 16:11

Thanks everyone. Yes, he’s autistic and had read a thing about if you want a relationship to continue you should propose within two years (!). We love each other and I think he wanted to make sure he’d done what he needed for us to stay together. I’m happy and want to be with him, and so I explained this doesn’t matter to me and isn’t right on a financial basis. I want the kids to inherit my share and am keenly aware of the financial implications.

I asked the question because I do love him and part of me would love a formal commitment and us wearing rings and so on. I never got the chance to do this properly. It’s really useful to hear what people think.

OP posts:
Brandyb · 15/08/2026 16:17

I really wouldn't go there. What will it achieve, other than creating a situation where you then have to do work to ringfence your children's inheritance etc. I can't really see what this would be except a romantic gesture that has a shit ton of legal implications.

Maybe explain to him that there are other ways of expressing commitment that don't need to be marriage. Have a lovely party in celebration of your partnership?

category12 · 15/08/2026 16:28

You could always do a handfasting type ceremony if you wanted.

Might tick the public commitment/romance box without the legal element.

(People can be a bit sneery about them, but I think it's nice).

Shloopie · 15/08/2026 16:31

Absolutely you were right. Your experience of marriage was awful so you can't afford to be romantic about it again. This way you and your kids financial situation is protected and you can enjoy your lovely new relationship for what it is. If you're still together in 10 years you can revisit the idea, or not!

TheKitchenLady · 16/08/2026 18:24

Sorry to hear you had such a dreadful first marriage - I have experienced similar, and never imagined I would marry again. But here I am happily married to my soul mate. But I would not have married him if I had any doubts whatsoever, so pleased go with what your head tells you, and not just your heart. If you are both happy with the way things are, just enjoy your love for each other - love with the right person is precious, and being happy and content, and enjoying life is what matters most.

As an aside to those casting doubt for financial/legal reasons, I have 3 children and my husband has 1. We have mirror wills, which protect us both when the other dies. On the death of the second of us, my portion of our estate goes to my children, and his portion goes to his child. Quite a straight-forward legal agreement.

Jolouhan · 16/08/2026 19:26

I think there are other options too. I was in a not entirely dissimilar position, and my partner and I decided to get non legally married - we exchanged vows and rings in a form that suited us, and referred to ourselves as husband and wife. We did this in a very small way (on our own in a place that had meaning for us, although we told all our families etc and had a meal when we got back) but you could easily do it the format of a wedding if you wanted.

A number of years later and circumstances had changed, he had health issues and my finances around the (now grown) children were not so complicated and we then actually got legally married - registry office, 7 guests, lunch out (and haven’t actually told our families about that 😂).

Public declarations of commitment and love don’t have to be a formal marriage - they can be whatever works for those involved.

Doone22 · 17/08/2026 08:26

The only thing marriage gives you is legal and financial protection. If you don't need them does he? If neither of you need them what are his feelings? Will he be upset not to be married? You can do other equally symbolic rituals like a wiccan wedding etc

chocoluv · 17/08/2026 08:28

I would be careful that you’re not lowering your own boundaries just to keep someone else happy/you’ve been convinced it’s the norm.

I never want to get married and my stance will never change on that.
There’s nothing wrong with that.

You don’t want to get married, you’re only questioning yourself because he said it.

Be honest that you do not want a proposal and give yourself a couple more years and then think about it again.

3luckystars · 17/08/2026 08:31

Don’t marry him. Don’t doubt yourself.

Apdjvt · 17/08/2026 09:00

I won’t be marrying again; I wouldn’t put myself into the position of being financially vulnerable after being burnt by this in a marriage.

SweetnsourNZ · 18/08/2026 12:08

TheKitchenLady · 16/08/2026 18:24

Sorry to hear you had such a dreadful first marriage - I have experienced similar, and never imagined I would marry again. But here I am happily married to my soul mate. But I would not have married him if I had any doubts whatsoever, so pleased go with what your head tells you, and not just your heart. If you are both happy with the way things are, just enjoy your love for each other - love with the right person is precious, and being happy and content, and enjoying life is what matters most.

As an aside to those casting doubt for financial/legal reasons, I have 3 children and my husband has 1. We have mirror wills, which protect us both when the other dies. On the death of the second of us, my portion of our estate goes to my children, and his portion goes to his child. Quite a straight-forward legal agreement.

Can that not be changed though, by the remaining partner. Or a new partner could still make claim if your new laws come in. I'm not sure of UK laws.

category12 · 18/08/2026 17:10

TheKitchenLady · 16/08/2026 18:24

Sorry to hear you had such a dreadful first marriage - I have experienced similar, and never imagined I would marry again. But here I am happily married to my soul mate. But I would not have married him if I had any doubts whatsoever, so pleased go with what your head tells you, and not just your heart. If you are both happy with the way things are, just enjoy your love for each other - love with the right person is precious, and being happy and content, and enjoying life is what matters most.

As an aside to those casting doubt for financial/legal reasons, I have 3 children and my husband has 1. We have mirror wills, which protect us both when the other dies. On the death of the second of us, my portion of our estate goes to my children, and his portion goes to his child. Quite a straight-forward legal agreement.

Do you mean a mutual will rather than a mirror will?

As far as i understand it, mirror wills can be changed at any time and the survivor can rewrite their will and do what they like.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page