I have a potentially unpopular or very different viewpoint to many here. I had to ask ai for help with it. I am posting a lot today to not think about some stress I cannot fix right now.
This is your son who clearly does not feel ready to be independent yet. He will always be your son. When children are not fully launched, we do what we can to help them. I feel this is not about guilt but about duty and love and also a weird kind of parental self-interest about wanting to get parenting right. Let's face it, as mums we want our kids to thrive. And lots of us may hope for future grandchildren who are raised in a secure home.
Having a house in the future is a great asset that makes retirement much easier, with housing outperforming other investments. Letting go of that security without marriage is a big step, as it sounds as though you would be unable to purchase the same again. I wonder if this may be a background factor in your hesitation.
I would have struggled immensely if my parents had taken this route of tough love with me. Although I was diagnosed with ADHD as a child, back then many thought you just "grew out of it and became lazy." which took a deacde to sort. I didn't receive the ASD diagnosis that solved the remaining mysteries until I was retirement age, because the diagnosis simply didn't exist yet. Leaving home when I chose to exposed my inability to work without a huge scaffold, so I stopped working and had to return many times before I met my DH. I am so glad my parents were just there for me. For decades it looked like I wasn't trying hard enough, and plenty of people had the tough love advice. But my parents trusted they had raised us well and knew there was more to the story without needing proof.
From your replies, we have no idea why your son is having these issues. He can drive and hold down a job, so he clearly isn't like me, yet your son's dysfunction, the messy room, the lack of planning, and the high emotions are close enough to some of what I went through at that age that I am identifying with him. But these are simply ways people respond to stress, so it can be from so many things—it could be anything from a vitamin D deficiency to something science hasn't even classified yet. We just don't know.
Your son is employed and has reasonable, not outrageous, desires. However, it does sound as though he may have some impulse issues and a difficult time navigating adulthood. He doesn’t save for his plan, and seems to have emotional control issues.
If you do not trust him to take care of the place, that is a clear sign he isn't ready to be launched yet. It is very common for children to leave the nest much later in the modern day. It simply isn't possible for most to buy a house as young as it was in the past. Once all his money is going toward rent, it will be incredibly difficult for him.
Can you look at other solutions? Can you enlist help from family, or hire a cleaner every week? Can a family member or friend house him, or house sit for you a few times a week? Can you help him find realistic work near your DP? A common strategy for parents of adult children with saving issues is to take some of what they pay in board and put it into an account in their name to establish a savings record—my friend's mum did this secretly and it worked beautifully. Can you help him seek a diagnosis and treatment for whatever ails him? Another solution is for him to just make the commute from your new place if he genuinely can't stand the idea of renting. I know it may not seem it to locals, but in many places in the world, that is not an unreasonable commute time.
Apologies for the length of this post! Thanks for being a good mum stopping to post here and really considering what your son is trying to communicate to you underneath his meltdowns, He sounds unprepared for losing his scaffold. Or he may be an A hole. I hope you both find a gentle way forward.