Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Is Mumsnet really that useful for parenting advice? It seems quite toxic…

39 replies

KellyK2026 · 05/11/2026 14:42

I say this because I recently came across a Thread where a mother was talking about screen time for a 12 month old. She said she uses screen time occasionally (approx. 30 mins across the week so she can get jobs done, go to the bathroom, etc.). Honestly, the amount of vitriol she received was horrific and I’d even say it amounted to bullying. From being called a terrible parent, to saying her child is going to be delayed, etc. It was genuinely disgusting to read. I think about all the mums trying their best to juggle everything and, perhaps some are struggling, and this sort of talk really isn’t helpful. I think a lot of people come on here thinking they are the perfect parent (or perfect, person) when they clearly aren’t. I do remember MN being quite useful
years ago, but I’m finding the group-think bullying a bit much now. Has anyone else seen a change in how people interact on here?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
LemonPuppyPorkChop · 06/11/2026 07:36

KellyK2026 · 05/11/2026 16:02

I think what’s also put me off is I had a friend who posted a Thread on something parenting related and faced a lot of backlash. She subsequently asked MN to take the Thread down due to the impact it was having on her mental health. MN was pretty resistant and said they don’t like to remove Threads with a high engagement. It seems like they prioritise engagement other their users’ mental health.

Edited

Of course they do! It’s not a charity, it’s a for-profit site with an enormous, varied set of anonymous users who can change names ad infinitum, not some warm-and-fuzzy MH charity setting. If you wouldn’t post whatever on Reddit, I wouldn’t post it here.

TeensNoMore · 06/11/2026 07:39

I have found the education boards very helpful. For example, without them I wouldn't have known to ask school re extra time, and without the extra time DD1 would have been at least a grade lower across the board.

In more recent years elderly parents has also been very supportive.

Also the SEN boards and MH.

You do need to be a bit careful how you post and be willing to hide the odd thread. A minority come on for a fight even if it is only tangetial to the main issue.

On the other hand you will get clear opinions, no fluffy agreeing just to be nice.

Newbutoldfather · 06/11/2026 08:24

There are some really good intelligent people on here who offer fantastic advice.

However, you have to wade through a lot of really unpleasant posts to take advantage. I kind of get it if someone is seeking advice on continuing an affair or something like that.

OTOH, how is it helpful to say to a stepparent ‘why did you have children with someone who is already a parent’ or to someone struggling with a useless partner ‘why did you breed with a man child’. I don’t understand posters like these.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Lexibletheflexible · 06/11/2026 08:29

Many women enjoy being able to hurt other women and Mumsnet provides a place for them to do it.

havitualcrime · 06/11/2026 08:37

I don’t give parenting advice. People don’t like my parenting advice. I’m old school, don’t take shit, kids know their place, respect authority type and despite the fact I have the most wonderful, best behaved teenagers who I am repeatedly told are the most polite children people have ever met, told by pretty much every parent who has ever had them in their house they’re a credit to me, it’s apparently pure luck and nothing to do with how I have raised them (or I am told to “just you wait”.

I know this isn’t true of course, but tbh I doubt I could help someone who is struggling down the line because I know we are where we are because of the expectations my DH and I set from day 1. Modern parenting has a lot to answer for with the state of society IMHO.

So I’m here for the Christmas and TV threads mostly!

SquirrelSoShiny · 06/11/2026 08:50

MN used to have a really well educated user base but increasingly I find posters either have poor reading comprehension or deliberately misread so they can troll the OP. It's all a bit uncanny valley these days.

Totaldramallama · 06/11/2026 09:46

Over the years on MN I have started maybe 2-3 threads asking for help with particular parenting issues and always deeply regretted it.

Even light-hearted threads often go down like a lead balloon because MN seems to have no sense of humour. I started a thread once about childhood films that you've rewatched and been surprised by the inappropriate content now you're an adult and people got so upright about me being upright. It was bizarre, though lots of responses were funny and in the spirit of the conversation. I had been quite surprised by the word Bitch being shouted loudly in the film Casper, not once but TWICE! I wasn't angry about it just thought it was an interesting thing to discuss and apparently I was unreasonable 😂

FranCockerelVoice · 06/11/2026 14:15

@Newbutoldfather , OTOH, how is it helpful to say to a stepparent ‘why did you have children with someone who is already a parent’ or to someone struggling with a useless partner ‘why did you breed with a man child’. I don’t understand posters like these.

It's not helpful. What's shocked me is the number of posters who get into a relationship with a recently-separated father, gladly take on the 'step-parenting' role for his usually young children, then find themselves becoming mothers themselves, and the father does not 'help' and prioritises his EOW children.

In the 1960s and 1970s women were sold the promise of 'having it all', but we ended up doing it all instead.

Blackandyellow65 · 06/11/2026 14:36

I don’t ask for advice on here anymore, and I think anyone asking for health advice should have their thread removed immediately. I queried about a health issue I was experiencing and was completely piled on when I said I was debating on going to a and e, to the point I was convinced I must have been as stupid as everyone was telling me. About 10 hours after coming off the thread I was blue lighted to an and e and me and my unborn child (I didn’t even know I was pregnant) almost died. When I came back on here with an update and advice not to listen to all the ‘know it all’ mnetters on here, I then got absolutely torn apart for being dumb enough to listen to strangers online. People on mn DETEST anyone seeking medical help for anything at all it seems. I remember shortly after someone posting about seeking help for a scald which had blistered, she got jumped on for wasting time for a ‘minor’ injury. Until she posted a photo of it and it was one of the most horrific burns I’d ever seen and every person on here soon changed their tune

TY78910 · 06/11/2026 14:40

Yeah, mental. I stay away from screen time and sweets / snack / car seat (rear vs front facing) threads. According to those you must purée everything with not a sprinkle of seasoning, cut up grapes until the child is 16, rear face them until 18, not a single sweet or chocolate - a rich tea biscuit once in a while is fine and absolutely NO screen time until they’re 21. Don’t even put the telly on.

Whywouldiknowthat · 06/11/2026 14:43

I don’t mind and in fact welcome direct and clear.

But the number of threads that just shriek ‘parent them / what are the consequences / boundaries’ makes me roll my eyes to the ceiling. That and ‘have you taken him to the GP to be assessed yet?’ There is no nuance at all.

KaleidoscopeSmile · 06/11/2026 14:48

Honestly these interminable "everyone on MN is horrible and toxic" posts are in the same vein as the ridiculous "all the mothers at the school gates are bitches" ones.

We all know it's not true and that MN is no more "toxic" - since you insts on the word - than any other widely-used general forum

Why are you here if you're so appalled by it? Really, why?

FranCockerelVoice · 06/11/2026 14:51

@KaleidoscopeSmile , Why are you here if you're so appalled by the OP?

ThisWiseRobin · 06/11/2026 14:53

KaleidoscopeSmile · 06/11/2026 14:48

Honestly these interminable "everyone on MN is horrible and toxic" posts are in the same vein as the ridiculous "all the mothers at the school gates are bitches" ones.

We all know it's not true and that MN is no more "toxic" - since you insts on the word - than any other widely-used general forum

Why are you here if you're so appalled by it? Really, why?

I think you just proved the point

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread