Please or to access all these features

Money matters

Find financial and money-saving discussions including debt and pension chat on our Money forum. If you're looking for ways to make your money to go further, sign up to our Moneysaver emails here.

Is there any point in having more than one private pension

12 replies

Mamma11818282 · 05/11/2026 12:27

I have two private pensions, one from where I used to work and another I set up myself. Is there any benefit in having two? If not how do I go about choosing which one? Would it make more sense to stick with the same provider as DH?

OP posts:
RB68 · 05/11/2026 12:29

Alot depends on the pensions themselves - we can't really comment as it is too specialist - you need to speak to an independent financial advisor who can investigate the type of pensions they are and get some info from you as to how your life is organised so he/she can sort out what suits you best

FluffballFitz · 05/11/2026 13:19

The provider being the same as your DH is irrelevant.

What you want from a pension is:
1.low fees (1% would be high, 0.02% would be low)

2.A choice of funds that you're happy with (this is individual preference. In general, a person with only 10 years left until retirement might want to think about lower risk funds. But another person with decades of work in front of them would be better served in higher risk, high reward funds. Additionally one person might want to simply invest in an all world tracker. Another person might want to put a percentage in AI/tech funds, or environmental funds, or emerging markets etc.)

3.Any additional benefits that are specific for your pension plan

Have a look at both of your pensions and compare them on these points. Get advice if you need it. There's no harm in having multiple pensions, so long as you're aware they exist and don't forget about them. The advantage of having more than one would be in flexibility. For example you could choose to draw from one when you're 58 and decide to work part time, but need to maintain an income, while continuing funding the second pension which you take 10 years later when you fully retire.

EscCtrl · 05/11/2026 13:28

Perhaps if you want to spread risk between pension companies (had a pension with Equitable Life Assurance Society when they went bust in the early 2000s).
Perhaps if you don't want your employer knowing how much you are saving into pensions, if you can max out your company pension contributions, and/or make money from other work and/or investments.

mybiggreenfrog · 05/11/2026 13:35

Of course there's benefit ... more pension

5gymbabe · 05/11/2026 14:48

Mamma11818282 · 05/11/2026 12:27

I have two private pensions, one from where I used to work and another I set up myself. Is there any benefit in having two? If not how do I go about choosing which one? Would it make more sense to stick with the same provider as DH?

Would think it rare that husband and wife were I same pension provider surely it depends who your employer is with

HRTtoHeart · 05/11/2026 14:50

DH has four, from various employers and one he set up himself. Why not book yourself a session with an advisor? I found that very helpful.

CaimanCrown · 05/11/2026 15:28

There is no real downside to keeping them separate other than a slight increase in your admin burden as you have to remember what you have and make sure they have your current address.

There may be an incentive to combine them, though, if one of them has cheaper fees, or better options on retirement, or access to a fund you like the sound of. Or even just because you prefer their app.

Ultimately combining them or keeping them separate won’t make or break your retirement. Unless the old workplace one is defined benefit. The general advice is to leave any defined benefit pension alone unless your personal circumstances are unusual.

Jopo12 · 05/11/2026 16:13

What type of workplace pension is it?
If it's defined benefit, then the answer to your question is very different from if it's defined contribution.

If both pensions are DC and the workplace one doesn't have any protected benefits (eg a protected age of 55 or guaranteed income) then both pensions are very similar . There will be a difference in platform fees, and if the workplace ones are high then you would benefit from transferring it a cheaper private pension.

There will also be a difference in the funds you've invested in. Some workplace pensions have a limited choice of funds that may not give you the best returns. Your sipp will have a much wider choice of funds so you are likely to get a higher return over the long term.

The final thing to consider is the length of time it takes to transfer a pension, if you sell funds just before the market takes off then you buy high in the new pension, then you will have lost out on that growth.

EwwSprouts · 05/11/2026 16:18

EscCtrl · 05/11/2026 13:28

Perhaps if you want to spread risk between pension companies (had a pension with Equitable Life Assurance Society when they went bust in the early 2000s).
Perhaps if you don't want your employer knowing how much you are saving into pensions, if you can max out your company pension contributions, and/or make money from other work and/or investments.

Came on to say the same. Many employees of PWC (large accountancy firm) were with Equitable Life. It can happen to any of us whether well informed or not. I would always spread the risk.

LeaveMooFreealonepleaseCadburys · 05/11/2026 16:25

As long as they aren't tiny my head would lean towards spreading the risk

(Another who saw lots of people at work have to delay their retirements significantly because their money was with EL)

I have a smallish private pension fund and a couple of chunkier local govt ones and I am thinking of topping up the private one further for balance.

Mamma11818282 · 05/11/2026 19:40

Thank you, you’ve given me loads to think about and look up!

OP posts:
Pherian · 05/11/2026 22:08

Mamma11818282 · 05/11/2026 12:27

I have two private pensions, one from where I used to work and another I set up myself. Is there any benefit in having two? If not how do I go about choosing which one? Would it make more sense to stick with the same provider as DH?

You need to speak to a financial advisor. Pensions are complex and you should not combine a pension until you’ve had appropriate financial advice.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread