Please or to access all these features

Other subjects

Do you believe in angels / things happen for a reason ?

101 replies

TheCleverGreySheep · 09/11/2026 19:12

Just wondering peoples thoughts…. There’s been a few things happen to me, that seem like someone is watching over me . ( things that could have gone so wrong, but somehow havnt. I see signs now again too.

Im hoping to get pregnant one day.. i just wondered if anyone has ever had the same ?

OP posts:
scalt · 12/11/2026 22:32

The usual classic sneering Mumsnet replies when anyone asks a question like this.

Eyesopenwideawake · 12/11/2026 22:39

No. We're as irrelevant as an single ant in the universe.

Nomura · 12/11/2026 22:53

Sannabay · 12/11/2026 22:16

It's complicated

It's not, its perfectly within context of God distinguising between Jesus, the Son of God, who created and sustains everything and angels as ministering beings. Proving that Christ is greater than angels, an issue for some believers.

mondaytosunday · 12/11/2026 23:35

Nope. Things don’t happen ‘for a reason’, if they do then it’s a very very cruel system. My daughter’s MS diagnosis at 17 - what good has that done her? None at all. My husband’s sudden death at 51? I cannot think of one positive result from that. I could go on. And on. Sure there are challenges in life and we grow from them but that’s not the same thing at all. And random good things? That’s not an angel looking out for you, they just happen, and a lot less than random bad things.

RedTagAlan · 13/11/2026 05:06

Sannabay · 12/11/2026 20:58

Now now. I didn't say Google it.

Christian Theology is a huge subject.

The simple answer re angels is to refer to the website I suggested. There there is a useful summary of biblical evidence for and first person accounts of angelic experiences.

The " churches" teaching about angels is a whole other subject.

Edited

You did say "google it" though. Quote "It's easier if I give you a website called Got questions. If you Google this and type angels in the search it will come up. "

Totally fair enough if you don't like pasting links to here though. I got this site.

GotQuestions.chat - Bible Questions & Answers

But what I asked was "Where does the Bible explain what angels are?". I think that should be easy. Just book, chapter and verse. As @Nomura posted: " (Hebrews 1:14) “Are not all angels ministering spirits sent to serve those who will inherit salvation?"

But that does not explain what they are. It is asking what they are. And here is Biblehub page on what they are.

What Does the Bible Say About Angels: Nature, Hierarchy and Mission | BibleVerseHub

From that article, we get this, second paragraph in :

"The problem is that the most common questions about angels rarely find answers grounded in Scripture. Most of what circulates in popular understanding about guardian angels, angelic hierarchies or how to recognize an angel's presence comes from extra-biblical traditions, apocryphal literature or simple cultural speculation. The Bible says a great deal about angels — but not everything said about angels actually comes from the Bible."

So there we have it. The Bible does not say. Except for this of course. "apocryphal literature". And that is why I mentioned the book of Enoch above. Because that is where much of the angel stuff comes from. But that was excluded from the Bible, even though it is referenced in the Bible. In Genesis 6:2 for example.

Gen 6:2 and the sons of God see that they, the daughters of men, [are] beautiful, and they take women for themselves of all whom they have chosen. (LSV)

That is a reference to Enoch. But it mentions "the sons of God ". So when the men of the early Church sat together and decided what this religion would be, they dropped Enoch, because of course, there is only supposed to be ONE son of GOD.

Enoch is a mad book. It can be found on this site linked below, along with many of the orher apocryphal texts. These are the Bible books that were left out of the Bible, but much of the stuff in them is still used by Churches.

Gnostic Library (othergospels.com)

The Infancy Gospel of Thomas is a good one by the way. There was quite an industry back in the day for writing gospels. And the Church Fathers were very selective on what made the cut, when they were inventing this new religion.

GotQuestions.chat - Bible Questions & Answers

Find answers to your Bible questions from trusted Christian resources. AI-powered search through GotQuestions.org content.

https://www.gotquestions.chat/

Zuve · 13/11/2026 05:37

Yes.

della74 · 13/11/2026 06:26

Believing everything happens for a reasons means we don't have the responsibility of thinking we are the cause.

Ratherhaveacupofteaandabiscuit · 13/11/2026 06:36

To quote Catherine Tate’s Nan
”What a load of old shit”

lottiegarbanzo · 13/11/2026 06:39

You’re hoping to get pregnant? Ok, that requires an egg a sperm and good timing.

lottiegarbanzo · 13/11/2026 06:45

Things happen for a reason in the sense that things follow from previous events, behaviours, knowledge, choices. Those are the reasons that make an event more likely.

So you become pregnant for a reason - that you had sex at a fertile time. That sex, the choices that led to the relationship it resulted from, those are the reasons.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 13/11/2026 06:54

I don't believe in the existence of deities or other supernatural beings such as angels and suchlike, and no, I don't believe things "happen for a reason", or in nebulous concepts like "fate", "luck", "evil", and so on. Human beings struggle with randomness and chaos, because we're naturally predisposed to see order and patterns in things even when and where there are none, so imaginations have invented these concepts as a way of rationalising the "shit happens" aspect of the universe and everything in it.

It's also another example of the pomposity of humanity, and our constant habit of centering ourselves and presuming everything which happens is related to us or because of us in some way, because we're somehow super-special and the universe makes special allowances for us. It's nonsense. We're a total insignificance and the universe couldn't give a hoot.

sorrynotathome · 13/11/2026 06:59

No. @TheCleverGreySheep why are you so special that you get an angel and millions/billions of others don’t?

Sherararara · 13/11/2026 07:02

Nope

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 08:13

RedTagAlan · 13/11/2026 05:06

You did say "google it" though. Quote "It's easier if I give you a website called Got questions. If you Google this and type angels in the search it will come up. "

Totally fair enough if you don't like pasting links to here though. I got this site.

GotQuestions.chat - Bible Questions & Answers

But what I asked was "Where does the Bible explain what angels are?". I think that should be easy. Just book, chapter and verse. As @Nomura posted: " (Hebrews 1:14) “Are not all angels ministering spirits sent to serve those who will inherit salvation?"

But that does not explain what they are. It is asking what they are. And here is Biblehub page on what they are.

What Does the Bible Say About Angels: Nature, Hierarchy and Mission | BibleVerseHub

From that article, we get this, second paragraph in :

"The problem is that the most common questions about angels rarely find answers grounded in Scripture. Most of what circulates in popular understanding about guardian angels, angelic hierarchies or how to recognize an angel's presence comes from extra-biblical traditions, apocryphal literature or simple cultural speculation. The Bible says a great deal about angels — but not everything said about angels actually comes from the Bible."

So there we have it. The Bible does not say. Except for this of course. "apocryphal literature". And that is why I mentioned the book of Enoch above. Because that is where much of the angel stuff comes from. But that was excluded from the Bible, even though it is referenced in the Bible. In Genesis 6:2 for example.

Gen 6:2 and the sons of God see that they, the daughters of men, [are] beautiful, and they take women for themselves of all whom they have chosen. (LSV)

That is a reference to Enoch. But it mentions "the sons of God ". So when the men of the early Church sat together and decided what this religion would be, they dropped Enoch, because of course, there is only supposed to be ONE son of GOD.

Enoch is a mad book. It can be found on this site linked below, along with many of the orher apocryphal texts. These are the Bible books that were left out of the Bible, but much of the stuff in them is still used by Churches.

Gnostic Library (othergospels.com)

The Infancy Gospel of Thomas is a good one by the way. There was quite an industry back in the day for writing gospels. And the Church Fathers were very selective on what made the cut, when they were inventing this new religion.

Red tag

Thing is I have a dilemma.
Gotta take the whole counsel of God.

So Jesus Christ came to save sinners.
People if they do not take Gods offer of salvation found in Jesus Christ seriously will have to answer to God on the day of judgement. It is appointed to men (and women) once to die and after this the judgement.
All our good works are like filthy rags, salvation is found in no one except Jesus Christ. This is apostolic Christian orthodox teaching.
So back to the OP. They asked about angels.
I referred them to a source, much as a teacher in yesteryore would refer a student to a book.
Now to you Red Tag. You are a pagan. You have stated you don't believe the faith that was handed down to me by my ancestors, I'd my ma n pa, their ma and ps before them etc.
So now to my dilemma. I'm to take the whole counsel of my God.
Jesus said "Don't cast pearls before swine,"

Or they will turn around attack you. (Not a direct quote sorry my paraphrase).
So you can see why I won't be engaging any longer in discussions of this nature with you.

I do hope you can understand my position.
I respect your beliefs.
But do remember that I came on this thread to answer a question. Not to engage in mindless semantic games and endure disrespect.

Ps thank you for yr input on issues on another thread regarding planes being moved out of the UK.

Soz but I haven't time to answer any questions from anyone else in this format. I live in the NW . If anyone wants advice re churches or books or even wants to meet for a coffee to discuss in a genuine way these serious issues. Do pm me.
Thanks and have a great weekend all. X

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 08:15

So by not I'd tut

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 08:41

Oh btw. To encourage fellow believers.

When I did my degree, I had a set text for Christian Ethics year 1. Anyway page one . History of Theological study at university. The universitys were set up by Christians.
Year one was something like astronomy, mathematics or medicine. Then and only when they had mastered those subjects could they progress to the higher study. Theology.

Obviously we have to be discerning what we read. No Christian mumbo jumbo Mickey mouse nonsense.

Hope I have encouraged you today x

Come Lord Jesus! X

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 08:42

Universities.

Sorry re sp only had two coffees.

RedTagAlan · 13/11/2026 08:51

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 08:13

Red tag

Thing is I have a dilemma.
Gotta take the whole counsel of God.

So Jesus Christ came to save sinners.
People if they do not take Gods offer of salvation found in Jesus Christ seriously will have to answer to God on the day of judgement. It is appointed to men (and women) once to die and after this the judgement.
All our good works are like filthy rags, salvation is found in no one except Jesus Christ. This is apostolic Christian orthodox teaching.
So back to the OP. They asked about angels.
I referred them to a source, much as a teacher in yesteryore would refer a student to a book.
Now to you Red Tag. You are a pagan. You have stated you don't believe the faith that was handed down to me by my ancestors, I'd my ma n pa, their ma and ps before them etc.
So now to my dilemma. I'm to take the whole counsel of my God.
Jesus said "Don't cast pearls before swine,"

Or they will turn around attack you. (Not a direct quote sorry my paraphrase).
So you can see why I won't be engaging any longer in discussions of this nature with you.

I do hope you can understand my position.
I respect your beliefs.
But do remember that I came on this thread to answer a question. Not to engage in mindless semantic games and endure disrespect.

Ps thank you for yr input on issues on another thread regarding planes being moved out of the UK.

Soz but I haven't time to answer any questions from anyone else in this format. I live in the NW . If anyone wants advice re churches or books or even wants to meet for a coffee to discuss in a genuine way these serious issues. Do pm me.
Thanks and have a great weekend all. X

Quote " Now to you Red Tag. You are a pagan."

Actually I am not. I am nor a Pagan. I am atheist.

Qiote " Not to engage in mindless semantic games and endure disrespect."

Where is the disrespect ? The thread title is asking if people believe in angels. All I have done is point out that what some people consider to be the concept/description of angels in Biblical terms, is not actually supported by the .... Bible.

Quote "Jesus said "Don't cast pearls before swine,"

Matthew 7:6. Sermon on the mount. Lets look at the context of that verse. It follows on from

Mat 7:-5 "Do not judge, that you may not be judged, for in what judgment you judge, you will be judged, and in what measure you measure, it will be measured to you. And why do you behold the speck that [is] in your brother's eye, and do not consider the beam that [is] in your own eye? Or, how will you say to your brother, Permit [that] I may cast out the speck from your eye, and behold, the beam [is] in your own eye? Hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to cast out the speck out of your brother's eye.
Mat 7:6 You may not give that which is [holy] to the dogs, nor cast your pearls before the pigs, that they may not trample them among their feet, and having turned--may tear you apart.(LSV)

Are you saying I am a pig and that you think I will tear you apart ?

If so, that seems to be another contradiction in the Bible. Because in the same sermon, he says :

Mat 5:44 but I say to you, love your enemies, bless those cursing you, do good to those hating you, and pray for those accusing you falsely, and persecuting you,( LSV).

How does that tie up with the pigs verse later in the same sermon ? Oh, I don't hate anyone by the way.

Anyway, there are no angels or supernatural. There is certainly no evidence at all.

RedTagAlan · 13/11/2026 08:55

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 08:41

Oh btw. To encourage fellow believers.

When I did my degree, I had a set text for Christian Ethics year 1. Anyway page one . History of Theological study at university. The universitys were set up by Christians.
Year one was something like astronomy, mathematics or medicine. Then and only when they had mastered those subjects could they progress to the higher study. Theology.

Obviously we have to be discerning what we read. No Christian mumbo jumbo Mickey mouse nonsense.

Hope I have encouraged you today x

Come Lord Jesus! X

Quote "Come Lord Jesus! X"

Can you explain what this means ? Are you calling for The Rapture ? If so, what version of it ?

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 09:06

RedTagAlan · 13/11/2026 08:51

Quote " Now to you Red Tag. You are a pagan."

Actually I am not. I am nor a Pagan. I am atheist.

Qiote " Not to engage in mindless semantic games and endure disrespect."

Where is the disrespect ? The thread title is asking if people believe in angels. All I have done is point out that what some people consider to be the concept/description of angels in Biblical terms, is not actually supported by the .... Bible.

Quote "Jesus said "Don't cast pearls before swine,"

Matthew 7:6. Sermon on the mount. Lets look at the context of that verse. It follows on from

Mat 7:-5 "Do not judge, that you may not be judged, for in what judgment you judge, you will be judged, and in what measure you measure, it will be measured to you. And why do you behold the speck that [is] in your brother's eye, and do not consider the beam that [is] in your own eye? Or, how will you say to your brother, Permit [that] I may cast out the speck from your eye, and behold, the beam [is] in your own eye? Hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to cast out the speck out of your brother's eye.
Mat 7:6 You may not give that which is [holy] to the dogs, nor cast your pearls before the pigs, that they may not trample them among their feet, and having turned--may tear you apart.(LSV)

Are you saying I am a pig and that you think I will tear you apart ?

If so, that seems to be another contradiction in the Bible. Because in the same sermon, he says :

Mat 5:44 but I say to you, love your enemies, bless those cursing you, do good to those hating you, and pray for those accusing you falsely, and persecuting you,( LSV).

How does that tie up with the pigs verse later in the same sermon ? Oh, I don't hate anyone by the way.

Anyway, there are no angels or supernatural. There is certainly no evidence at all.

Pagan dictionary definition...one among others. A person who doesn't believe. Early churches designation of unbelievers.

Atheist an unbeliever.

I did not call you a swine. I did not say you specifically disrespected me. You're not my brother. Actually you're right though Jesus says I shouldn't judge the unbeliever. God will judge those.

Sorry respectfully Red Alan. I hope I can call you that. You know I'm rubbish at links etc. Did I judge you here?

Cos if I did judge you I'm sorry. That was wrong of me.

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 09:10

RedTagAlan · 13/11/2026 08:55

Quote "Come Lord Jesus! X"

Can you explain what this means ? Are you calling for The Rapture ? If so, what version of it ?

Sorry RA.

That wasn't meant for you.

You don't believe. Why do you persist in this line of questioning. You have already said you have thrown out God's word.

No judgement here. Just curiosity.

Have you ever read the poem. The Hound of Heaven?

Do you like poetry, sorry if you don't. I'm not a fan tbf. But that poem is kinda powerful.

Oh from exegesis to poetry appreciation in two hours (or thereabouts). :)

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 09:17

Umm you're right mindless semantic games was judgemental.

Sorry.

Anyway look I've got to get to work.

And as stated I don't want to get into Theological discussions with you via this medium.

But if you like you can pm me. Or I can signpost you to someone way more intelligent than me. In RL or via the internet.

Hope this helps :)

RedTagAlan · 13/11/2026 09:30

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 09:10

Sorry RA.

That wasn't meant for you.

You don't believe. Why do you persist in this line of questioning. You have already said you have thrown out God's word.

No judgement here. Just curiosity.

Have you ever read the poem. The Hound of Heaven?

Do you like poetry, sorry if you don't. I'm not a fan tbf. But that poem is kinda powerful.

Oh from exegesis to poetry appreciation in two hours (or thereabouts). :)

My point is that for believers in the Rapture, when they say "Come Lord Jesus! X", what they are actually doing is calling for the destruction of the world as we know it. That non Christians burn in hell for eternity and so on, depending on what version is subscribed to.

Yeah, I am an atheist, but that does not mean I should be happy for individuals to proselytize online, and who seek to recruit, to what is effectively a death cult.

You talk about you having to " endure disrespect.", when there is no disrespect, but at the same time it appears you might be praying for, or calling for, the end of the world.

Yup. Sorry to use a thin end of the wedge argument here, but this this is where believing in Angels can lead to.

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 11:21

RedTagAlan · 13/11/2026 09:30

My point is that for believers in the Rapture, when they say "Come Lord Jesus! X", what they are actually doing is calling for the destruction of the world as we know it. That non Christians burn in hell for eternity and so on, depending on what version is subscribed to.

Yeah, I am an atheist, but that does not mean I should be happy for individuals to proselytize online, and who seek to recruit, to what is effectively a death cult.

You talk about you having to " endure disrespect.", when there is no disrespect, but at the same time it appears you might be praying for, or calling for, the end of the world.

Yup. Sorry to use a thin end of the wedge argument here, but this this is where believing in Angels can lead to.

Sounds like you've made up your mind about me and my beliefs Red.

OaO

RedTagAlan · 13/11/2026 12:15

Sannabay · 13/11/2026 11:21

Sounds like you've made up your mind about me and my beliefs Red.

OaO

Not at all. That is why I asked what you meant by "Come Lord Jesus! X". But you did not answer. I am just describing the common meaning of it.

That is why I asked. To find out if that is the meaning you apply to it.

Do you agree that is is often used as a prayer, or a call, for what is called the Rapture to happen ? And that my description of that is what many Christians want to see happen ?