Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

Was my neighbour dismissive about me considering an elective C-section after trauma?

29 replies

MumLifeUnfiltered · 18/08/2026 21:12

I've been trying to conceive for a few months. I have a daughter from a previous relationship who is almost 12. I was speaking to my neighbour about giving birth as she's just had a baby via planned C Section 4 weeks ago.

Back story: I had an extremely traumatic birth with my daughter, 80+ hours of labour, admitted to hospital at 2cm dilated as they were concerned, 3rd degree tear and episiotomy, failed ventouse and forceps delivery due to my daughter getting stuck in the birth canal. I ended up going to theatre for an hour so they could sew me up and repair the tear and cut as it was too difficult to do in the room. I was then readmitted to hospital 5 days post partum due to having a severe infection and needing IV antibiotics for a few days. I also had to be under a Gynecologist for 7 years due to my scar tissue not healing correctly, I had to have physio on my scar for 3 years and I've had to have 3 surgeries to help with the pain. I have been discharged from the gynaecologist for a few years now as the final surgery seemed to work(still have some pain every now and then).

Anyway on to the actual conversation now. I mentioned that I may look into an elective C section due to everything I went through with my daughter and everything after. She basically told me that I would be stupid to do that and I should just give birth naturally as any kind of natural labour is nowhere near as bad as having a C Section. I get that C Sections aren't the easy option and is MAJOR abdominal surgery. I haven't even made a decision I just said I was considering it as an option as was told by my Gynaecologist that it would probably be the best route for me if I have any more children. It made me really really shit like she was saying that what I went through wasn't traumatic and like she was diminishing it. Am I overreacting feeling this way? I never said anything to her at the time I just moved on from the conversation but it's left me feeling a bit upset.

OP posts:
ExplodingSmittens · 19/08/2026 09:30

I know all the benefits of natural birth for the baby. Even knowing that when my BF said she was considering an ELCS for her second I said I thought it was a great idea. She hadn’t experienced half of what you went through with her first but it was bad enough. She said the experience was so mire chilled than her first birth and actually recovered more quickly than her natural birth.

I would try not to focus too much on the opinion of your neighbour, she’s a new mum and she’s probably exhausted.

In your situation I’d follow your Obstetrician’s advice.

WeddingDressguest · 19/08/2026 09:32

Because she's in agony, just having had one. The pain is a very recent and real memory for her.

Side from that, I don't understand why you're detailing all your problems with birth trauma to your neighbour. You call her your neighbour, not your friend

Just keep it yourself - your birth plans are not your neighbours business.

You're not even pregnant yet. I shudder to think what you'll be like when you actually are ANd people are making all sorts of comments which they always do.

Coconutter24 · 19/08/2026 09:38

It’s odd that she’s had such a great experience and happy to share that after having an elective C section. I would have asked if you’ve had such a great experience why wouldn’t you recommend it?

noramoo · 19/08/2026 10:00

People get very defensive around birth choices - it's understandable in many ways but can be uncomfortable to navigate. At the end of the day it's 100% your choice and nobody should question that. Anecdotally I had an elective C section and it was a very positive experience.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page