Please or to access all these features

Legal matters

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.

Forecourt eye accusing me of unpaid fuel despite proof of payment

20 replies

Mimicha · 31/10/2026 23:37

Hi everyone, looking for some advice!

I've received a £90 demand from Forecourt Eye alleging that I failed to pay for fuel at a Tesco petrol station.

I've been back and forth trying to resolve this, and have now visited the Tesco Acton branch, where staff investigated and provided me with a receipt confirming that I purchased diesel and groceries totalling £23.62. The payment also shows on my bank statement.

The strange thing is that the evidence Forecourt Eye is using refers to Supreme unleaded petrol, even though my car is diesel!

I've appealed and provided the evidence, but Tesco keeps directing me back to Forecourt Eye rather than taking responsibility. I've also explained the stress, inconvenience and expense this has caused, including having to travel to the forecourt which is about a 30 min drive from my home.

Has anyone dealt with Forecourt Eye before? How likely are they to cancel the charge, and would I have a strong defence if they decided to take this to court?

Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 01/11/2026 07:45

It’s clearly not you and you have evidence so of course in a court case you’d win. Have they responded since you have provided copies of the receipt and bank statement and informed them your car runs on diesel?

Sally2791 · 01/11/2026 07:46

Have they quoted your reg number?

Meadowfinch · 01/11/2026 07:52

You have proof that you paid for your fuel and goods, and that your car uses diffrent fuel anyway, so I'd write to them again saying you have provided evidence to the contrary, you did not steal anything and you consider the conversation closed. Then ignore them. If they want to take you to court and end up looking spectacularly stupid. that is on them.

Either their system isn't working properly or someone has cloned your car and you may receive other bills.

You could call 101, report it to them as a possible cloning, and ask for advice.

goodnessgran · 01/11/2026 08:33

I can well imagine it’s very stressful. I would write to them (send it recorded/signed for delivery) with copies of your evidence and send directly to their CEO at HQ who currently looks to be someone called Nick Fisher. Also send a backup on email too.

Say that this is causing you a great deal of stress and unless you have an acknowledgement within 10 working days, you’ll have no choice but to pass the information on to a newspaper. Honestly, the Mail LOVES a good ‘furious customer’ story.

Of course you don’t have to go that far but it might spook them enough to take action.

NiaAndFar · 01/11/2026 08:43

I have had similar from a company called VARS. The trouble is thst you will be blocked from uding any poletrol station using this company. I paid it after emailing them to clearly say i was paying under duress. I have now sent them a letter before action demanding repaymrnt before small claims court. I don't know what eill happen... It seems the latest scam!

socialdilemmawhattodo · 01/11/2026 08:55

Have you asked to see the footage and photos. It might show a totally different car, or better still a van or truck.

JohnofWessex · 01/11/2026 09:06

NiaAndFar · 01/11/2026 08:43

I have had similar from a company called VARS. The trouble is thst you will be blocked from uding any poletrol station using this company. I paid it after emailing them to clearly say i was paying under duress. I have now sent them a letter before action demanding repaymrnt before small claims court. I don't know what eill happen... It seems the latest scam!

What about making a subject access request to see the details of the allegation followed by a complaint to the Information Comissioner?

There were organisations that maintained 'blacklists' in the past which came badly unstuck.

AS says

  • Defamation: Placing a company or individual on an internal or external blacklist risks defamation claims under the Defamation Act 2013. If a business entity is blacklisted, it can sue if it can prove the listing caused or is likely to cause serious financial loss.
  • Data Protection (UK GDPR / DPA 2018): Processing, storing, or sharing individuals' data on a blacklist without explicit legal grounds constitutes a severe breach of data protection laws, opening up the organization to heavy fines from the ICO. 1, 2, 3, 4]

Do either of you have any legal cover eg through Home/Car Insurance a Union etc

Employment Relations Act 1999 (Blacklists) Regulations 2010

The Employment Relations Act 1999 (Blacklists) Regulations 2010, No. 493 (as amended) Bespoke Legal Register Resource.

https://www.isova.co.uk/legal-register/the-employment-relations-act-1999-blacklists-regulations-2010

Passaggressfedup · 01/11/2026 09:07

That's almost no petrol. Are they suggesting you did get this petrol but came back with another car?

GooglePenguinBollardsIDareYou · 01/11/2026 09:17

I had similar from another company. I wrote an email copying my evidence of receipt, payment with location and business name of the exact amount they claimed I didn’t. Email below if it helps with my details removed. I had to send it 3 times including to their complaints department before they responded that they had closed the matter. I ignored all other letters/calls from them. I knew that if they tried to take me to court it would be an inconvenience but ultimately but they would lose. I didn’t get banned from petrol stations FYI.
FAO: QDR Solicitors

Dear Sir or Madam,

I write to formally dispute the debt claimed in your letter dated x date.

On x date I made a debit card payment at x petrol station , the same location cited in your letter, totalling £xx.xx. This transaction is confirmed on my bank statement and is enclosed as evidence. The fuel was paid for at the till as part of this transaction. The pump records your client relies upon log the time of filling, not the time of payment, which accounts for the difference in timestamps.

The alleged debt does not exist. No money is owed.

Please place all recovery and escalation activity on hold while the dispute is reviewed. I require written confirmation that:

  • My email and supporting evidence have been received
  • The account has been placed on hold
  • No police referral or further enforcement action will take place while the dispute remains unresolved
  • The alleged debt and administration fee will be removed once the payment evidence has been verified

I require you to close this matter and confirm in writing within 14 days that it has been resolved. I will not engage further by telephone.

Yours faithfully,

CelticSilver · 01/11/2026 09:35

I presume that's a typo for £123?! How did you get diesel and groceries for £23 without driving a DeLorean?

Ineffable23 · 01/11/2026 09:38

CelticSilver · 01/11/2026 09:35

I presume that's a typo for £123?! How did you get diesel and groceries for £23 without driving a DeLorean?

By putting £20 of petrol in and buying a thing of milk and a bag of carrots (or whatever)?

Mimicha · 01/11/2026 11:33

Yes exactly lol £20 of diesel, milk and a snack. They said they have the footage of my dispensing the DIESEL which I have paid for and the store manager has given me a store copy of my receipt. The manager acknowledged that it must be a mistake and that I should contact Tesco customer service , but they keep fobbing me off back to forecourt eye. I don't believe I should be using my time and effort chasing up their error. It is incredibly stressful. I have emailed the CEO, waiting to hear what they have to say.

OP posts:
JohnofWessex · 01/11/2026 14:03

Forecourt Eye are Tesco's contractors so the liability is with Tesco to sort it out

Ivegothewashingout · 01/11/2026 18:52

We had similar, but I can’t remember if it was Forecourt Eye.
We chased about through who ever sent the fine and got no where.
In desperation went to the petrol garage and had to return when the petrol station manager was present. Manager disappeared to look at the CCTV footage and came back and said it was an error and could see it was not us, but the car on the other side of the pump.
The store manager def has power to cancel.
Have you tried the actual petrol station, or the store. Have you pushed them to look at the CCTV?

Mimicha · 01/11/2026 18:58

Yes I did have a lengthy conversation with the store manager, where at first he was adamant it was me that dispensed the petrol...and then subsequently realised my car is a diesel and this is the same car I dispensed diesel for on the day. He retrieved my receipt and proof of payment and said I needed to take it up with Tesco customer services who have been useless up until now.

OP posts:
JohnofWessex · 01/11/2026 19:23

Information Comissioner?

They are holding inaccurate information about you

Mimicha · 01/11/2026 20:36

Oo thanks will look into that !

OP posts:
RobboDevon · 03/11/2026 10:04

Stop wasting your effort and time with Customer Services... Approach DIRECTLY their CEO team at with all details to [email protected] and [email protected]
ForecourtEye won't be interested in any conversation with you, nor will Customer Services as they're limited in what they can actually achieve.
The CEO will instruct the relevant team to deal with it.
I had same issue, goods paid for, retail assistant FAILED to enter fuel on system. Got a letter from ForecourtEye about the cost PLUS their £40 charge.

Add in to your email the following text...

Your cashier didn't spot the missing fuel charge and allowed me to leave, therefore believing I had paid as they offered me a receipt which is your companies methods a the till.
I will argue that the payment service wasn't performed with reasonable care and skill as required under Section 49 (1) Consumer Rights Act 2015
I am more than happy to settle the alleged cost of the FUEL ONLY and that you contact ForecourtEye to cancel the administration charge upon completion of my payment to yourselves or your nominated method
Should an amicable and simple resolution of me offering payment for the fuel but NOT the ForecourtEye administration charge I will seek a Subject Access Request for CCTV footage, till records for that day, the name of the retail assistant and their record of training, and any transaction logs for the time suggested in preparation for legal action.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 03/11/2026 10:17

RobboDevon · 03/11/2026 10:04

Stop wasting your effort and time with Customer Services... Approach DIRECTLY their CEO team at with all details to [email protected] and [email protected]
ForecourtEye won't be interested in any conversation with you, nor will Customer Services as they're limited in what they can actually achieve.
The CEO will instruct the relevant team to deal with it.
I had same issue, goods paid for, retail assistant FAILED to enter fuel on system. Got a letter from ForecourtEye about the cost PLUS their £40 charge.

Add in to your email the following text...

Your cashier didn't spot the missing fuel charge and allowed me to leave, therefore believing I had paid as they offered me a receipt which is your companies methods a the till.
I will argue that the payment service wasn't performed with reasonable care and skill as required under Section 49 (1) Consumer Rights Act 2015
I am more than happy to settle the alleged cost of the FUEL ONLY and that you contact ForecourtEye to cancel the administration charge upon completion of my payment to yourselves or your nominated method
Should an amicable and simple resolution of me offering payment for the fuel but NOT the ForecourtEye administration charge I will seek a Subject Access Request for CCTV footage, till records for that day, the name of the retail assistant and their record of training, and any transaction logs for the time suggested in preparation for legal action.

Edited

Op paid for her diesel. The penalty is for petrol, so why are you suggesting she should pay for goods she didnt have or use?

Mimicha · 03/11/2026 10:52

I think you may have misunderstood, there is no missing fuel charge - I paid for my diesel and they are alleging I dispensed £50 worth of supreme unleaded petrol. I have my receipt and have discussed with the manager of the store who said to contact Tesco customer service who have been useless. Yes I have now emailed the CEO. They are looking into it . Will keep the thread updated as soon as I hear back!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page