Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Charlie Lamdin/Moving Home With Charlie

3 replies

ComeOnTurtle · 19/11/2026 09:22

I see this chap mentioned on here quite a lot so wondered what people thought of him and the recent furore about his Best Agent site.

I quite like his podcasts/videos, think he's good at identifying things that don't work in the property market and explaining how the economics of estate agency affect that market (eg EAs competing against one another to value higher to get seller business, leave sellers unsold for ages then suggest they drop the price. Also the proportion of EA profit that comes from mortgage and conveyancing referrals rather than sales, meaning that EAs want to list your house even if they know they won't sell it). He's also quite a bullshitter though so you have to take some of the stuff with a pinch of salt.

OTOH the whole Best Agent thing (if anyone is following that) seems a bit dodgy- web scraping agents' listings, not including the name of the agent on the site, so if you see a house on Best Agent you like you have to inquire through them, and the original EA only receives your enquiry if they pay a fee. If they choose not to pay (for an enquiry based on their own scraped listing/IP) then they never receive your enquiry and you are never told this.

Wondered if anyone had any thoughts. Suspect most people will have no idea who I'm talking about 😂

OP posts:
XVGN · 19/11/2026 10:17

I'm someone who has mentioned MHWC quite a lot. I understand that many people are put off by him and his demeanour. I can cherry-pick the detail of his messages from the personality and that's what I do. It's useful.

However, I have never looked at his Best Agent stuff. I wouldn't even know what the USP is for his own scraping service. For me, you cannot beat RM with the addition of the Area360 Add-in.

Another person whose style can offend the senses (calling EA's boys and girls in his early days - "maaaaate") is Christopher Watkins. Again, ignore the EA personality and observe the data - UK Property Market Stats Show on YT.

Sheeshbee · 19/11/2026 11:21

I feel like the best-agent scraping functionality is a stopgap so they have listings to work with while developing the site further.

A - They clearly want to replace rightmove eventually, and rightmove charge agents to be listed & for referrals, so it's really a normal business model.
B - It's easy for estate agents to block the automated website scraping if they want.

Charlie comes across as a bit of a dick, and is a real house price crash doom monger, but equally the reforms he's suggesting all make sense. The house listing portals are currently very stagnant, stale and are not going to improve anything further, even though free browser extensions show how easy it'd be.

They should be very worried about AI eating their lunch.

p.s. I spent 3 months trying to report to Rightmove that their railway station data is out of date (3 new stations near me) and despite sending them this, responding to emails, their data is still wrong. Hope it's fixed before I come to sell my place, as being 0.4 vs 2 miles from a station is rather more appealing.

ComeOnTurtle · 19/11/2026 11:53

Sheeshbee · 19/11/2026 11:21

I feel like the best-agent scraping functionality is a stopgap so they have listings to work with while developing the site further.

A - They clearly want to replace rightmove eventually, and rightmove charge agents to be listed & for referrals, so it's really a normal business model.
B - It's easy for estate agents to block the automated website scraping if they want.

Charlie comes across as a bit of a dick, and is a real house price crash doom monger, but equally the reforms he's suggesting all make sense. The house listing portals are currently very stagnant, stale and are not going to improve anything further, even though free browser extensions show how easy it'd be.

They should be very worried about AI eating their lunch.

p.s. I spent 3 months trying to report to Rightmove that their railway station data is out of date (3 new stations near me) and despite sending them this, responding to emails, their data is still wrong. Hope it's fixed before I come to sell my place, as being 0.4 vs 2 miles from a station is rather more appealing.

If it's a stopgap then I agree- no problem at all if they have their own paid listings rather than scraping. I think if they are scraping and then trying to charge after the event it's a bit different unless they make clear to enquirers that their enquiry might not be forwarded.

Agree there are lots of issues with Rightmove!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread