Please or to access all these features

Pedants' corner

Erroneous pedantry

30 replies

Prekoc2 · 13/11/2026 21:00

I'm increasingly seeing mistakes made by people who clearly think they are being very careful to use correct grammar and/or punctuation but are actually committing horrific solecisms, and wondered whether anyone else has noticed this?

Some examples:

  1. This old chestnut: He gave it to my husband and myself / He came to my husband and I's house for dinner.
  2. Extra spaces before brackets ( like this) and before certain punctuation marks; like this !
  3. Unnecessary commas between repeated words, i.e. "He said that, that was the last time he would help her out," or "At that point I had, had it for three months".

and probably the oddest one:

  1. Commas between subject and verb, i.e. "Our company, has been asked to arrange a meeting with you [at least they didn't say "with yourself", I suppose...] or "Fred and I, will be coming to visit you tomorrow."

Where are these "rules" coming from?

Doubtless I've made a Muphry's Law error somewhere, but I hope that doesn't invalidate my point and at least some fellow pedants will know what I'm talking about and have noticed it as well.

OP posts:
Prekoc2 · 15/11/2026 17:09

HoppityBun · 15/11/2026 12:08

I don’t think it’s much to do with not understanding the grammar.

There seems to be an aversion to saying “me” or “I” when it’s correct to do so. There’s a feeling that “myself” is somehow better. I don’t have the headspace to analyse it. But QE2 used to be laughed at for her “my husband and I“.

I'd say there's a much stronger aversion to using "me" than to using "I", which is why you see solecisms such as, "It belongs to my husband and I."

But yes, "myself" has somehow become viewed as more polite, or more educated, as opposed to simply being for reflexive or emphatic purposes.

I realise language as a whole can have different "levels", but it's bonkers that what is simply a set of grammatical rules gets misconstrued in this way as implying degrees of politeness.

OP posts:
Prekoc2 · 15/11/2026 17:12

OneZanyMintQuoter · 15/11/2026 17:04

Doesn't matter, everything will be AI / autocorrectes

I'm pretty confident it's not. Otherwise how do you explain people using these errors in speech?

OP posts:
SisterTeatime · 15/11/2026 17:16

I’ve seen a lot of incorrect ‘and I’ recently (in a work context), as well as ‘Her and the King’ errors online, even on news sites. I wonder if that’s partly because ‘he and the Queen’ would be correct and people are getting confused.

Fakeplasticchimneyswhy · 15/11/2026 18:01

I sometimes (probably incorrectly) use ‘myself’ instead of ‘I’ because as a PP pointed out, “my husband and I” followed by a verb makes you sound like the late QE who had a very distinctive and posh way of speaking. “Me and my husband” is clearly wrong in this context and this was drummed into me as a child.

Interestingly, my late mother who spoke very correctly in 1950s BBC English used to label the backs of photos in which she featured with ‘self’ rather than ‘me’ or ‘I’.

PleasantPedant · 15/11/2026 18:37

People complain about posters putting two spaces after a full stop. That’s what we were explicitly taught to do way back in the 20th century.
Not me. It was a single space after a full stop. I wasn't a typist.

...used to label the backs of photos in which she featured with ‘self’...
Quite normal.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page