Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Is this an acceptable company response to a potentially serious incident involving a known product defect?

23 replies

cluttered · 06/11/2026 17:56

About 20 years ago I had multiple double glazed roof windows fitted by a big household name company. At the time I registered the windows on their website and over the years I have bought related products (fitted blinds) for which I had to give the model number so the company has my details on their system and knew I had these particular windows.

I have never had any problems with them until earlier this week one of the windows spontaneously shattered in the middle of the night. Specifically, it was the inner pane of a window located directly over my son’s bed. Luckily, he had pulled down the fitted blackout blind which caught the glass, otherwise he would have been showered with shards of glass, some of which were quite large and heavy and all of which were extremely sharp as it’s not safety glass.

Looking online, others have experienced this and it is apparently due to a defect in a particular batch of these units which the company has known about as there is a safety warning on their website that these particular windows are liable to spontaneously implode, especially in cold weather.

In the past it appears that the company has replaced the defective glass for free but when I contacted them they told me that the policy had changed and now they will send me replacement glass for me to arrange my own installation or I can have a 30% discount off an entirely new window.

I have 2 questions: should they have attempted to contact me to warn me about this fault or is placing a small alert on their website sufficient. Secondly, since it appears that 4 of the 5 windows I had installed at this time are from the defective batch, I will be looking a quite a large outlay if I choose the option of new windows and even arranging the installation of 4 replacement double glazed units will leave me out of pocket. Is this really all the manufacturer is required to offer under consumer law?

Thanks for reading this if you’ve got to the end!

OP posts:
bababamama · 06/11/2026 18:03

The issue is that it is 20 years old, it comes down to whether a 30% discount, or materials only is reasonable for a product of that age

MozzieFreeZone · 06/11/2026 18:07

Is it Velux?

MozzieFreeZone · 06/11/2026 18:09

A Velux skylight in our house spontaneously shattered 6 years ago - 10 years after installation. The batch number was still legible and it was identified as a known issue. They refitted it with a new glazed unit.

Territories · 06/11/2026 18:28

under the consumer rights act, after 6 months of purchase the onus is on the consumer to prove the item was faulty at purchase.

Whilst you can say you have windows from this defective batch, given the windows are 20 years old, I don’t think there’s much more you can force them to do. I think if it went to court, the court could decide that 20 years of use without issue may mean that a 30% discount is fair / replacement glass is fair.

Isn’t this the sort of thing to go through your home insurance for anyway?

cluttered · 06/11/2026 18:32

Yes, it's Velux. Apparently they were replacing the defective windows previously but are no longer offering this.

i had thought that if a product behaved unexpectedly causing damage/injury the manufacturer was responsible regardless of product age. Surely it wasn't expected for an inner pane to shatter. If it could have been anticipated they should have used safety glass considering the potentially severe consequences, especially since being on a sloped roof it would naturally fall inwards.
I asked them why they hadn't attempted to contact customers to warn them but they said their lawyers has advised them they were doing everything that was legally required.

OP posts:
angelasim · 06/11/2026 18:35

Oh, great. It's not as if the glass panels starting to look a bit tatty or even as if the glazing failed . The window they sold you shattered and could have seriously injured someone. But technically they haven't done anything wrong.
Black mark to Velux, I won't be using them again.

cluttered · 06/11/2026 18:36

I'm not sure if this would be covered by home insurance because it's not caused by an external event such as a storm. Presumably they could argue that either the windows hadn't been properly maintained or that it was a known defect, I'm not sure either of those is covered?

OP posts:
cluttered · 06/11/2026 18:38

It doesn't bear thinking about what could have happened if the blind hadn't been pulled down to catch the glass!

OP posts:
cluttered · 06/11/2026 18:47

Do you think it could be worth going on social media to publicise this? Given that this could happen with 3 more of my windows?

OP posts:
cluttered · 06/11/2026 18:48

Yes they will replace the glass units as in send them to me free of charge but I have to organise installation.

OP posts:
prh47bridge · 06/11/2026 20:46

If this was classed as a product recall, they should have contacted you. However, most recalls achieve a surprisingly low success rate. Consumers ignore recall notices for all kinds of reasons, including thinking they are marketing and throwing them away without reading them. Similarly, notifications by email go astray for all kinds of reasons, including ISPs implementing over-enthusiastic spam filters. So it is possible that they did try to notify you but, for whatever reason, you didn't see it.

As you had the units for over 6 months, the burden of proof would be on you to show that the units were faulty when supplied. However, the fact the units are subject to a warning on the supplier's website makes it easier for you to do so. As the windows were faulty, they must install replacement units or cover the cost of doing so. They shouldn't leave you out of pocket. If they stick to their position, you can take them to small claims court to claim the cost of installation.

TheLette · 06/11/2026 20:55

Previous legal advice about Consumer Rights Act is correct about the 6 months period but ignores the 6 year limitation period for claims (this isn't stated in the Act but it's the applicable time period). You don't have a claim based on that Act because 20 years has passed. You might have some kind of claim based on product safety / recall laws - I don't know, I'm not that kind of lawyer (but I do know my stuff on the Consumer Rights Act and contract law !).

Btw this also happens quite often with glass shower screens - when my daughter was a baby she narrowly missed the glass going all over her because it happened when I was running the bath. But I think that's a known product risk generally; there was no recall for the particular shower screen we had.

prh47bridge · 06/11/2026 22:43

Apologies - I misread the first post and thought you had had the windows 2 years. After 20 years, the previous poster is correct that your rights under the Consumer Rights Act are gone. You are therefore relying on the manufacturer's good will, so I'm afraid all you will get is what they are offering.

cluttered · 06/11/2026 23:12

Ok thanks PPs for the information on the limitations of the Consumer Rights Act. I've heard of glass shower screens shattering but I thought because that's not unknown they are made of safety glass whereas these windows most definitely are not! Velux did say the risk is just with this batch and not that it may happen with any older windows.

So maybe I'll just have to go with what they're offering. I'm just disappointed that it seems that until the last year or so they were covering the installation cost and now they're not. And they did tell me they didn't try to contact customers as they were advised by their lawyers that a warning on their website was sufficient.

OP posts:
Becs51 · 08/11/2026 19:23

I would say unless you can find that Velux have advertised the faulty batch numbers and prove yours are part of that batch there isn’t really anything you can do other than accept their offer. If this had happened within a couple of years you’d have a good case but the fact you’ve had multiple windows for 20 years without incident I would say significantly affects your chances of anything more. Double glazing typically needs to be replaced around 20-30 years so they could well argue that it’s at the end of its natural life which caused the issue.

SweetnsourNZ · 09/11/2026 09:33

TheLette · 06/11/2026 20:55

Previous legal advice about Consumer Rights Act is correct about the 6 months period but ignores the 6 year limitation period for claims (this isn't stated in the Act but it's the applicable time period). You don't have a claim based on that Act because 20 years has passed. You might have some kind of claim based on product safety / recall laws - I don't know, I'm not that kind of lawyer (but I do know my stuff on the Consumer Rights Act and contract law !).

Btw this also happens quite often with glass shower screens - when my daughter was a baby she narrowly missed the glass going all over her because it happened when I was running the bath. But I think that's a known product risk generally; there was no recall for the particular shower screen we had.

Edited

I know someone recently who hadxa relatively new shower glass combustion. Home insurance covered it and the damage caused to bathroom. This was in New Zealand but I think our policies are the same. Also happens with oven doors, especially there is a slight movement in the alignment.
And glass tables.

GrumblingGeek · 09/11/2026 10:31

i’d try citizens advice or trading standards for advice

MeAndTheDoggo · 09/11/2026 17:42

I think 30% off is fair considering they’re 20 years old. It might be a fault but they’re not going to know whether it is a fault, or if it’s due to lack of care and watching for issues such as blown units

cluttered · 10/11/2026 05:25

Yes, Velux have posted on the codes of the defective batch on their website saying that windows made in that period may spontaneously shatter and that they will replace them. I would expect double glazing units of that age to fail and let in moisture etc but not to explode showering the vicinity with shards of non-safety glass. And they are not claiming any windows of that age could be dangerous, only those from the defective batch.

They have confirmed that 3 additional windows of mine in addition to the shattered one are defective so they will supply replacement glass but not install it. Obviously if there weren’t a safety risk I wouldn’t be paying to install new glass in windows that appeared perfectly fine!

Also, this event could have had catastrophic circumstances if my son hadn’t had the blind pulled down as these shards would have fallen onto his face while he was asleep. I would have thought that, if he had been seriously injured, we would have had a case against Velux for knowing there was a defect and not advising us? If someone bought a car 10 years ago and the manufacturer later became aware the brakes were defective but didn’t do their best to contact the owners, wouldn’t the manufacturer be held responsible if there were a fatal crash due to the brakes failing? Or is the law stricter for motor vehicles than other purchases?

OP posts:
Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 10/11/2026 05:30

Hope your son wasn’t too shook up, that must have been so scary! The response that their lawyers said they did enough is awful. I think they should have contacted everyone

allthemind · 10/11/2026 05:33

We had our velux glass of qualifying models replaced for free 2 years ago, after neighbours in house of same age shattered. They were put in in 2003. Im surprised they no longer do it for free.

cluttered · 10/11/2026 07:06

@allthemind that’s when ours were put in also! The customer service agent I spoke to said they’d stopped offering the installation and we’d have to pay for it ourselves.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page