Please or to access all these features

Nurseries

Find nursery advice from other Mumsnetters on our Nursery forum. For more guidance on early years development, sign up for Mumsnet Ages & Stages emails.

Nursery says the extras aren’t included in the funded hours but I never realised it would cost this much

224 replies

Yluna47 · 17/10/2026 10:54

My ds is 2 and has been at nursery since January. He goes 3 days a week while im at work and generally he loves it there, runs in without looking back at me most mornings so no issues with the actual nursery.

He’s eligible for the funded hours now and I thought it would make a decent difference to what we pay but honestly im a bit shocked by the latest invoice. I know its not completely free and I wasn’t expecting to pay nothing but I thought we’d be saving more than we are.

Before the funding we were paying around £610 a month for the 3 days. Now its just over £360. Which is obviously a saving but when I looked at the breakdown there’s £250 for the extra hours, £55 for meals and snacks, £35 consumables and £20 activities. I thought some of this would be included in the funded hours but apparently not.

The meals one is annoying because you have to pay it, they don’t let you send food from home. The consumables is apparently things like wipes, nappies, suncream and craft stuff. He’s potty training so doesn’t use many nappies now and I do wonder what we’re paying for some months, but I know they still have things to buy for all the children. The activities charge is for things like music sessions and other things they do during the week.

I did read the paperwork when he started but if im honest I didn’t properly understand all the funding stuff. It said there would be additional charges and I signed it, so I know I can’t really say I wasn’t told anything. I just didn’t realise it would still be this much once the funding kicked in. I think I assumed the funded hours would come off the bill and then we’d pay for whatever hours were left, but it seems to work differently.

My partner thinks we should just leave it alone because ds is settled there and we both work, so what else are we supposed to do. He’s not wrong really. I don’t want to move him somewhere else just to save money when he’s happy and knows everyone. But £360 a month is still a lot for us and I was hoping we’d be able to put some of that money away instead.

I’ve asked another mum at nursery what she pays and she said hers was cheaper but her child only goes two days and I don’t know if she’s getting the same hours as us. I don’t really want to start asking everyone what they’re paying because it feels a bit nosy.

Are these charges normal? I know nursery staff need paying and the funding doesn’t cover everything but I can’t get my head around the fact its advertised as funded hours and there’s still so much to pay. Can you ask to opt out of the extras or would they just tell you to find another nursery? Has anyone actually managed to get their bill reduced without changing childcare completely?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
ZingyAquaLemur · 06/11/2026 04:59

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 05/11/2026 11:38

You fail to understand. These nurseries entire service offer costs a lot more per hour than the government is willing to fund. "no one is asking about a champagne service" - yes you are, if you are trying to use a nursery that has additional costs without paying the additional costs. Opting out of nappies and meals and add-on-activities doesn't make it any cheaper to care for your child if the overall running costs per hour are 150%-200% of the amount per hour that the government gives. Any nursery that is making it difficult to "opt out" of their extra charges has no choice but to do that in order to be able to offer the service level that the majority of customers want and are willing to pay for. Other nurseries exist that don't have the additional costs or make it easy to opt out of them. Use those nurseries. Families that need the higher level of service for their children are still entitled to use the government funding support if their income doesn't exceed the level at which that help is withdrawn, so it's unreasonable for those nurseries to have to withdraw from the scheme.

I do understand your point, and appreciate that nurseries have significant running costs that government funding may not fully cover. I also agree that parents who want additional services should expect to pay for them.

But I think you’ve actually highlighted the very problem I’m raising. You’re essentially arguing that because government funding isn’t sufficient, nurseries have ‘no choice’ but to make opting out of additional charges difficult. That’s precisely what I disagree with.

Simply asking for access to a government-funded entitlement on the conditions set out without being pressured into paying for extras that are legally supposed to be optional, is not the same as expecting a ‘champagne service’. It’s about following the rules if you choose to accept the funded places.

If a nursery’s running costs exceed the funding it receives, that is of course a legitimate concern to take up with the government and a separate issue in itself. But that does not justify shifting the shortfall onto parents through charges they cannot realistically decline.

And suggesting parents should simply go elsewhere completely overlooks the lack of affordable childcare places and the practical difficulties working parents face.

The government’s guidance is clear: additional charges must be voluntary, and reasonable alternatives must be available.

A* nursery’s preferred business model doesn’t override the rules attached to public funding. If extras are ‘optional’ in name but compulsory in practice, they’re not *optional.

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 06/11/2026 06:26

@ZingyAquaLemur how do you propose a high quality nursery should facilitate a bargain-seeking customer should "opt out" of having a better-than-legal-minimum staff to child ratio, having more experienced and skilled staff on higher wages rather than relying heavily on inexperienced apprentices, or having premises and toys/equipment that are in better condition through more regular maintenance and replacement when things get worn out? Or do you think it should be legally enforced that you can only have government support for childcare if you choose a shoestring budget nursery that doesn't go the extra mile to create a nice environment in case some customers don't want to pay the cost of that?

cattussuperior · 06/11/2026 09:51

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 06/11/2026 06:26

@ZingyAquaLemur how do you propose a high quality nursery should facilitate a bargain-seeking customer should "opt out" of having a better-than-legal-minimum staff to child ratio, having more experienced and skilled staff on higher wages rather than relying heavily on inexperienced apprentices, or having premises and toys/equipment that are in better condition through more regular maintenance and replacement when things get worn out? Or do you think it should be legally enforced that you can only have government support for childcare if you choose a shoestring budget nursery that doesn't go the extra mile to create a nice environment in case some customers don't want to pay the cost of that?

Good post.

as I keep saying, it’s the messaging which is the only issue. In my view it’s great that there is now public funding to subsidise childcare - it’s something me and my fellow mums would have given our right arms for back in the day! I’m glad things are easier for my ds and dil than it was when my ds was in nursery. Why should parents who wish to use a high quality nursery which chooses to have better than legal minimum staff ratios, better qualified staff, superior provision and activities, not be able to access the subsidy?!

there will always be an element of choice. I didn’t choose the cheapest nursery for my babies because I valued what in my opinion was a better, more costly provision. And I paid that even when it was the equivalent of my take home pay. If subsidies childcare had been around back then (I wish!) then I would still have made the same choice and paid more as a top up for the nursery I wanted.

it just seems like sour grapes to not want to afford parents the choice to pay more.

I Wish the messaging were just clear: ‘this is a subsidy. Some childcare provisions will still cost more, but everyone (parents and providers) eligible for the subsidy can have it’

SheilaFentiman · 06/11/2026 09:54

I agree re the messaging (subsidy, not free).

I'm not sure that even nurseries using the legal minimum ratios and minimum qualified staff can meet their costs from the government rate per hour, especially in areas with higher rents etc.

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 06/11/2026 10:27

SheilaFentiman · 06/11/2026 09:54

I agree re the messaging (subsidy, not free).

I'm not sure that even nurseries using the legal minimum ratios and minimum qualified staff can meet their costs from the government rate per hour, especially in areas with higher rents etc.

Agree, physical location of nursery in an area of high ground-rent/property value is another thing that's tricky to provide an opt-out option for!

SheilaFentiman · 06/11/2026 10:29

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 06/11/2026 10:27

Agree, physical location of nursery in an area of high ground-rent/property value is another thing that's tricky to provide an opt-out option for!

Yes - high rent for the nursery but also for the local workers!

Skdkhvyvrhej · 06/11/2026 10:32

Look around other nurseries. They all do it differently. Ours is everything included. But when you go over the free hours (which are purposefully designed to be basically impossible for 99% of parents) then it costs a lot a lot. So unless you are really flexible to when you can take the hours then it’s probably the same

SheilaFentiman · 06/11/2026 10:41

The free hours aren't purposefully designed to be basically impossible. They come from the genesis of the scheme as funding for early years (3+) education, which applied to 'school day' sessions or part sessions, term time only. So 9-12 5 days a week in term time or whatever gave the 15 hours.

When I was a child (a decade or some ago now Grin) those were my nursery school hours and my SAHM walked me to and from the nursery attached to my future infant school.

ETA I agree that they are pretty silly from the perspective of today's parents and the extension of the scheme down to 9 months young, though!

cattussuperior · 06/11/2026 11:03

SheilaFentiman · 06/11/2026 10:41

The free hours aren't purposefully designed to be basically impossible. They come from the genesis of the scheme as funding for early years (3+) education, which applied to 'school day' sessions or part sessions, term time only. So 9-12 5 days a week in term time or whatever gave the 15 hours.

When I was a child (a decade or some ago now Grin) those were my nursery school hours and my SAHM walked me to and from the nursery attached to my future infant school.

ETA I agree that they are pretty silly from the perspective of today's parents and the extension of the scheme down to 9 months young, though!

Edited

But surely the ‘free hours’ are aren’t silly from the perspective that most parents will benefit from them? Several posters have commented that they are paying maybe £200/£300 less per month than they were without them, and in some cases it’s an even bigger saving. My ds and his wife pay around £510 per month for 3 days a week which really isn’t much when you break it down per hour, and definitely way better than without the subsidy.

I agree that the historic connection to early years’ education also seems a bit confusing when it’s offered from 9 months now, but I think that’s when paid mat leave ends? I’m a bit out of touch with the details as things have changed so much over the years from when it was 12 weeks! My dil had a whole year off on mat leave but I think the last bit was ‘extended’ leave and not paid. But if 9 months is when paid leaves ends, having the free hours available from that point is obviously a big help for working parents.

SheilaFentiman · 06/11/2026 11:34

But surely the ‘free hours’ are aren’t silly from the perspective that most parents will benefit from them?

Kinda - but in the same way it should be described as a subsidy, it should really be set up as a budget by month or year, rather than by term, and not linked at all to specific sessions, IMO.

"Here is £300 a month towards your childcare costs provided your child does at least x hours a month" or similar would be clearer.

ETA it would also help with the 'bottlenecks' where a child reaching the right age two days before the termly cut off is a lot 'better off' than one turning 9 months two days after and hence missing a whole term of funding.

cattussuperior · 06/11/2026 11:55

SheilaFentiman · 06/11/2026 11:34

But surely the ‘free hours’ are aren’t silly from the perspective that most parents will benefit from them?

Kinda - but in the same way it should be described as a subsidy, it should really be set up as a budget by month or year, rather than by term, and not linked at all to specific sessions, IMO.

"Here is £300 a month towards your childcare costs provided your child does at least x hours a month" or similar would be clearer.

ETA it would also help with the 'bottlenecks' where a child reaching the right age two days before the termly cut off is a lot 'better off' than one turning 9 months two days after and hence missing a whole term of funding.

Edited

Yes, I agree. Far simpler to offer a subsidy for childcare without any reference to ‘free hours’. There will obviously still be more expensive provisions, and nurseries with more favourable staff ratios than the legal minimum requirement, places in pleasanter locations etc - that’s market forces. And no one can blame parents for choosing the best option they can afford. But it should be clear that this is a (very nice!) subsidy - then everyone knows where they stand and have no reason to feel anything is unfair or lacking in transparency

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 06/11/2026 12:01

£55 for meals and snacks for 3 days a week 4 weeks a month ish = 12 days ?
ish

£55/12 = £4.58 a day ish
how many meals - lunch or lunch and tea how many snacks/what sort of snacks
does that include milk to drink with a snack ?

school lunches - are how much ? about £2.50/£2.85 in a Primary school here in Torbay so in the future you will be paying that at some point ?
tho of course you may choose to send your child to school with a packed lunch.

so is that a couple of quid a day for tea or tea and snacks

what about breakfast, how early does your child go to nursery ?

Thus I think the meals charge is reasonable,
( I know a local day nursery to me has a cook and she makes ' proper ' healthy cooked meals with great variety. )

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 06/11/2026 12:16

£35 for the extras - will this stop when he is fully toilet trained ?
about £8.75 a week about £2.91 a day

ASDA tells me that a packet of Pampers nappy pants size 6 28 nappies is £6 on offer from £10

ASDA also tells me that Pampers Sensitive Baby Wipes Plastic Free, 52 Baby Wet Wipes are 98p, I chose sensitive as I don't know your child, and plastic free as I guess everyone is environment friendly.
I suspect a packet of ( only ) 52 could easily be used in a week esp if the child has a dirty nappy every day.

I wonder what else is counted as ' extras '

and yes if the Nursery has ' visitors ' in for extra activities - gym or music then you will be charged for it and that may be one of the reasons you chose that nursery.

It's amazing how all the little things add up.

ZingyAquaLemur · 06/11/2026 13:01

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 06/11/2026 06:26

@ZingyAquaLemur how do you propose a high quality nursery should facilitate a bargain-seeking customer should "opt out" of having a better-than-legal-minimum staff to child ratio, having more experienced and skilled staff on higher wages rather than relying heavily on inexperienced apprentices, or having premises and toys/equipment that are in better condition through more regular maintenance and replacement when things get worn out? Or do you think it should be legally enforced that you can only have government support for childcare if you choose a shoestring budget nursery that doesn't go the extra mile to create a nice environment in case some customers don't want to pay the cost of that?

I think you’re deliberately taking my argument to extremes at this point. You’re introducing scenarios I’ve never suggested, then getting worked up over those scenarios rather than addressing what I’ve actually said.

Nowhere have I argued for lower staffing standards, inexperienced staff or nurseries operating on shoestring budgets. Those are arguments you’ve created, not mine.

And describing parents trying to access a government-funded entitlement as “bargain-seeking customers” is unnecessarily condescending.

I’ve repeatedly acknowledged the financial pressures nurseries face. My point has always been about TRANSPARENCY and making supposedly optional charges GENUINELY optional.

You seem determined to turn a straightforward point about fair opt-out policies into a debate about compromising childcare standards, despite me never suggesting anything of the sort.

You’re entitled to disagree, but inventing arguments on my behalf and then arguing against them isn’t a meaningful discussion.

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 06/11/2026 13:04

SheilaFentiman · 06/11/2026 10:29

Yes - high rent for the nursery but also for the local workers!

And living in an area where rents, and childcare costs, are higher than other more budget areas is a choice, not a right. Lots of people cannot afford all the nice things that they would like for the lifestyle they want. Dealing with that by whining for the government to enforce rules to make the nicer things stop existing, so that you don't have to be jealous of people with nicer things, is not usually how we deal with that. And a more rigorously enforced set of rules definitely would result in the nicer nurseries simply shutting down. The blind eye is turned to the nurseries that make the books balance with extra charges because there aren't sufficient nursery places as it is, and closing down thriving and popular ones isn't sensible.

Pp are correct that the terminology should be changed to make it clear that it's a subsidy, but with the onus on Local Authorities to ensure that there are enough shoestring-budget places for people who can't afford any more than that. This problem arose because the government approached the roll-out of early years education and childcare differently than how they rolled out universal education for older children a few decades earlier. With schools, the private and charitable existing schools all had the choice to be rolled into a new universal state provision administered centrally, and anyone who wanted to opt out of the basic state offering to get something better has to pay full whack to get something high quality with no subsidy. They could have duplicated that for nurseries but it was obvious that wouldn't work as so many families need so much more than 30hrs pw term-time-only so this hybrid system emerged instead.

SheilaFentiman · 06/11/2026 13:18

And living in an area where rents, and childcare costs, are higher than other more budget areas is a choice, not a right.

In case you weren't clear, I meant for the nursery workers when I said local workers.

The people who need nurseries because of work often need to live within commuting distance i.e. high cost distance of the cities with those jobs. You can't square the circle with a Choosy McChoice argument.

Anyway, this is getting nowhere. Have a good day, and goodbye.

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 06/11/2026 14:11

ZingyAquaLemur · 06/11/2026 13:01

I think you’re deliberately taking my argument to extremes at this point. You’re introducing scenarios I’ve never suggested, then getting worked up over those scenarios rather than addressing what I’ve actually said.

Nowhere have I argued for lower staffing standards, inexperienced staff or nurseries operating on shoestring budgets. Those are arguments you’ve created, not mine.

And describing parents trying to access a government-funded entitlement as “bargain-seeking customers” is unnecessarily condescending.

I’ve repeatedly acknowledged the financial pressures nurseries face. My point has always been about TRANSPARENCY and making supposedly optional charges GENUINELY optional.

You seem determined to turn a straightforward point about fair opt-out policies into a debate about compromising childcare standards, despite me never suggesting anything of the sort.

You’re entitled to disagree, but inventing arguments on my behalf and then arguing against them isn’t a meaningful discussion.

You are being unrealistic. Opt-out policies can only apply to things that it is possible to offer to one child and not another, or possible to supply from home - food and drink, nappies, extra activities. It is ridiculous to suppose that the only differences in costs for an expensive nursery vs a cheap one are solely bound up in such things. Yes greater transparency would be great but is actively prevented by legislation that wants to pretend that all nurseries have the same running costs when they don't, and most parents are fine with that and pay the price it costs to have their children in a nursery they like. You don't like the examples I gave and say you "aren't talking about those", as if you being blind to reality means I shouldn't be allowed to talk about reality, but those are the real costs that real nurseries have to cover the money for somehow. If the choice is that either they close down because it's impossible to offer the service that people want and are willing to pay for, or they cover it by charging £10 a day for "nappies" when everyone knows the actual nappy cost is under £2, then its really better for the community if they don't close down. The third option would be for them to downgrade to become a less nice place where parents aren't happy for their children to attend full time, cutting costs to the bone and setting themselves into a death spiral where their core customers decide that the cut price option isn't what their children need - the slower path to going out of business rather than the decision to stop.

Timeforachange26 · 06/11/2026 14:14

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 06/11/2026 12:01

£55 for meals and snacks for 3 days a week 4 weeks a month ish = 12 days ?
ish

£55/12 = £4.58 a day ish
how many meals - lunch or lunch and tea how many snacks/what sort of snacks
does that include milk to drink with a snack ?

school lunches - are how much ? about £2.50/£2.85 in a Primary school here in Torbay so in the future you will be paying that at some point ?
tho of course you may choose to send your child to school with a packed lunch.

so is that a couple of quid a day for tea or tea and snacks

what about breakfast, how early does your child go to nursery ?

Thus I think the meals charge is reasonable,
( I know a local day nursery to me has a cook and she makes ' proper ' healthy cooked meals with great variety. )

School dinners are free in ks1 i thought

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 06/11/2026 14:38

@Timeforachange26

yes which is why I said ' at some point '

Timeforachange26 · 06/11/2026 14:40

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 06/11/2026 14:38

@Timeforachange26

yes which is why I said ' at some point '

So at least 6 years in the future by the time someone with a baby in nursery might have to pay. And the rules may have changed by then

And my DDs have never had school dinners for their kids and just packed lunches

PremiumHuman · 06/11/2026 14:46

SheilaFentiman · 06/11/2026 11:34

But surely the ‘free hours’ are aren’t silly from the perspective that most parents will benefit from them?

Kinda - but in the same way it should be described as a subsidy, it should really be set up as a budget by month or year, rather than by term, and not linked at all to specific sessions, IMO.

"Here is £300 a month towards your childcare costs provided your child does at least x hours a month" or similar would be clearer.

ETA it would also help with the 'bottlenecks' where a child reaching the right age two days before the termly cut off is a lot 'better off' than one turning 9 months two days after and hence missing a whole term of funding.

Edited

If they did a ‘here’s a monthly £300 voucher,’ then prices would rise rapidly and the voucher would soon become worthless. Much like when they got rid of stamp duty due to Covid 😁

addictedtotheflats · 06/11/2026 15:01

mine goes 3 days and its £340 a month stretched over 52 weeks. No funding is £1014 a month

SillySallySaidSo · 06/11/2026 19:21

Whatwerewetalkingabout · 18/10/2026 09:13

Yes its normal and its disgusting, I also think there needs to be a bigger discussion in this country about profit in childcare (and all care services) I think all childcare settings should be non profit.

My DC was in nursery 3 years ago and we had these charges, an extra £22 a day on funded days. With the 30 hrs "free" childcare they averaged it out over a full year so it was only about 24 hrs a week as its only funded for term time and because they were open 11 hours a day we only got 2 fully "funded" days a week with a £22 surcharge for both. Any extra days were at their full rate even if you only took your child in for 7 or 8 hours.

Our nursery was also owned by an individual and then sold to a chain (investment company) the year after I left, and I've heard things have got worse in terms of what is offered and more expensive.

I agree the government doesn't give nurseries enough funding to really function but I checked companies house and before our nursery was sold it was making an obscene amount of profit for under 100 children.

I am a childminder. My profit is my income. Do you propose i work for free like some sort of charity service so parents can go out to work and earn far more than I bring home?

Whatwerewetalkingabout · 07/11/2026 11:50

SillySallySaidSo · 06/11/2026 19:21

I am a childminder. My profit is my income. Do you propose i work for free like some sort of charity service so parents can go out to work and earn far more than I bring home?

Thats obviously not what I'm talking about in the slightest, I think workers should be paid more and said they were underfunded. I'm obviously talking about investment firms (Which I literally said in my post) buying up childcare, adult care and veterinary practices.... Maybe read my post again.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page