Sorry op this wasn’t in reference to you nowadays. Just in response to the historical comment about lots of people having kids older in the past. When people were on like pregnancy 15 by mid forties and life expectancy was low etc. I personally didn’t think that was relevant to you.
Life expectancy is good in the year 2026. No reason why your littlest wouldn’t have you for 40+ years.
Loads of men have a kid at 44. I don’t think many people would say to a prospective 1st time dad not to bother as he’s too old! So from that POV 44 is not too old if you are able to fall pregnant/ have a healthy pregnancy.
If you have the time/ funds/ space for another baby not to impact the lives negatively of the kiddies you already have - then go for it. It’s your family. If you both want another it’s not anyone’s business. I’m not sure in the long run 4 or 5 would make a huge difference.
I would take the time to sit and consider life for each individual member of your family and consider the impact. Not just now - but over the years. Will another sibling be a barrier to any of them having space, privacy, funds for trip, hobbies, help starting out as adults? Especially for your eldest kids.
Also just be aware when the peri/ menopause years hit you could well find a huge drop in energy. If you had a bad sleeper and Peri kicked in when baby still young it could be really rough on everyone. All the health/ impact/ energy level comments are relevant but I do think slightly less so as you have 2 yr old so not much age gap there.
Good luck with your decision. Either way enjoy your lovely family whichever path you choose xxx