OP, are you me?! I could have written this. I’m the same age as you, DH is a little younger than yours and we have one DD who is 7. Until she was about 5, I was more than happy with one, but since then I’ve had this internal conflict about having another, it hits me every few months! I wonder if it’s reaching late thirties and watching DD grow up that’s brought it on?!
We have a really lovely life. We’re not stressed or stretched, good marriage, financial security and can give DD a brilliant education, let her try whatever activities she likes and travel together to amazing places. I did NOT like the baby stage. I found it boring as hell and genuinely thought I’d ruined my life at times! I love the age she’s at now and the freedom that comes with it.
However… I worry in ten years I might regret not having another, every now and again I imagine us as a family of four. I love the idea of DD having a much younger sibling, someone she could help look after, take to concerts one day and be there for as they grow up. Then I realise that most of my reasons are centred around what another child might bring to DD’s life, rather than what she might lose, what my DH and I really want or the reality of raising another child (that I maybe don’t 100% want?!) and how that might change me as a mum. Who’s to say they would even be close?! I don’t speak to my own sister and I’m certainly not lonely! I also think that if I’m lucky enough to live to 80, DD will be almost 50. Hopefully by then she will have made her own family so won’t be lonely or desperately missing siblings.
I will say two things though. Firstly, whatever you decide, there will be an element of guilt. If you have two, you might feel guilty about being stretched, having less time for each child, sacrificing some freedom, etc. There is always going to be some level of guilt when you have children, regardless of how many you have. Secondly, I genuinely do believe a lot of people have more than one because it’s what society expects. Some probably would have been much happier sticking with one, but they got caught up in the idea of the dream family rather than actually considering the reality of raising two. Ironically, these will be the people who tell you that you should have another whilst you are watching them running around stressed out their heads!
I have absolutely no answers for you (or myself!), but I just wanted to say that you’re definitely not alone in feeling this way!