Bouncer or swing? Which is more useful?

[AuntieMaggie]

I had a swing for my first DC but remember that they looked a bit uncomfortable and hunched over in it so thought maybe a swing would be better? Which did you find more useful? And any recommendations for one?

Trouble is what one baby loves another hates. Where’s your original
Swing now? If you can get that back
You can have
Both a swing and a
Bouncer!

I had both for my daughter and she loved both, they both had a vibrating feature. The swing was at my house and the bounced at my mother in laws and she settled in both. I think it depends on the baby, I originally only bought a swing but my MIL got a bouncer for when I visited which was quite often. I'm pregnant with twins this time and I've bought two bouncers and still have my daughters swing chair, so I'll rotate between the two.

Trouble is what one baby loves another hates I'm hoping that means this baby will like the Moses basket cos my first one hated it!

Yes I still have the swing like the attached so you can see it's not very supportive when they're little or fall asleep. I also have an old basic bouncer but thinking about a vibrating one...

This is the swing I had for my daughter and will use for my twins. It's very supportive, and you can adjust the seat so it's in different positions. I've got two bouncers as well but that's just for when one is in the swing or if both of them don't like the swing. It's awkward because you don't know if they will like the sensation of the swing or not

My daughter hated her Moses basket as well 🤦🏻‍♀️ much preferred being cuddled which lead to zero sleep

My daughter loathed the swing and only liked the expensive Baby Bjorn bouncer 🙄