Does this make sense ??

[TheOriginalNutcracker]

Which member of your family do you get on best with ??

Does it ??

With which member of your family do you get on with the most / best?

Oh yes, i agree it could be written better, but does it not make sense anyway ??

Just wondering really because it was a question ds (8) wrote as part of his homework and the teacher commented that it didn't make sense.

I thought it was rather nit picky, but then I am a bit sensitive about ds and school atm so I am willing to be corrected.

Not grammatically correct but certainly good enough for an 8 year old I would think.

Or is she saying that it doesn't make sense in that you wouldn't ask which family member you got on best with?

Either way- bit nit picky IMO.

He had picked a character from a film and had to write 5 questions to ask them.

He is struggling alot with school atm, and homework is an absolute nightmare, so the fact that even did it at all is a miracle. His teacher is aware he is struggling and so i felt that there was just no need for her comment.

Ds takes everything to heart, and when he read it he said 'see i knew i'd do it wrong'.