Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

4 year old lying

15 replies

Firsttimemum2002 · Today 13:54

Hi all, so my 4 year old son lied to me yesterday. About something trivial. I had gone to lay his pjs on his bed for after he got out the bath, and saw that there were a few Pringles on the bed. I had given him some Pringles after school before dinner so clearly he had gone and either ate on his bed or just put them there whilst I was cooking dinner.

He knows he’s not allowed food in the bedroom. When I asked him why they were there he denied it and provided the reasoning that “the wind must’ve blew them off the kitchen table to the bed.” I told him that I wasn’t even that mad he had done it, but the lying is what I’m more disappointed with. I just wanted him to say oops sorry and put them in the bin and say he wouldn’t do it again. Am I expecting too much?! I’m a first time mum so not sure if this is normal or not. I don’t believe he’s ever lied to me before, I feel like we have a really good relationship in general so was a bit shocked that he straight up lied to my face. Also, I wouldn’t say I’m overly harsh with him either I don’t shout or scream or issue extreme punishments ( in this instance all I wanted was for him to clean them up,) but because he flat out refused he had put them there I ended up doing it myself.

Any tips on what I can do to ensure this doesn’t happen again? Not necessarily the Pringles on the bed, I can get over that 🤣 just the blatant dishonesty.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Nutsandghosts · Today 14:01

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn.

Sunshineclouds11 · Today 14:03

They drop little lies in here and there.

something like this I would just explain there was no need to lie, just ask.

Topseyt123 · Today 14:11

Normal behaviour of a child that age.

Just tell him that you know that isn't true and that you are disappointed he blatantly lied to you. Then you still make him clear them up no matter what he claims.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Lavendersong · Today 14:12

He’s 4 and therefore only just learning the ability to lie. It’s completely normal. I’d be more worried if he couldn’t come up with a lie tbh. It’s a developmental milestone. No need to be so dramatic about Pringles otherwise he will just learn to be secretive which is worse

Peonies12 · Today 14:18

Honestly I think you’re making a massive deal of it. Just remind him that food doesnt go in bedroom. Don’t use withholding food as a punishment.

Orangwipe · Today 14:28

Hes not even 60 months old hes still learning its no big deal, you just have to keep telling him, that in this family we dont lie, and you should never feel like you have to either.

Withholding food is a no go for me i hate it when parents do it.
I was raised with a mother Withholding food as a punishment, its a disgusting thing to do to anyone.

Hes only a tiny boy just a friendly kind reminder small talk will sort it.

Lavendersong · Today 15:40

Also why ask him why they’re there. You know exactly why they’re there. It’s a silly question. Just say ‘ I found some Pringles on your bed remember we said no food in your room’ that’s it end of conversation. Short, factual and to the point.

ToddlersAreBananas · Today 15:43

I'm amazed he's never lied before.
Me, about twice a day, 'have you got a dirty nappy?'...
'... no...'

Wemustbetherebynow · Today 15:49

Denise Robertson (wise agony aunt on This Morning, back in the day) had a wise take on this in one of her books, that small children will lie to avoid punishment or to avoid making adults cross. She had the view that this was perfectly normal and it was best to gently correct the child and then to have a think about what the child might be scared of if they told the truth, because that might tell you something about the way you are parenting that you might want to reconsider.

RancidRuby · Today 15:59

I agree with everyone else, it’s normal and all you need to do is just breezily tell him you know that’s not true and to please not lie. His explanation as
to how the Pringles got there was great though, I would’ve been secretly impressed with that if I were you.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · Today 18:10

It’s normal and also a normal part of child development, not being able to lie is more of a worry tbh. His story of the wind blowing them up there is very sweet bless him.

My dd had a naughty fairy that got the blame for lots of things!

Yellowwellyboots · Today 18:15

Gosh, my two year old lies everytime I ask her if she's done a poo.

Bitzee · Today 18:19

Normal part of children development and you kinda did lead him into lying by asking why they were there, which was silly really because you knew exactly what he’d done, but then in his little mind he’s thinking he’ll be in trouble if he tells the truth but he has an opportunity to avoid that by lying. It would have been far better to just say I’ve seen the crumbs, food stays downstairs and shouldn’t have gone up to your room, now you’re going to help me clean it up with the dustpan and brush and if it happens again you’ll have to eat all your snacks at the kitchen table.

Bitzee · Today 18:20

Also he clearly has a lovely imagination with his wind story! Bless him!

Savvysix1984 · Today 18:40

It’s completely normal stage of cognitive development and whilst annoying you should be proud of his creativity. I think you’re making too much of a big deal of it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page