Please or to access all these features

Higher education

Talk to other parents whose children are preparing for university on our Higher Education forum.

DC hating Oxbridge as modules cancelled

29 replies

Liesmorelies · Today 05:13

Obviously I'm being vague in some respects as I don't want to out my YP (hence Oxbridge for a start) but essentially they are doing the Art/Humanities degree of their dreams in the place of their dreams and have been getting excellent feedback etc - not struggling with the work or anything like that. But come Y2 A LOT of the specialist modules they were really looking forward to doing have not run and, on enquiry, may not run next year either. It means the whole area of study they are most interested in is now not really a part of the degree.

YP is so upset about this they are now questioning even being there. It's like doing art and not doing any of your favourite movements or artists ever. Obviously you know you won't be doing them all the time, but now you are never doing anything on them at all. With the modules for next term, they didn't even get their first choice, which any other year would not have been something they would have chosen anyway. So they are doing something they don't have any real interest in at all. Passion for their subject was got them there and it's not being fulfilled.

They are constantly ringing and messaging saying they want to drop out. I think they are now spiralling and saying there are no jobs out there but at least they would have enjoyed the degree but now there's no point - just £££ debt for nothing at all. I don't know what to say. I am so disappointed for them and just don't know what to suggest. They've spoken to some staff who've been sympathetic, but there's nothing they can really do. Does anyone have any thoughts or advice please?

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · Today 05:32

Have they spoken to their Director of Studies? They need to be focused in who they talk to.

Is there a possibility that they will be having more elective options next year, like a dissertation, in the field they want? Can they start setting that up now with the DoS’s help, to visit an academic who might supervise that and get to know them?

I get that this is not ok but I do also firmly believe that nothing is wasted. This could be a scenic route but I think they will get to where they want to be. As for jobs… it’s not great but there ARE jobs. I hope they’re not doomscrolling all the AI shite, it’s just not helpful. Suggest a phone detox??

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · Today 05:38

If their favourite topics are offered at another university, your DC could almost certainly arrange a transfer. Universities will generally accept an Oxbridge student who has passed their first year to go into their 2nd year. Student loans funding will stretch to allow a change like this if needed. Obviously they don't get the kudos of the Oxbridge degree but it's more important to be studying where you will thrive than it is to have that kudos.

Generalising as "Oxbridge" to avoid specifics isn't much of a disguise. Cambridge degrees use a module structure. Most Oxford degrees that I am familiar with do not, except for the "life long learning" pathways that are entirely separate from the normal undergraduate pathways. Undergraduate degrees at Oxford have a universal structure for the syllabus that each student will follow, with quite limited flexibility for options.

Lovelyview · Today 05:55

How annoying for your child. I would assume that as they're into the second year they will have to withdraw and then start in the second year of another university next October. How do they feel about friend groups and potentially having to make new friends at a new university? I think if there's another university that offers an ideal curriculum it might be worth considering moving although given the state of further education there will probably be no guarantee those modules will be available next October either. Can they pick a dissertation topic in the area they're interested in? That might be a factor worth considering.

Liesmorelies · Today 06:08

Thanks all. It just seems ridiculous to move from Oxbridge after all the weight that they placed on getting there in the first place but perhaps it would be for the best - I just don't know. And I don't know how they'd cope if they went somewhere else and it was a similar picture! They do have a dissertation coming up which they were really looking forward to so I think getting started on that might help. Tutors had mentioned a masters in this area, but now YP is saying would they even have someone to supervise it? I wish they didn't have such a niche interest...

OP posts:
Whyherewego · Today 06:11

If their passion is something specific and that is what they anticipated pursuing post degree then they'd prob be worth giving some thought to transferring to another uni that does offer this topic.

If it was just their interest and they don't know yet what they want to do career wise then Oxbridge is a good place to springboard from for the world of work.
If they can do their dissertation in this topic then it doesn't sound too bad ?

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 06:14

I would look at other universities. DD1's subject isn't even offered at Oxford or Cambridge.

OneZanyCat · Today 06:19

I've not come across this, normally it's relatively protected at Cambridge / Oxford but it niche maybe there was only one academic or two. It maybe worth trying to find out what has happened to cause this like if the academic is on a sabbatical (in my subject they used to have them every 7 years) it could be the issue is one year only. Or if they have retired or left and it's niche it may be longer.

I would investigate are there other ways they could study the subject, you can sometimes move course though normally at end of part 1 and sometimes would mean restarting. Or look at other universities if it's something offered elsewhere though they could get same issue elsewhere and more costs. But if they investigate can think of solution and consider pros and cons. Though if they can do a dissertation in it and possibly join interest groups it maybe ok. It might be worth talking to students in year above in their subject to see their views. The just dropping out with no plan obviously not a great idea.

AlliumDelights · Today 06:30

But some of the modules might run next year - it's not a definite no. The dissertation route suggested by the previous poster sounds like a good option.

This does happen - a friend of mine at Uni did a year abroad because a lecturer was on sabbatical the year that he wanted to do an historical archaeology course in our history degree. But really my friend should have been doing a different degree (archaeology) at another University and his family vetoed that because family tradition dictated which Uni you went to. But that course was very niche and with sabatticals or just teaching refreshment, it can happen that that what you've set your heart on isn't available.

I think talk of dropping out is a bit worrying and a bit of an extreme reaction. If they are doing the degree they want to do, then the skills they are learning can be applied to the topic they love in reading outside the classroom. It's hard to say if they are being too inflexible of mind from the limited detail you've given. If no early modern history were available at all that's one thing but no courses on Reformation history in the Low Countries is another.

Perhaps they could go to their personal tutor again to talk this out to see if there is a different way to approach this: either broadening out their interests or finding away into the topic via dissertation?

AlliumDelights · Today 06:38

Liesmorelies · Today 06:08

Thanks all. It just seems ridiculous to move from Oxbridge after all the weight that they placed on getting there in the first place but perhaps it would be for the best - I just don't know. And I don't know how they'd cope if they went somewhere else and it was a similar picture! They do have a dissertation coming up which they were really looking forward to so I think getting started on that might help. Tutors had mentioned a masters in this area, but now YP is saying would they even have someone to supervise it? I wish they didn't have such a niche interest...

If they are talking about Masters in the area, then it sounds very niche and they are trying to specialise too soon OP.

Dozer · Today 06:53

The spiralling is a concern. Is DC enjoying it and coping (socially etc) overall? If so, they’d probably be best making the best of what’s still on offer and doing their area of interest for the dissertation.

I’d ask DC whether they have investigated the offer and potential to go into year 2 at other universities; and what their plan would be if they drop out of university entirely for the moment, limiting funding, loans etc if they later decide to do a degree.

Job seeking won’t be any easier with no degree.

I’d be irritated with the uni, including about the talk of a masters - at huge expense! - instead of what was advertised for undergraduate, but other than request the modules not a lot DC can do about university decisions.

BadSkiingMum · Today 07:00

Are the modules likely to return in another academic year?
If so, could they take a year out and then carry on?

Otherwise, if there is no real solution then I think they should probably carry on and make the best of it. They will be coming out with an Oxbridge degree which many people would be very happy to have!

For my own part I was very restricted in where I could study and did an undergraduate degree in a place that was well regarded but wasn’t really my choice, let alone my ‘dream’. It never grabbed at my heartstrings but I definitely enjoyed elements of the course and ultimately I got my degree and just moved on to the next stage of my life.

The only problem is that I have developed a love of studying and done multiple courses during my working life, perhaps because it wasn’t quite right the first time!

phyllidafosset · Today 07:02

I think trying to dial them back from this as a catastrophe is really important. If they enjoyed year 1, then there are aspects of the subject they are enjoying more broadly which is really important. They seem to have enjoyed Oxbridge as an experience too. Undergraduate degrees are about building thinking and learning skills, they are never the moment where you get to really come to grips with an intellectual passion, that is what PhDs are for 😊. Really, a module or two in an area is such a surface scratch. I totally appreciate that it is a huge disappointment, but tell them the degree is absolutely not a waste of time because, as others have said absolutely it can be a dissertation (even if there is nobody there to teach the module there will almost certainly be someone with enough transferable knowledge to supervise the dissertation), and then they can lean into it more at MA (hopefully) but even if not much at ‘taught’ levels, absolutely at PhD level (somewhere else if there is nobody there). Then, job wise, they can go back and teach the course for a job 😊

Essentially, they are getting all the skills they need, they will be able to do it at dissertation level, and then it is still there for them at much deeper, and at what will be much more satisfying, deeper and more rigorous levels of study once they have built the core learning skills through their undergraduate degree (and probably an MA).

And the PhD potentially fills the job concerns hole too.

I absolutely would not suggest changing degrees midway through second year for a few modules. Nothing is worth that disruption, particularly not because they can be encouraged to make their own path towards it via dissertation and MA (if nothing more, through a bigger dissertation), and then PhD. If they would never be interested in this at PhD level then that is absolutely okay, but a dissertation and pursuing their interest independently as a hobby with the skills they will have acquired is also entirely okay. Their interest is still there and they absolutely can explore it.

AlliumDelights · Today 07:08

@DozerI work at a Uni and mentioning the postgraduate pathway is reasonable if you have a student who might want to specialise at some stage - it's just an option. No university can guarantee specific undergraduate course offerings.

My own specialism isn't currently available at the department my husband is teaching at. I've just woken him to ask what he'd advise a student in that situation and he said the dissertation is probably the route forward. I hope some solution can be found for this student that allows their interests to be studied.

My friend is now lecturing in an Archaeology department although I was the one who broke it to him that the course wasn't running the next year - his face 😮

SoftIce · Today 07:16

DC sounds a little too focused, perhaps. When I started my first degree, I was like that - I was convinced I would go into one specific sub-field. I then developed a passion for a completely different sub-field. Later again, I was able to see the beauty of all the different sub-fields.

It is good to have a passion but at undergraduate level it shouldn't be all consuming, you should be interested (or at least open to be interested) in many things. If DC is very unhappy for reasons which could be fixed at another university, then move. But personally, I wouldn't move just because modules have been cancelled.

(I do get that DC was looking forward to them, and it is a shame, but normally there should be plenty to interest DC.)

AlliumDelights · Today 07:18

I always saw myself as an early modernist and now I've moved into the nineteenth century - I blame the menopause.

LeopardOnEverything · Today 07:19

Sounds like an opportunity to build resilience and versatility. Maybe it's also time for DC to start looking into postgraduate study in their favourite area - a relevant bachelor's degree from Cambridge will open doors just about anywhere.

TheCompactPussycat · Today 07:35

You'll find this happens in most universities so I doubt moving will really solve things. I understand that it's disappointing but optional modules tend to reflect the personal interests of lecturers in the department. It's not like a school curriculum where another member of staff can just teach the same content.

Academics cannot be forced to stay in a job simply because a student hoped to take their module a year or two from now. Academia is a pretty precarious employment option these days and one of the results is that there is a higher turnover of academic staff and therefore a higher turnover of optional modules to study.

gingerbreadandlemonade · Today 08:02

Masters courses are hard fought so don’t worry about that too much, they may choose another institution.
in the meantime, transfer or rusticate.
they can use the year to figure out whether the degree is important or not and then return.

Genevieva · Today 09:37

They are nearing the end of the first term of year 2. It might feel like there is a long time ahead, but assuming this is a 3 year degree, they are half way through the content teaching time before finals. I suggest discussing the issue, finding support for any areas of freedom that might bring hope, then focussing on doing as well as possible do that they can go on to study a taught masters in the specialism of their choice. There are lots of other aspects of Oxbridge life, including academic enrichment clubs, societies and projects, discussion groups etc. They can continue studying the area of interest beyond the taught curriculum.

Wadsworthy · Today 11:09

There are many many reasons why students should never rely on all optional modules being available to them at any point in their degree.

Degree programmes commit to teaching the core of the subject in compulsory or core modules & curriculum. Optional modules are regularly changed, moved, or rested.

At a place like Cambridge - and at any research-led university (Russell Group mostly) - optional modules will often map onto staff research interests - it's called research-led teaching & it's really important part of stretching and challenging students, as well as disseminating hot off the press research. It is also in the nature of such modules that they are regularly changed and rotated - keeping them fresh and relevant to the latest research & knowledge.

There are other staffing reasons. It could be that the academic teaching in the area is on sabbatical, or maternity leave, or has left to work elsewhere, or is working on something else, or has a serious illness, or has been given other duties in academic leadership which take them away from a lot of teaching for a few years.

Your DC needs to undertstand this.

They also need to understand that in an excellent department & university ANY module they do will give them something - will give them what they need, and teach them something they didn't know they needed. You DC is being taught by world experts - they do actually know what they're doing.

clary · Today 11:48

I agree with those saying ideally the YP needs to find a way to live with this and continue at Cambridge. Or Oxford. As other say, sometimes modules don’t run bc staff move or take sabbatical, there is lower uptake, there are logistical reasons.

My DD was very disappointed when a module which had initially attracted her to the Eng lit course she took (a specialist was at the uni) did not run in her final year. In fact it was under-subscribed and her PT suggested she do a dissertation on it – obvs supervised by the specialist. She hadn’t initially planned to do a diss (it was optional) but it turned out to be a really good way to go and meant she could pick an area of specific interest within that module. Plus it counted for more in the end than the module would have. So as others suggest, this could actually be a positive. Sometimes (often) you have to find a workaround and this is a good lesson in that.

How much of a big deal is the module anyway? I don’t have direct experience of Oxford or Cambs but at my DCs’ unis a module was just run for one semester and was only part of the work they did then. Does it have a bigger impact at your DC’s uni, as in, it runs for the whole year or forms most of the content for a semester?

ETA Apols I have read the OP properly and it's about several modules. I still think a degree from Oxford (or Cambridge) is surely worth more than some possible modules that also may not run at another uni.

Bronde · Today 11:57

Have a DC at Cambs (also humanities) and find this quite odd. Didn't your DC choose their modules in the summer term? And were they not selected for any of them, and then the ones they were selected for cancelled?

Perhaps each college and course is different - but this sounds quite strange based on my understanding of how it works. Is your DC's area of interest very niche? Is there nothing within their course now that excites them?

What I would say, based on chatting to several of DC's non-Oxbridge friends, the tutor contact time and the extent of a wide variety of academic specialisms, often doesn't really compare at other unis. So I'd think VERY carefully about ditching the course and going elsewhere - your DC could end up even more unfulfilled.

AmberSpy · Today 11:57

LeopardOnEverything · Today 07:19

Sounds like an opportunity to build resilience and versatility. Maybe it's also time for DC to start looking into postgraduate study in their favourite area - a relevant bachelor's degree from Cambridge will open doors just about anywhere.

Came here to say this. I have some sympathy for your DC, OP, but frankly talking about dropping out seems a bit over dramatic and self-indulgent. I'd do your best to nip that in the bud - point out that Arts and Humanities subjects are being cut back at many top universities, so the grass isn't necessarily greener anywhere else.

Be kind and supportive, obviously, but try to encourage them to see this as an opportunity to extend their interests and expertise. I'm saying this as someone who also read a Humanities subject at Oxbridge and sometimes had to be rather flexible about module choices - it's done me no harm whatsoever, and it probably taught me quite a lot about not sweating the small stuff.

Unfortunately adult life is sometimes about facing up to your disappointments and then cracking on anyway. Dropping out of an Oxbridge degree when they have every chance of succeeding at it would be a very silly response.

ThreadPence · Today 12:33

AlliumDelights · Today 06:30

But some of the modules might run next year - it's not a definite no. The dissertation route suggested by the previous poster sounds like a good option.

This does happen - a friend of mine at Uni did a year abroad because a lecturer was on sabbatical the year that he wanted to do an historical archaeology course in our history degree. But really my friend should have been doing a different degree (archaeology) at another University and his family vetoed that because family tradition dictated which Uni you went to. But that course was very niche and with sabatticals or just teaching refreshment, it can happen that that what you've set your heart on isn't available.

I think talk of dropping out is a bit worrying and a bit of an extreme reaction. If they are doing the degree they want to do, then the skills they are learning can be applied to the topic they love in reading outside the classroom. It's hard to say if they are being too inflexible of mind from the limited detail you've given. If no early modern history were available at all that's one thing but no courses on Reformation history in the Low Countries is another.

Perhaps they could go to their personal tutor again to talk this out to see if there is a different way to approach this: either broadening out their interests or finding away into the topic via dissertation?

A family tradition dictating what uni someone goes to? What the hell is wrong with the parents?

ThreadPence · Today 12:39

Encourage them to think about modules less in terms of specific content (periods, personalities, events and so on), and more in terms of the analytical lenses, theoretical frameworks and methodologies they are using. For instance, if they are interested in gender they will learn a great deal that is interesting and transferable regardless of the specific history, art, literature, or whatever their degree is focussed on.