Well I emptied out one of the kids toy crates and put the pup in that next to my bed last night with her blanket and she was fine!! She did whine a bit at first but I kept stroking her until she settled then she woke up during the night about 2-3 times so I took her downstairs and outside for a wee then back to her box. Got up with her then about 6am. Quite pleased but dh still not convinced a crate is a good idea. Also managed to get her to poo outside too so going well!! Never thought I'd be quite so enthusiastic about dog poo though