Please or to access all these features

Money matters

Find financial and money-saving discussions including debt and pension chat on our Money forum. If you're looking for ways to make your money to go further, sign up to our Moneysaver emails here.

Life assurance & critical illness

12 replies

Longsmallsally · 26/10/2026 22:38

My husband and I are reviewing our existing life insurance. Our current policy expires next year.
Neither of us receives employer sick pay, so we want to make sure we're protected if one of us dies, develops a serious illness or is unable to work.

We definitely want:
Decreasing life cover to pay off the mortgage if either of us dies.
Separate, level critical illness cover, which would pay a lump sum and wouldn’t reduce or cancel the separate mortgage life cover.

Then we’ve looked at:
Family income benefit to provide an income for a few years, if either of us dies.
Accident and sickness cover

The problem is the cost of the critical illness cover, so we need to tailor it to suit our budget whilst also having as much peace of mind as possible.
We're trying to work out whether a smaller critical illness lump sum, alongside the other stuff would be a sensible compromise, or do we want more critical illness and not the income protection and accident cover.

It has to be a happy medium between feeling as financially secure as we can afford to be, in the event of something life changing happening, and it not costing so much it’s just not possible to do.

I'd be grateful for any experiences or advice on any of this

Thanks

OP posts:
Hayley1256 · 27/10/2026 02:46

Personally I would take out a level term life insurance policy to cover the mortgage and loss of income if either of you dies.

Them I would look an income protection plan that would cover a % of your income in the event of illness and not been able to work. Critical illness cover can be expensive as it pays a lump sum so income protection can be cheaper as it pays a monthly amount.

Beenaroundabit · 27/10/2026 03:54

You're much more likely to be critically ill than die during your mortgage term, statistically see speaking.

I have critical illness cover, DTA for the mortgage and LTA for the bills on top, should the worst happen - all taken out when I was 20 years younger, didn't have the health challenges I have now, and I don't smoke. You have to consider your own attitude to risk, and balance it out against the cost.

Longsmallsally · 27/10/2026 06:24

Hayley1256 · 27/10/2026 02:46

Personally I would take out a level term life insurance policy to cover the mortgage and loss of income if either of you dies.

Them I would look an income protection plan that would cover a % of your income in the event of illness and not been able to work. Critical illness cover can be expensive as it pays a lump sum so income protection can be cheaper as it pays a monthly amount.

Thank you.

We currently have level cover, which would pay the mortgage off and leave us with a little spare. But not loads. We have critical illness cover with that.

The income protection plan we’ve been quoted only covers for death, not illness. We’ve been quoted for a separate plan that’s accident and sickness, that one covers us for 2 years pay.

OP posts:
Longsmallsally · 27/10/2026 06:29

Beenaroundabit · 27/10/2026 03:54

You're much more likely to be critically ill than die during your mortgage term, statistically see speaking.

I have critical illness cover, DTA for the mortgage and LTA for the bills on top, should the worst happen - all taken out when I was 20 years younger, didn't have the health challenges I have now, and I don't smoke. You have to consider your own attitude to risk, and balance it out against the cost.

We’ve always taken policies out that last 5 or 10 years. I didn’t even think at the time to extend that period. Hindsight and all that

We’ve been quoted £435 for critical illness alone at £250k cover so I guess we have to reduce the amount until we reach a sensible monthly cost. Our FA said that life assurance comes almost as a free add on to CI cover.

The info we have leaves us covered in the event of death. But the cover for illness and unable to work there accident and sickness policy covers us for 2 years pay, and then whatever we can afford for the critical illness policy. He gave us a price where the critical illness and mortgage protection were together meaning a lump sum for either or. That was a more reasonable cost, but it’s one lump sum so we’d have to choose between paying the mortage off or helping with whatever we may need that a critical illness could bring. Which we don’t want

OP posts:
Bunnycat101 · 27/10/2026 12:07

How old are you? The quote is obviously very expensive now and I feel like you’ve been poorly advised in the past if you’ve been doing 5 year terms as your risk (and therefore premium cost) increases so much with age

If one of you were to get sick, how many years would you need to cover until pension age? Realistically would 2 years actually help you? Is there a wage discrepancy where one of you is more critical financially than the other? Could you self insure to build up an emergency fund?

We ended up just going for hefty life cover and not critical illness. We are well over-insured on our deaths and we took our policy out in our 20s until we are 70 which was probably an error in hindsight. We couldn’t get anything cheaper now so no point changing. However, we are under-protected for severe illness and it is a bit of a worry.

Beenaroundabit · 27/10/2026 12:15

CI cover is more expensive because it's more likely to happen than death during your mortgage term. £435 a year is about what I pay for less cover just for me, so I think that's not too bad!

It also depends on if you have kids, what your other monthly expenses are and hugely your attitude to risk.

Quercus5 · 27/10/2026 12:42

A warning about critical illness cover - it only covers you if your illness is on their list, which is quite restrictive. Income Protection is much more comprehensive as it covers a much wider range of illnesses. Also IP pays out each month that you’re unable to work, whereas CI pays a one-off lump sum.

Longsmallsally · 27/10/2026 15:18

Bunnycat101 · 27/10/2026 12:07

How old are you? The quote is obviously very expensive now and I feel like you’ve been poorly advised in the past if you’ve been doing 5 year terms as your risk (and therefore premium cost) increases so much with age

If one of you were to get sick, how many years would you need to cover until pension age? Realistically would 2 years actually help you? Is there a wage discrepancy where one of you is more critical financially than the other? Could you self insure to build up an emergency fund?

We ended up just going for hefty life cover and not critical illness. We are well over-insured on our deaths and we took our policy out in our 20s until we are 70 which was probably an error in hindsight. We couldn’t get anything cheaper now so no point changing. However, we are under-protected for severe illness and it is a bit of a worry.

Mid 50’s

I think we took our cover in the past at what we could afford - but equally weren’t advised to think long term, or if we were we didn’t consider it. As I said, hindsight and all that

in an ideal world I’d want to mortgage paid off upon death and a lump sum to help.
Assuming the other person is still working it would be to make life a little easier.
But I’m thinking if the unthinkable happens now, rather than in a few years when we have the mortgage to pay and not old enough to retire
we have savings but not enough to last for months and months realistically.

i think it’s easy to be coveted for death, so easier to over insure I guess abut speaking to a friend of mine who used to be a financial advisor he said in 22 years he’s only ever had 3 deaths. Its all critical illness - so I don’t want to be under coveted but also have to be realistic with costs too

OP posts:
Longsmallsally · 27/10/2026 15:21

@Quercus5 I’ve been sent the list and it’s quit comprehensive from what I can tell but I guess there are things that won’t be covered. I think when you’re on a budget you have to do the most you can and hope.

@Beenaroundabit that’s excellent cost for the year.
I don’t like risk, I like feeling secure so want as much as I can get whilst not going overboard in the costs
we have no children financially dependent on us. Our other monthly expenses aren’t huge tbh.

OP posts:
Switchd · 29/10/2026 00:36

We are early 40s, large mortgage, 2 DC. We have level term life insurance which will cover the mortgage (plus as time goes on and the mortgage decreases there will also be some left over for a lump sum). It expires when the youngest DC is 22 and we are mid-late 50s. We also have DIS through work, so the LI is possibly overkill, but it's cheap as we took it out years ago and gives us peace of mind, plus more flexibility around work should one of us get a terminal illness. Should one of us die, we would also have the inherited pension pot (defined contribution).

I do worry more about being underinsured for illness. We have income protection through work for 2-5 years. If we were still unable to work beyond that, I think we'd have to access our pension pot early based on ill health. I have considered whether to buy additional accident, sickness and unemployment insurance but it seems quite expensive. Overall our main objective is to be able to stay in our current house until youngest DC has finished uni, and I think we can do that.

tommymel1989 · 30/10/2026 16:28

Longsmallsally · 26/10/2026 22:38

My husband and I are reviewing our existing life insurance. Our current policy expires next year.
Neither of us receives employer sick pay, so we want to make sure we're protected if one of us dies, develops a serious illness or is unable to work.

We definitely want:
Decreasing life cover to pay off the mortgage if either of us dies.
Separate, level critical illness cover, which would pay a lump sum and wouldn’t reduce or cancel the separate mortgage life cover.

Then we’ve looked at:
Family income benefit to provide an income for a few years, if either of us dies.
Accident and sickness cover

The problem is the cost of the critical illness cover, so we need to tailor it to suit our budget whilst also having as much peace of mind as possible.
We're trying to work out whether a smaller critical illness lump sum, alongside the other stuff would be a sensible compromise, or do we want more critical illness and not the income protection and accident cover.

It has to be a happy medium between feeling as financially secure as we can afford to be, in the event of something life changing happening, and it not costing so much it’s just not possible to do.

I'd be grateful for any experiences or advice on any of this

Thanks

One thing worth asking your adviser to clarify is whether a critical illness payout would reduce or end the life cover, or whether the covers are separate that seems central to what you’re trying to achieve. Also ask them to put the payment triggers and payment periods for each option side by side.

I rcently sorted mine and found the explanation of critical illness cover here: https://www.getlifenest.co.uk/critical-illness-cover.

It won’t tell you which combination is right for your circumstances, but may help with the terminology.

Critical Illness Cover | Conditions and Claims

See how critical illness cover works, why policy definitions matter and what to compare before you request quotes.

https://www.getlifenest.co.uk/critical-illness-cover

Longsmallsally · 30/10/2026 16:45

tommymel1989 · 30/10/2026 16:28

One thing worth asking your adviser to clarify is whether a critical illness payout would reduce or end the life cover, or whether the covers are separate that seems central to what you’re trying to achieve. Also ask them to put the payment triggers and payment periods for each option side by side.

I rcently sorted mine and found the explanation of critical illness cover here: https://www.getlifenest.co.uk/critical-illness-cover.

It won’t tell you which combination is right for your circumstances, but may help with the terminology.

Thank you, we’ve have chatted about this. We definitely don’t want the life assurance and CI cancelled if one person makes a claim, so we’re going for separate policies

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page