Please or to access all these features

Money matters

Find financial and money-saving discussions including debt and pension chat on our Money forum. If you're looking for ways to make your money to go further, sign up to our Moneysaver emails here.

Anyone else put loads into pensions? Are you nervous about it?

97 replies

OnTheLookOutForCheese · 01/11/2026 14:48

I salary sacrifice 57% of my salary into my work pension.
I know its the most sensible thing to do because of the tax relief.
But it makes me slightly nervous for reasons I'm struggling to articulate - it feels like a very long-term bet which I'm worried I'll lose.

I put the maximum into my ISA every year, including £4K into a LISA while they're around and I'm still able.

Does anyone else put a big wedge of their salary into pensions? How do you feel about it? Or did you do this, and now you're regretting it, or perhaps it worked out well for you?

Thank you!

OP posts:
Gingerbreadseasoniscoming · 01/11/2026 14:50

I'm worried for the same reasons you are. It feels like if the rules change or the economy collapses all of that money might disappear - or at least become worth not much!

distinctpossibility · 01/11/2026 14:51

To be honest if the remaining 43% of your income still leaves you enough to put away £25k in ISAs and pay your expenses, you are doing amazingly well, and could pay for some financial advice to reassure, support and guide you.

Meadowfinch · 01/11/2026 14:52

It depends. Are you intending to use the money for retirement?

I know several people who loaded up their pensions, so their dcs could inherit tax free, and are now facing a 40% reduction due to new tax laws from next April, so they will need to take as much as they can at 20% income tax, and rearrange their other assets to be a more tax efficient inheritance.

OnTheLookOutForCheese · 01/11/2026 14:54

@Meadowfinch Yes, intending for the pension to fund retirement.

OP posts:
Cadenza12 · 01/11/2026 14:57

Remember that you should actually live your life now. It's of course an excellent idea to prepare for retirement but not to the detriment of living your life today and actually getting some pleasure from your labours. Life is short.

OnTheLookOutForCheese · 01/11/2026 15:01

@Cadenza12 I agree and I absolutely do - the extreme FIRE people are bonkers.

OP posts:
ThirdStorm · 01/11/2026 15:07

I’m not worried and I’m contributing a similar % to you. I have plenty to live on and decent savings. It’s better in a pension than anywhere else especially with the tax relief plus my employer shares their NI saving.

It gives me great comfort to know I’m saving for retirement.

OnTheLookOutForCheese · 01/11/2026 15:18

Thanks @ThirdStorm That's reassuring, and you're right to approach the issue as a kind of "what's the alternative?"

@distinctpossibility I've had some financial advice but the advice is always to put as much as possible into pensions and it'll be basically fine. I'm following that advice but it makes me nervous 😁

OP posts:
Twatterati · 01/11/2026 15:25

ThirdStorm · 01/11/2026 15:07

I’m not worried and I’m contributing a similar % to you. I have plenty to live on and decent savings. It’s better in a pension than anywhere else especially with the tax relief plus my employer shares their NI saving.

It gives me great comfort to know I’m saving for retirement.

Try telling that to the people who had pensions with British Home Stores…

https://doyleclayton.co.uk/the-bhs-pensions-scandal-and-the-legislative-response-the-pension-schemes-act-2021/

The BHS Pensions Scandal and the Legislative Response: The Pension Schemes Act 2021

The episode ultimately prompted a major legislative response, culminating in the Pension Schemes Act 2021, which substantially strengthened the powers of The Pensions Regulator (TPR) and introduced new criminal sanctions. The Act, which came into force...

https://doyleclayton.co.uk/the-bhs-pensions-scandal-and-the-legislative-response-the-pension-schemes-act-2021/

OnTheLookOutForCheese · 01/11/2026 15:39

@Twatterati Yes, exactly this kind of thing freaks me out. I'm in a fairly safe pension scheme not linked to a single employer so that BHS situation isn't likely, but not impossible I guess.

OP posts:
Nourishinghandcream · 01/11/2026 15:39

I was putting 20% into my pension but as I started to wind down for (early) retirement, I upped it to 45% for a couple of years.
TBH I was aware that it COULD be a risk but the chances of that were low compared to the benefits (reduced deductions, growth etc) which (so far🤞) have been excellent.
My company paid for us to receive independent retirement advice and they said the same OP, put as much in as you can afford.

Cometsarecool · 01/11/2026 15:42

If you're putting the maximum into a LISA every year, does that mean you haven't bought a property? Because if not, you might look at saving more money outside of a pension so that you can buy a home.

Like you I put a massive % into pensions for several years, but I only started that when I was already mortgage-free.

titchy · 01/11/2026 15:42

You must be earning a fuckton if you can still save and have plenty of spending money. So your pension pot must be enormous if you’re contributing that much and planning to continue to do so.

So why? What do you plan to do with your massive pension? You’ll probably have ten years where you’re healthy enough to have some amazing adventure, but after that, when age catches up with you? What’s the big pension going to be for?

OnTheLookOutForCheese · 01/11/2026 15:46

@Cometsarecool Sorry, I wasn't clear about the LISA. It's for retirement saving, not a first-time house. I have a house and no mortgage.

@Nourishinghandcream That's great to hear, thank you. We also get free pension advice through work and its always "put in as much as you can". But it makes me nervous even though I know it makes sense.

OP posts:
DryIce · 01/11/2026 15:52

Depends a lot on your goals, doesn't it? When you're planning to retire, and what retirement income you want.

I put loads in mine, but I'm not planning to do my ft good salary job forever so I need to front load it.

If you plan to keep working and contributing, work out what contributions get you to where you want to end up and put in that much. The chance in inheritance tax does make me question going over a certain amount, although mine is quite high as I'm quite risk averse

tripleginandtonic · 01/11/2026 15:56

In order to put more thsn half your salary into a pension you must be absolutely loaded anyway so even if it tanked you'd not be on the streets. Nothing here to worry about OP.

ErrolTheDragon · 01/11/2026 16:03

Twatterati · 01/11/2026 15:25

Try telling that to the people who had pensions with British Home Stores…

https://doyleclayton.co.uk/the-bhs-pensions-scandal-and-the-legislative-response-the-pension-schemes-act-2021/

That was a company defined benefits scheme I think? I assume the OP is in a defined contributions scheme so that’s a very different scenario.

Cometsarecool · 01/11/2026 16:08

Saving into a pension is the ultimate long-term bet. You're betting that you live long enough to be able to use it (although if it's a DC pension it wouldn't be entirely lost as your dependents would inherit it.) You're betting that the govt doesn't change the rules too much re the age you can draw it & tax-free lump sum. And you're betting that the stock market is a good place to invest money over the long term.

It's good that you're already saving the maximum into your ISAs as they give you the flexibility to take that money whenever you want, unlike pensions. This can enable people to retire early or to reduce their hours.

You haven't said how much of a pot you've built or how old you are, but I guess the question always is: what else would you do with the money?

GOODCAT · 01/11/2026 16:14

I put in a large chunk of my salary into my pension and savings as can currently manage to do that. It didn't used to be like that. Also I was in my 40s when auto enrolment came in and my pension isn't as strong as it might be.

You are lucky to be allowed to salary sacrifice that much, I am limited to 20%.

My pension keeps going down, but I wouldn't spend it if I didn't save it, so not much point in doing much else with it.

My Mum's health meant she had to retire early but she is now in her 80s and suffered awful health issues throughout so I want to try to make sure I have the option to finish earlier and to afford to buy in help in old age when I need it.

HermioneWeasley · 01/11/2026 16:18

Are you using a stocks and shares ISA or cash?

I’d be maxing out S&S which will give you tax free income whenever you choose to take it - not linked to any government dates

ThirdStorm · 01/11/2026 16:24

Twatterati · 01/11/2026 15:25

Try telling that to the people who had pensions with British Home Stores…

https://doyleclayton.co.uk/the-bhs-pensions-scandal-and-the-legislative-response-the-pension-schemes-act-2021/

A really terrible situation.

Im in a DC fund run independently from my employer by Scottish widow so a very different situation and no deficit to consider thankfully.

roses2 · 01/11/2026 16:40

If you can afford to continue maxing out your pension, I would continue. It will either get taxed 40% now or it will get taxed at 40% on inheritance tax in many years time. Either way it will get taxed but at least if you invest in the pension it will grow at 5-10% year on year which is more than an average bank savings account and you can enjoy a decent retirement.

My method of saving is:

  1. Max out pension
  2. Max out ISA
  3. Anything leftover split 50/50 between easy access savings and holidays

We have enough for a (£10-15k) holiday once every 5 years but we are financially secure both short term and long term.

HumanIntelligence · 01/11/2026 17:10

I'm worried about the government messing with things, and the stock market crashing.

The rising state pension age is also impacting when the 25% tax free amount can be withdrawn. It's already moved by two years, and I'm worried it will again. Then I can't use it to help with kids university costs as planned.

I have the same value in a DC pension as my house is worth, early 50s. I wish I'd put more into S&S ISA because it's more accessible.

I'm worried about redundancy, needing to use the pension to live on if I can't find suitable work from 57, and unlucky timing of a stock market crash.

Worst would be that I die just when my DC pot is maxed and house are paid off and the children cop inheritance tax. That's piss me off after being sensible when younger. I'd be dead pissed off I suppose!

JLou08 · 01/11/2026 17:35

I wouldn't be putting over half my salary into a pension the way the age is rapidly increasing. I have a work place pension and a NEST pension. I can't take from my NEST until I'm 58. I'm also in a high risk fund so aware that I could lose money but given that I only put in a small amount I feel it's worth the risk.
I'm living my life now because I do think there's a possibility retirement won't even be a thing by the time I get there. My GF's health declined as soon as he retired at 65, one of my GMs died at 60 from cancer so I'm also mindful that even if it doesn't increase further I may not be here or in good health to enjoy it.

Fralleagloe · 01/11/2026 18:49

I put 80% of my income into pensions to maximise tax efficiency. But I don't have a big income, DH and I have joint finances so my spending money isn't limited to my remaining salary. It's split across a NEST pension and a SIPP and I'm not concerned about the provider going bust. It's invested in the stock market in high risk funds, as I'm late 40s and I have the time to ride out fluctuations. I'm not worried about dips, that's to be expected and it's not really important as I won't be withdrawing any time soon.

I also have S&S ISA and LISA maxed out annually, also invested into higher risk funds.

I am not too concerned about the IHT as it still won't add up to huge amounts given that my salary is quite low and I only started pension saving in my 30s, so it'll mostly be spent during retirement than passed on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread