Please or to access all these features

One-child families

Got questions about only having one child? Find the answers here.

I don’t want another DC but feel guilt for DD’s future

52 replies

Oneandonex · 10/11/2026 12:13

Name changed.
DD is 6. She is a wonderful kid and I am loving this stage of parenting. She is very happy and settled and gets a lot of love and attention from me and DH and we have a good family life.
I have founs the baby stage incredibly difficult. Had a traumatic birth where we risked losing her and she was a high need baby and we didn’t sleep for years. I never want to relive those first 2-3 years again.
In addition to this, we have no family support, work full time, have an expensive mortgage for a small 2 bed home (which we are hoping to upgrade in a few years) and live near London where house and childcare prices are crazy. I am 39 and DH is 45. I have always felt we were one and done and DH is also aligned.

I could continue to list the reasons why I think an only child is the best choice for us as a family and I do truly feel this way. However, I sometimes feel a sense of guilt imagining the day we will no longer be around and feel as if we are letting DD down. I try to stay rational and think that it isn’t necessarily a given that a sibling will be a good source of support later in life as they might not get along or live in different countries etc. I also have plenty of friends who are only children and had/have a lovely life.
Does anyone else feel this guilt? Please refrain from replying things like “we have 2/3/4 kids and you should too, only children are sad” etc. I am interested to speak with fellow parents of only children that share the same thoughts or found a way to get over that.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
LadyInBluee · 10/11/2026 14:01

I feel like threads like this become a bit of an echo chamber with everyone devaluing what having a sibling means. I don’t think it’s bad to have an only child, my DH is an only and is perfectly happy. I have a sibling and I prefer having that extra person (plus their partner, nieces and nephews, cousins for my DC). The truth is most siblings will have some kind of positive relationship throughout their lives. I hope my DC can support each other and be a source of security for one another as they go through life. It also makes the home noisier and my elder DC really benefits from not having parents solely focussed on her. She enjoys the fun her younger sibling brings. We don’t mind the increased juggle of positive as we have somehow embraced the madness of the early years and just with it for now. Also I personally felt something was missing before we had our second. I had this feeling that my children would want to spend time as a family when they are teens and older if a sibling were part of it, not just visiting parents. I’m sure all of our own experiences skew our opinions and everyone has to do what’s right for them, but if you have a happy family then an extra person around the table is generally a lovely thing.

ratheralotofnonsense · 10/11/2026 14:12

@LadyInBluee i think this is it, you say I personally felt something was missing before we had our second

That isn’t to say it’s a bad thing, but it’s just to make the point that it’s just not possible to predict or control adult relationships from decisions you make when your children are young. In other words, no one can say it’s ‘better’ to be an only child or to have siblings - neither is better, there are huge variations and variables in that none of us know what could have been, only what is.

So have the children you want, not the one you think your existing children may or may not want!

BreakfastClub80 · 10/11/2026 14:14

We have an only DD, not by choice. We needed fertility treatment (5 long years) for her and didn’t manage any siblings. So I didn’t feel guilt exactly as there was nothing more I could have thrown at it, and I loved the baby stage etc etc. We appreciated that she was our “one in a million” but it did take time to move on mentally especially in the earlier years when new siblings are appearing regularly in other families.

DD is now 17, and is totally happy being an only child. I’m one of three and sometimes think she might like less attention on her but as she gains independence, we all naturally give each other a bit more space. We’re all close and have a good balance of time together and apart, plus she’s very open with us about her life. We’re also often include her friends in holidays etc so she has company of her own age so as they get a older you can get around some of the disadvantages of being an only (if that type of thing is one for you). So basically, I’m trying to say that your DD is unlikely to miss what she doesn’t have and more likely to appreciate the benefits.

I suspect you’re feeling more sensitive as you’re at the point of making a final decision and this is totally normal. It will take time to feel fully confident after you’ve decided but I don’t think you need to feel guilty or worried for your DD.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 10/11/2026 14:24

LadyInBluee · 10/11/2026 14:01

I feel like threads like this become a bit of an echo chamber with everyone devaluing what having a sibling means. I don’t think it’s bad to have an only child, my DH is an only and is perfectly happy. I have a sibling and I prefer having that extra person (plus their partner, nieces and nephews, cousins for my DC). The truth is most siblings will have some kind of positive relationship throughout their lives. I hope my DC can support each other and be a source of security for one another as they go through life. It also makes the home noisier and my elder DC really benefits from not having parents solely focussed on her. She enjoys the fun her younger sibling brings. We don’t mind the increased juggle of positive as we have somehow embraced the madness of the early years and just with it for now. Also I personally felt something was missing before we had our second. I had this feeling that my children would want to spend time as a family when they are teens and older if a sibling were part of it, not just visiting parents. I’m sure all of our own experiences skew our opinions and everyone has to do what’s right for them, but if you have a happy family then an extra person around the table is generally a lovely thing.

It isn't about "devaluing" what having siblings can mean at all. Of course there can be huge benefits from children having siblings, though those benefits are by no means universal.

But there are also huge benefits to being an only child, so there is no reason for a couple who doesn't want more than one child to feel guilty. You felt that something was missing in your family until you had a second child. Others might not feel that. Or some might still feel that something is missing until they had a third or fourth or fifth child or whatever.

There is no optimal choice, just advantages and disadvantages to whatever model you choose or somehow end up with.

Peonies12 · 10/11/2026 14:49

LadyInBluee · 10/11/2026 14:01

I feel like threads like this become a bit of an echo chamber with everyone devaluing what having a sibling means. I don’t think it’s bad to have an only child, my DH is an only and is perfectly happy. I have a sibling and I prefer having that extra person (plus their partner, nieces and nephews, cousins for my DC). The truth is most siblings will have some kind of positive relationship throughout their lives. I hope my DC can support each other and be a source of security for one another as they go through life. It also makes the home noisier and my elder DC really benefits from not having parents solely focussed on her. She enjoys the fun her younger sibling brings. We don’t mind the increased juggle of positive as we have somehow embraced the madness of the early years and just with it for now. Also I personally felt something was missing before we had our second. I had this feeling that my children would want to spend time as a family when they are teens and older if a sibling were part of it, not just visiting parents. I’m sure all of our own experiences skew our opinions and everyone has to do what’s right for them, but if you have a happy family then an extra person around the table is generally a lovely thing.

Well maybe realise some others never felt anything was ‘missing’? Even when I was single before my DH and DD, nothing was missing for me. The thought of our house being any ‘noisier’ is awful for me. Quantity doesnt equal happiness

Favouritefruits · 10/11/2026 14:53

You feel guilty she’s all on her own, I feel guilty my two can’t have as much as if I’d just had the one. Parenting is one huge guilt trip. Do what’s best for your family and ignore all the guilt! If you had another you’d feel guilt over that too.

JustGoogleIt15 · 10/11/2026 15:32

Having a sibling who is nasty and narcissistic is awful.

Oneandonex · 10/11/2026 15:38

LadyInBluee · 10/11/2026 14:01

I feel like threads like this become a bit of an echo chamber with everyone devaluing what having a sibling means. I don’t think it’s bad to have an only child, my DH is an only and is perfectly happy. I have a sibling and I prefer having that extra person (plus their partner, nieces and nephews, cousins for my DC). The truth is most siblings will have some kind of positive relationship throughout their lives. I hope my DC can support each other and be a source of security for one another as they go through life. It also makes the home noisier and my elder DC really benefits from not having parents solely focussed on her. She enjoys the fun her younger sibling brings. We don’t mind the increased juggle of positive as we have somehow embraced the madness of the early years and just with it for now. Also I personally felt something was missing before we had our second. I had this feeling that my children would want to spend time as a family when they are teens and older if a sibling were part of it, not just visiting parents. I’m sure all of our own experiences skew our opinions and everyone has to do what’s right for them, but if you have a happy family then an extra person around the table is generally a lovely thing.

But you see, the idea of a messy home and more people around isn’t actually appealing to me. I am an introvert and value my own peace and time so having more “chaos” around me isn’t something that would be good for my happiness and mental health. Appreciate it is different for you and that’s great. But the point here is to exchange experience with like minded people who have made the same choices for x reasons.

OP posts:
Oneandonex · 10/11/2026 15:40

Peonies12 · 10/11/2026 14:49

Well maybe realise some others never felt anything was ‘missing’? Even when I was single before my DH and DD, nothing was missing for me. The thought of our house being any ‘noisier’ is awful for me. Quantity doesnt equal happiness

Edited

Yes I never once had the feeling that something was missing, at all. If something, I often have nightmares about having a second DC and the thought of it actually makes me feel sad as I love our family of 3!

OP posts:
LadyInBluee · 10/11/2026 15:42

That’s why I tried to express why another child was appealing to me. I completely get that it’s not the right choice for some families, and I don’t think one is necessarily “better” than the other for children generally either. I was just offering another perspective as I thought you were still weighing up your decision and these threads can sometimes become a chorus of “siblings are worthless” (or words to that effect) which doesn’t really help anyone either.

There’s no need to feel guilt over only having one child if that’s what’s right for you and your family but sometimes that niggle is worth examining to make sure you are fully at peace with your decision.

LadyInBluee · 10/11/2026 15:43

Also to clarify I said to me I felt something was missing - I don’t assume other parents feel that way and I know many very happy one child families. I was just sharing my personal perspective.

Tulipsriver · 10/11/2026 15:45

I have two and firmly believe that, whilst there are pros and cons for having multiple children, having another baby specifically so your existing child isn't alone is the worst reason.

They may not even like their sibling in adulthood!

Have another baby if you desperately want one. But if not, enjoy your daughter and concentrate on all the additional time and resources you can pile on her.

Oneandonex · 10/11/2026 15:46

LadyInBluee · 10/11/2026 15:42

That’s why I tried to express why another child was appealing to me. I completely get that it’s not the right choice for some families, and I don’t think one is necessarily “better” than the other for children generally either. I was just offering another perspective as I thought you were still weighing up your decision and these threads can sometimes become a chorus of “siblings are worthless” (or words to that effect) which doesn’t really help anyone either.

There’s no need to feel guilt over only having one child if that’s what’s right for you and your family but sometimes that niggle is worth examining to make sure you are fully at peace with your decision.

Thank you.
No, as states above, I have zero doubts about the fact that I don’t want another DC. My post was more in relation to guilt towards my daughter’s future once we won’t be here anymore.

OP posts:
Piglet89 · 10/11/2026 15:49

I share exactly the same thoughts. I hate the baby and toddler stage: babies need you all the time, my son didn’t sleep well until we trained him and toddlers are often really annoying - totally irrational and impervious to danger. Just: no.

There is absolutely no way I’d go through three years of that again just so my son can have a sibling which he doesn’t even particularly want.

Do I feel guilt about the possible future when we’re older? Maybe, yes. Still doesn’t override the thought of the baby and toddler stage tho. Shudder

LadyInBluee · 10/11/2026 15:53

There are pros and cons to your daughters future once you won’t be here anymore.

The pros are she will have full share of any inheritance. I know of more than a few siblings who fall out over wills/ inheritance/ caring for parents.

The cons are she will shoulder the loss and practical side of things alone. Yes she may well have a partner or family of her own, but a supportive sibling would be equally responsible for parents in a way that a spouse or partner isn’t. Also a supportive sibling would be someone she could maintain that family connection with.

Having said that it’s not guaranteed that siblings remain close so I think make decisions based on what you want for your family and your life. If you know you are happy with one child then let go of the guilt and enjoy your life.

I stuck with one for years after severe PND and was determined to have one. I couldn’t shake off the feeling of missing something and eventually took the plunge and had DD2. After that I felt relieved, it was the fear of PND stopping me from having the family I wanted. Obviously it’s noisier, more expensive, logistically much more difficult - but despite that it was right for me. Having children on paper is never a good decision it has to be what your heart wants! If you don’t feel that pull then stay as you are. There are many one child families now it’s not unusual. I would only advise you to go for it if you were feeling like you wanted another but something was holding you back but it sounds as if you are perfectly happy as you are.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 10/11/2026 15:58

LadyInBluee · 10/11/2026 15:53

There are pros and cons to your daughters future once you won’t be here anymore.

The pros are she will have full share of any inheritance. I know of more than a few siblings who fall out over wills/ inheritance/ caring for parents.

The cons are she will shoulder the loss and practical side of things alone. Yes she may well have a partner or family of her own, but a supportive sibling would be equally responsible for parents in a way that a spouse or partner isn’t. Also a supportive sibling would be someone she could maintain that family connection with.

Having said that it’s not guaranteed that siblings remain close so I think make decisions based on what you want for your family and your life. If you know you are happy with one child then let go of the guilt and enjoy your life.

I stuck with one for years after severe PND and was determined to have one. I couldn’t shake off the feeling of missing something and eventually took the plunge and had DD2. After that I felt relieved, it was the fear of PND stopping me from having the family I wanted. Obviously it’s noisier, more expensive, logistically much more difficult - but despite that it was right for me. Having children on paper is never a good decision it has to be what your heart wants! If you don’t feel that pull then stay as you are. There are many one child families now it’s not unusual. I would only advise you to go for it if you were feeling like you wanted another but something was holding you back but it sounds as if you are perfectly happy as you are.

Honestly, my husband does way more to help me with my dad than my sibling. It isn't a given that siblings will feel equally responsible and there is no way of getting them to step up and do more if they don't want to.

And honestly, my friends have been a much greater comfort for me since the loss of my mum. I don't have a bad relationship with my sister but we had very different ideas about the funeral etc and I think it would have been so much easier if I had been the only one responsible.

laura246810 · 10/11/2026 16:36

Having an only child doesnt mean they are alone. Just ensure they socialise loads outside school (clubs or your house being the fun house for friends to come over to). Equally children with lots of siblings can be alone in a crowd iyswim.

You shouldnt feel guilty.

Strawberriesandpears · 10/11/2026 17:37

LadyInBluee · 10/11/2026 14:01

I feel like threads like this become a bit of an echo chamber with everyone devaluing what having a sibling means. I don’t think it’s bad to have an only child, my DH is an only and is perfectly happy. I have a sibling and I prefer having that extra person (plus their partner, nieces and nephews, cousins for my DC). The truth is most siblings will have some kind of positive relationship throughout their lives. I hope my DC can support each other and be a source of security for one another as they go through life. It also makes the home noisier and my elder DC really benefits from not having parents solely focussed on her. She enjoys the fun her younger sibling brings. We don’t mind the increased juggle of positive as we have somehow embraced the madness of the early years and just with it for now. Also I personally felt something was missing before we had our second. I had this feeling that my children would want to spend time as a family when they are teens and older if a sibling were part of it, not just visiting parents. I’m sure all of our own experiences skew our opinions and everyone has to do what’s right for them, but if you have a happy family then an extra person around the table is generally a lovely thing.

Couldn't agree more. I fully appreciate that many people do not get on with their siblings or don't see much of them etc, but I think that really devalues what siblings relationships can bring to a person's life. I would love to have a sibling, a brother or sister in law, a niece or nephew but non of these relationships are open to me as an only child (who has a partner who is also an only child). It's literally us against the world, which is a rather lonely place to be.

IButtleSir · 10/11/2026 17:49

My wife and I are completely happy with our decision to only have one. We both agree we are much better parents to one child than we could be to two. We're also much better parents (and people) when we're not horribly sleep deprived, which we were for the first couple of years of our daughter's life. I don't feel any guilt about my decision!

PringlesTowerz · 10/11/2026 19:48

OP, are you me?! I could have written this. I’m the same age as you, DH is a little younger than yours and we have one DD who is 7. Until she was about 5, I was more than happy with one, but since then I’ve had this internal conflict about having another, it hits me every few months! I wonder if it’s reaching late thirties and watching DD grow up that’s brought it on?!

We have a really lovely life. We’re not stressed or stretched, good marriage, financial security and can give DD a brilliant education, let her try whatever activities she likes and travel together to amazing places. I did NOT like the baby stage. I found it boring as hell and genuinely thought I’d ruined my life at times! I love the age she’s at now and the freedom that comes with it.

However… I worry in ten years I might regret not having another, every now and again I imagine us as a family of four. I love the idea of DD having a much younger sibling, someone she could help look after, take to concerts one day and be there for as they grow up. Then I realise that most of my reasons are centred around what another child might bring to DD’s life, rather than what she might lose, what my DH and I really want or the reality of raising another child (that I maybe don’t 100% want?!) and how that might change me as a mum. Who’s to say they would even be close?! I don’t speak to my own sister and I’m certainly not lonely! I also think that if I’m lucky enough to live to 80, DD will be almost 50. Hopefully by then she will have made her own family so won’t be lonely or desperately missing siblings.

I will say two things though. Firstly, whatever you decide, there will be an element of guilt. If you have two, you might feel guilty about being stretched, having less time for each child, sacrificing some freedom, etc. There is always going to be some level of guilt when you have children, regardless of how many you have. Secondly, I genuinely do believe a lot of people have more than one because it’s what society expects. Some probably would have been much happier sticking with one, but they got caught up in the idea of the dream family rather than actually considering the reality of raising two. Ironically, these will be the people who tell you that you should have another whilst you are watching them running around stressed out their heads!

I have absolutely no answers for you (or myself!), but I just wanted to say that you’re definitely not alone in feeling this way!

Oneandonex · 11/11/2026 09:48

PringlesTowerz · 10/11/2026 19:48

OP, are you me?! I could have written this. I’m the same age as you, DH is a little younger than yours and we have one DD who is 7. Until she was about 5, I was more than happy with one, but since then I’ve had this internal conflict about having another, it hits me every few months! I wonder if it’s reaching late thirties and watching DD grow up that’s brought it on?!

We have a really lovely life. We’re not stressed or stretched, good marriage, financial security and can give DD a brilliant education, let her try whatever activities she likes and travel together to amazing places. I did NOT like the baby stage. I found it boring as hell and genuinely thought I’d ruined my life at times! I love the age she’s at now and the freedom that comes with it.

However… I worry in ten years I might regret not having another, every now and again I imagine us as a family of four. I love the idea of DD having a much younger sibling, someone she could help look after, take to concerts one day and be there for as they grow up. Then I realise that most of my reasons are centred around what another child might bring to DD’s life, rather than what she might lose, what my DH and I really want or the reality of raising another child (that I maybe don’t 100% want?!) and how that might change me as a mum. Who’s to say they would even be close?! I don’t speak to my own sister and I’m certainly not lonely! I also think that if I’m lucky enough to live to 80, DD will be almost 50. Hopefully by then she will have made her own family so won’t be lonely or desperately missing siblings.

I will say two things though. Firstly, whatever you decide, there will be an element of guilt. If you have two, you might feel guilty about being stretched, having less time for each child, sacrificing some freedom, etc. There is always going to be some level of guilt when you have children, regardless of how many you have. Secondly, I genuinely do believe a lot of people have more than one because it’s what society expects. Some probably would have been much happier sticking with one, but they got caught up in the idea of the dream family rather than actually considering the reality of raising two. Ironically, these will be the people who tell you that you should have another whilst you are watching them running around stressed out their heads!

I have absolutely no answers for you (or myself!), but I just wanted to say that you’re definitely not alone in feeling this way!

Thanks so much and couldn’t agree more! The people who often ask me about the second child are either completely stressed and running around like crazy all the time (and no thanks I don’t want that life), OR people who are much more privileged than us in terms of family support, money, space etc and therefore have a massive advantage (think being able to leave the kids with young-ish grandparents to go on nice holidays alone as a couple. We would never be able to do that) and having a cleaner, a nanny, a gardener, huge houses and wider support network around. We are not in this position and I know life with 2 would be very hard in our situation.

OP posts:
Blackrosethorn · 11/11/2026 15:40

I think it's a situation with no guarantees either way. She might hate being an only child, she might love it. She might have been best friends with her sibling or maybe not.

I have two children, 3 years apart and they are 4 and 1. I enjoyed being a mum of 1 and found it the perfect balance however I got caught up on the idea that my youngest needed a sibling and anxiety they would be "lonely" without one and I mainly had my second to give my eldest a sibling.

I obviously love my youngest but I absolutely hate my life now. I get very little joy now and everything is just exhausting and hard work and relentless. It may be their ages but who knows. My eldest may have a sibling now but it's come at a great cost to me his mum. If I'd had my time I would have just stuck at one.

And it's ridiculous as I have two siblings who have provided me with no support or anything over the years and don't have children either so I'm not an auntie nor do my children have cousins on my side.

I am not dismissing the very real concerns and feelings of some only children when they feel a lack of sibling relationship and lack of family and I acknowledge them. However the feelings of parents matter too, we're not robots. For many people there is simply not the support in place whether it be family or expensive childcare etc to support a second child. And for many parents, a second child can push them into not coping and have disastrous consequences on mental health.

Oneandonex · 11/11/2026 15:57

Blackrosethorn · 11/11/2026 15:40

I think it's a situation with no guarantees either way. She might hate being an only child, she might love it. She might have been best friends with her sibling or maybe not.

I have two children, 3 years apart and they are 4 and 1. I enjoyed being a mum of 1 and found it the perfect balance however I got caught up on the idea that my youngest needed a sibling and anxiety they would be "lonely" without one and I mainly had my second to give my eldest a sibling.

I obviously love my youngest but I absolutely hate my life now. I get very little joy now and everything is just exhausting and hard work and relentless. It may be their ages but who knows. My eldest may have a sibling now but it's come at a great cost to me his mum. If I'd had my time I would have just stuck at one.

And it's ridiculous as I have two siblings who have provided me with no support or anything over the years and don't have children either so I'm not an auntie nor do my children have cousins on my side.

I am not dismissing the very real concerns and feelings of some only children when they feel a lack of sibling relationship and lack of family and I acknowledge them. However the feelings of parents matter too, we're not robots. For many people there is simply not the support in place whether it be family or expensive childcare etc to support a second child. And for many parents, a second child can push them into not coping and have disastrous consequences on mental health.

So sorry to hear this and I hope things get better for you💐

OP posts:
ratheralotofnonsense · 11/11/2026 16:38

I obviously love my youngest but I absolutely hate my life now. I get very little joy now and everything is just exhausting and hard work and relentless.

I relate to this a lot. I love them both but am really failing them.

zoeslim · 11/11/2026 16:42

In a world of Ai and violence all over the place I would not want a young kid now

Swipe left for the next trending thread