Please or to access all these features

Higher education

Talk to other parents whose children are preparing for university on our Higher Education forum.

DD is unhappy at new sixth form - possible to change?

36 replies

AmusedHare · 13/11/2026 23:07

My DD (16) started at a private school this year and so far seems to hate it. She complains to me every day that there’s no intellectual challenge and that the support for STEM subjects and university entrance exams (she’s taking Maths, Further Maths, Physics and Computing) is abysmal. According to her, her HOY is also an awful bully who takes every chance possible to pick on DD, such as enacting more and more extreme punishments for very minor lateness (recently she tried to give DD a 90 minute after school detention for being just 5 minutes late) and keeps pressuring her to drop an A Level even though she’s made it clear that she doesn’t want to.

She hasn’t made any friends and seems to be quite lonely at her new school. Her grades have also started suffering as she just feels so isolated and under stimulated at this new school. I’ve also had my fair share of trouble with the school, such as teachers at the school acting shifty and outright lying to me about my own daughter.

I know it’s quite late to be looking at switching sixth form but would there be any chance she would be able to get a place at another school this late in the year? She’s told me upfront that if she would have to restart Year 12 to go to a different school, she would rather stick it out at this one. But this school really seems to be draining the life out of her, everyday she seems to come home more miserable than the last and I just don’t see how she could live like this for the next two years.

OP posts:
cestlavielife · 13/11/2026 23:12

Why did you choose the school?

What does this mean?
"
acting shifty and outright lying to me about my own daughter."

What other schools are an ootion? Go talk to them

Bufftailed · 13/11/2026 23:15

Crack on and email all the local ones. She sounds like a good student and if they do same exam boards they might take her. Tricky situation.

SylvanMoon · 14/11/2026 08:31

I would think another sixth form would take her, but the problem will be whether they're doing the same exam boards, although the content she's covered so far is probably transferrable across them all. What does she mean by the support for university entrance exams being abysmal? What entrance exams is she talking about and what sort of support for this would she be expecting in her first term of a two-year A-Level?

fairyring25 · 14/11/2026 11:15

As your DD has not made friends and is very unhappy, hopefully, you can find her a new school that does the same exam boards by calling around. However, all schools will punish students who are late-even if it is only 5 minutes twice a week. Also, if your DD's grades are dropping and she is struggling maybe it is a good idea to drop one subject to focus on three. Schools will not prepare for university entrance exams until at least the summer term of Year 12-it is too early now.

Offherrockingchair · 14/11/2026 11:16

Why are you paying for this?!

Pinkissmart · 14/11/2026 12:09

Op, her grades are dropping, so of course her teachers are going to recommend she drops her 4th A level. Why is she clinging on to it?

There are so many things she can do to push herself- public online lectures, MOOCS, personal projects ( especially with CS).

It is only for a year and a half more. If she likes her subjects, she needs to just get her head down and concentrate on study.

Has she stayed on from secondary?

MeshMesh · 14/11/2026 14:09

Sack the place off, go state and save a load of cash.

ifonlytheydlisten · 14/11/2026 19:36

Why did you choose it out of interest? My DD is at a very large stare 6th form and experience is polar opposite. I have never heard of detention at that age. They are normally treated as adults

AmusedHare · 14/11/2026 23:22

I had heard from a friend whose daughter did similar A Levels that it was a good school, and out of the ones DD had applied to it was the closest commute wise so she found it most preferable. According to DD it’s quite uncommon at her sixth form for most teachers to give detentions, but she says her HOY gives out detentions quite frequently for relatively minor things such as forgetting to put on her lanyard or being in the halls during form time.

OP posts:
AmusedHare · 14/11/2026 23:32

ifonlytheydlisten · 14/11/2026 19:36

Why did you choose it out of interest? My DD is at a very large stare 6th form and experience is polar opposite. I have never heard of detention at that age. They are normally treated as adults

I had heard from a friend whose daughter did similar A Levels that it was a good school, and out of the ones DD had applied to it was the closest commute wise so she found it most preferable. According to DD it’s quite uncommon at her sixth form for most teachers to give detentions, but she says her HOY gives out detentions quite frequently for relatively minor things such as forgetting to put on her lanyard or being in the halls during form time.

OP posts:
Moreholidaysthanjudithchalmers · 15/11/2026 12:15

Realistically I think she’d have to restart yr12 in September.
If her grades are falling then dropping to 3 seems sensible. Most courses only want 3 A levels.
The things you mention lateness, in corridor when shouldn’t, no lanyard are often dealt with firmly by schools as that’s what parents want. Has she got adhd? If so ensure school are aware.
In terms of prep for exams it’s usually driven by students as they are high achieving and demonstrating their passion for subject. My dd was at a grammar and all LNAT (law) prep was by herself zero from school (they were awkward about her having morning off to sit it!)
Likewise intellectual challenge, reading beyond class work it’s student led.
Is she doing an EPQ? That’s good for challenging them and helping with transition to uni mentality.
It doesn’t sound a good fit. She may be best suited to a more relaxed sixth form college.
There’s no rush for uni. Better to be happy and get great grades a year later than middling grades at 18.

poetryandwine · 15/11/2026 13:27

Hello, OP -

I am a former STEM admissions tutor. My School is very high tariff, in the tier just below COWI. From my perspective there are a few different things going on here.

I cannot comment on the disciplinary side of things, or on the teachers’ behaviour towards you and DD.

It us undoubtedly true that unhappiness and the resulting stress can affect academic performance. Given the strength of DD’s feelings, I think this is a reason to consider changing to a different Sixth Form if possible.
(Note however that she will be subject to standard policies wherever she goes.)

At the same time, whether DD changes or not, it would be good to unpack what is happening a bit further. DD is taking three of the most demanding A levels plus a less inherently challenging but time intensive one (CS). Whilst the stresses of unhappiness nay be affecting her performance, the notion that she is underperforming because she is under-challenged is not going to cut much ice. The more mature response to being under-challenged - and one DD is old enough to appreciate, especially as she seems ambitious - is at minimum to ace all of your work before turning to mischief or tuning out, if not going the extra mile for yourself intellectually.

So I think it is possible that DD may be struggling a bit more than she is sharing. Nothing wrong with that. As a general principle, admissions tutors prefer to see what applicants can do at their best, and prefer three A levels showing full potential to four A levels with compromised marks. Perhaps her teachers know this.

Every university in the land will offer on three A levels. One exception is that a few programmes or Colleges at Cambridge explicitly want applicants to have a typical workload for their Sixth Form. However Cambridge is full of Maths and Physics students with Maths, FM and Physics (only).
Another anomaly is that many programmes at Imperial will make students doing four A levels a dual offer, either three A stars ( as long as the fourth A level is sat) or two A stars and two As.

In my admissions role I saw too many applicants who would have benefitted from dropping an A level. Even if DD is undecided between Physics and CS, she can make a very strong CS application with Maths, FM and Physics, keeping up an interest in CS on the side. No Russell Group university requires CS A level for admission to the CS degrees.

In my personal life I have seen a fresh start for a dearly beloved and gifted child in a similar situation make all the difference in the world. I know that for the only time in a highly distinguished academic career, they genuinely struggled academically during the period of their unhappiness, so I see the possibility that something similar could be happening with your DD. I hope she will get that new start.

However as PP say autumn of Y12 is very early for any school to be organising tuition for university entrance exams. If DD wants to start getting an idea of what these are about, she can go to the MEI website. I haven’t checked it recently but they usually have a section devoted to mock exams, exam prep, etc. They sometimes offer in-person and/or online (paid) tuition that she might consider signing up for.

Best wishes to DD.

poetryandwine · 15/11/2026 13:29

PS Strongly agree with the closing sentence from @Moreholidaysthanjudithchalmers !

MeridaBrave · 15/11/2026 13:39

Email the local private ones. But doesn’t sounds like she is coping with 4 A levels.

If you in London I recommend Brampton College.

AmusedHare · 15/11/2026 16:25

poetryandwine · 15/11/2026 13:27

Hello, OP -

I am a former STEM admissions tutor. My School is very high tariff, in the tier just below COWI. From my perspective there are a few different things going on here.

I cannot comment on the disciplinary side of things, or on the teachers’ behaviour towards you and DD.

It us undoubtedly true that unhappiness and the resulting stress can affect academic performance. Given the strength of DD’s feelings, I think this is a reason to consider changing to a different Sixth Form if possible.
(Note however that she will be subject to standard policies wherever she goes.)

At the same time, whether DD changes or not, it would be good to unpack what is happening a bit further. DD is taking three of the most demanding A levels plus a less inherently challenging but time intensive one (CS). Whilst the stresses of unhappiness nay be affecting her performance, the notion that she is underperforming because she is under-challenged is not going to cut much ice. The more mature response to being under-challenged - and one DD is old enough to appreciate, especially as she seems ambitious - is at minimum to ace all of your work before turning to mischief or tuning out, if not going the extra mile for yourself intellectually.

So I think it is possible that DD may be struggling a bit more than she is sharing. Nothing wrong with that. As a general principle, admissions tutors prefer to see what applicants can do at their best, and prefer three A levels showing full potential to four A levels with compromised marks. Perhaps her teachers know this.

Every university in the land will offer on three A levels. One exception is that a few programmes or Colleges at Cambridge explicitly want applicants to have a typical workload for their Sixth Form. However Cambridge is full of Maths and Physics students with Maths, FM and Physics (only).
Another anomaly is that many programmes at Imperial will make students doing four A levels a dual offer, either three A stars ( as long as the fourth A level is sat) or two A stars and two As.

In my admissions role I saw too many applicants who would have benefitted from dropping an A level. Even if DD is undecided between Physics and CS, she can make a very strong CS application with Maths, FM and Physics, keeping up an interest in CS on the side. No Russell Group university requires CS A level for admission to the CS degrees.

In my personal life I have seen a fresh start for a dearly beloved and gifted child in a similar situation make all the difference in the world. I know that for the only time in a highly distinguished academic career, they genuinely struggled academically during the period of their unhappiness, so I see the possibility that something similar could be happening with your DD. I hope she will get that new start.

However as PP say autumn of Y12 is very early for any school to be organising tuition for university entrance exams. If DD wants to start getting an idea of what these are about, she can go to the MEI website. I haven’t checked it recently but they usually have a section devoted to mock exams, exam prep, etc. They sometimes offer in-person and/or online (paid) tuition that she might consider signing up for.

Best wishes to DD.

Certainly possible. So far in her November Assessments she did achieve AAA*A so I’m not currently too worried about those to be honest. I think specifically her school doesn’t offer any aid to do with university exams at all. More specifically I think in terms of university preparation her school only mandates that all students attend a weekly enrichment lecture, as well as mandating every student volunteer inside of school four times throughout year 12 and participate in two work experience opportunities. I think she was unhappy with this because so far all the lectures have been unrelated to her subjects (seemingly only to do with history or geography or politics thus far), and she believes that work experience isn’t very important for the degrees she’d be considering.

OP posts:
AmusedHare · 15/11/2026 18:06

Moreholidaysthanjudithchalmers · 15/11/2026 12:15

Realistically I think she’d have to restart yr12 in September.
If her grades are falling then dropping to 3 seems sensible. Most courses only want 3 A levels.
The things you mention lateness, in corridor when shouldn’t, no lanyard are often dealt with firmly by schools as that’s what parents want. Has she got adhd? If so ensure school are aware.
In terms of prep for exams it’s usually driven by students as they are high achieving and demonstrating their passion for subject. My dd was at a grammar and all LNAT (law) prep was by herself zero from school (they were awkward about her having morning off to sit it!)
Likewise intellectual challenge, reading beyond class work it’s student led.
Is she doing an EPQ? That’s good for challenging them and helping with transition to uni mentality.
It doesn’t sound a good fit. She may be best suited to a more relaxed sixth form college.
There’s no rush for uni. Better to be happy and get great grades a year later than middling grades at 18.

Her grades aren’t really dropping in all subjects, only Applied Maths and Physics are below what I’d expect. Aside from that all 90% + and for the combination of subjects she’s taking I don’t think she can viably drop Physics. She does have ADHD and I’ve informed the school about it.

OP posts:
ReprogramNeeded · 15/11/2026 18:21

I would think that another independent sixth form would take her before Xmas - lots of them have space now and will want the money. But, wouldn't you have to give two terms' notice to the school if you withdraw her?

It sounds a little bit like you and your DD don't really respect the policies of the school, though, and everywhere you go there will be policies that you might not like. Being in the right place at the right time is really important, and you might discuss with school what would help your DD do that, and make clear to your DD she must do better. It sounds a little bit like because she is so clever, you/she thinks things don't apply to her. Volunteering, guest lectures, and work experience are all ready valuable to all young people IMO. Why on earth would she think she wouldn't benefit from work experience??

BePeachNewt · 15/11/2026 18:31

AmusedHare · 15/11/2026 16:25

Certainly possible. So far in her November Assessments she did achieve AAA*A so I’m not currently too worried about those to be honest. I think specifically her school doesn’t offer any aid to do with university exams at all. More specifically I think in terms of university preparation her school only mandates that all students attend a weekly enrichment lecture, as well as mandating every student volunteer inside of school four times throughout year 12 and participate in two work experience opportunities. I think she was unhappy with this because so far all the lectures have been unrelated to her subjects (seemingly only to do with history or geography or politics thus far), and she believes that work experience isn’t very important for the degrees she’d be considering.

What university entrance exam specifically does she think she needs to prep for? TMUA?

Noodles1234 · 15/11/2026 18:37

Being in the hall during form time and being 5 minutes late would also be sanctionable at my 6th Form as this is truancy, her KS4 school would have been the same? A one off lateness is fine, multiple occasions is avoidance, and usually for 6th form students is they want the more laid back of college but staff on tap like 6th form. I’m not for one moment assuming your DD is truanting, but attendance even form attendance is mandatory. Work with the school, find out what is happening and take what they say on board (as some teens start to enjoy their freedom a little too much).

It could be some find 6th Form suffocating and the stress builds, Private Schools often take their grades seriously especially now, so they could be on her case to adhere, and they may care about her too.

If she is really not happy enquire around and see if they are able to swap, I am not wholly sure but enquire sooner rather than later.

CurlyKoalie · 15/11/2026 18:38

Was she at a state school for her GCSE exams? It's not clear from the OP.
If so, the private school may be a very different regime to the one she was used to.
From your later post her grades look Ok in most subjects so far, so perhaps she is missing the friends she had in year 11. Where did they all go?
Perhaps they are telling her about a very different offering at a 6 th form college? In truth, most do offer a more relaxed atmosphere. Some students respond well to that. Some don't.
The lanyard thing is non negotiable in most 6 th forms and many workplaces these days because of safeguarding and persistent refusal to comply might carry a sanction wherever she goes.
Lots of students move before Christmas in Year 12. I would give her the freedom to choose if she wants to stay or move because she seems unhappy where she is but warn her that she will have to take the consequences if she lacks the maturity to work as hard in a less structured environment environment.

Remembers93 · 15/11/2026 19:03

AmusedHare · 14/11/2026 23:22

I had heard from a friend whose daughter did similar A Levels that it was a good school, and out of the ones DD had applied to it was the closest commute wise so she found it most preferable. According to DD it’s quite uncommon at her sixth form for most teachers to give detentions, but she says her HOY gives out detentions quite frequently for relatively minor things such as forgetting to put on her lanyard or being in the halls during form time.

These are not ‘minor’ things - wearing a lanyard is a basic safeguarding requirement and should be addressed.
Additionally, three A-levels is the recommendation for almost all students. The very top universities in this country want to see excellence in three, rather than a diluted performance across four. If your child wants something extra, I would recommend EPQ - some universities lower offers for this. Please listen to your child’s school in respect of the advice offered regarding her subjects: I am a teacher of 25 years’ experience and a current 6th form tutor, and can tell you that there are few things more irritating about the job than parents who seem to think they know better than those who are expert.

TB23 · 15/11/2026 20:06

So who picked this school? At her age and stage in her education surely she did after having been given options? Why is she doing 4 A-Levels? Who advised that because most often it isn't advisable? What are the teachers lying about? Was she late once or was this a repeated issue? All seems somewhat peculiar. Most sixth forms are very much invested in their students' further options. If she wants to swap, it will depend on whether the new college offers the exact same courses and exam boards, otherwise she'd have to repeat a year.

AmusedHare · 15/11/2026 20:48

CurlyKoalie · 15/11/2026 18:38

Was she at a state school for her GCSE exams? It's not clear from the OP.
If so, the private school may be a very different regime to the one she was used to.
From your later post her grades look Ok in most subjects so far, so perhaps she is missing the friends she had in year 11. Where did they all go?
Perhaps they are telling her about a very different offering at a 6 th form college? In truth, most do offer a more relaxed atmosphere. Some students respond well to that. Some don't.
The lanyard thing is non negotiable in most 6 th forms and many workplaces these days because of safeguarding and persistent refusal to comply might carry a sanction wherever she goes.
Lots of students move before Christmas in Year 12. I would give her the freedom to choose if she wants to stay or move because she seems unhappy where she is but warn her that she will have to take the consequences if she lacks the maturity to work as hard in a less structured environment environment.

Her old school was a state school, which she seemed to enjoy more even though she didn’t have any close friends, but unfortunately that school didn’t have a sixth form. It may either be to do with this being a different school or that it’s sixth form, but in my opinion her new school is much stricter than her old one. In her old school, there was no punishment for being late to form unless it was extremely frequent, and detentions were extremely rare and only generally given for very grave offences. But she hasn’t gotten any detentions for not wearing her lanyard or being in the halls during form, I’ve just heard this anecdotally and in the behavioural policy. She’s only been late to form, otherwise she’s been handing in all her work on time and wearing her lanyard all day.

OP posts:
AmusedHare · 15/11/2026 21:08

Noodles1234 · 15/11/2026 18:37

Being in the hall during form time and being 5 minutes late would also be sanctionable at my 6th Form as this is truancy, her KS4 school would have been the same? A one off lateness is fine, multiple occasions is avoidance, and usually for 6th form students is they want the more laid back of college but staff on tap like 6th form. I’m not for one moment assuming your DD is truanting, but attendance even form attendance is mandatory. Work with the school, find out what is happening and take what they say on board (as some teens start to enjoy their freedom a little too much).

It could be some find 6th Form suffocating and the stress builds, Private Schools often take their grades seriously especially now, so they could be on her case to adhere, and they may care about her too.

If she is really not happy enquire around and see if they are able to swap, I am not wholly sure but enquire sooner rather than later.

At her old school, detentions were extremely rare and generally there was no punishment for being late to form other than a verbal warning unless it was regular. Though it could be different for sixth formers. According to this school’s policy policy, the way it works is if someone is late to form time, they receive a half hour morning detention before school from 7:55-8:25. If they’re late to form six or more times, the punishment for being late becomes a 90 minute detention from 16:00-17:30 or an hour lunchtime detention from 13:00-14:00 if leaving school at 17:30 isn’t viable. I am meeting with the HOY on Wednesday so I’ll try to see her point of view as well on the matter.

OP posts:
BeverleyBrooks · 15/11/2026 21:23

So has your DD actually been given any detentions, or is she anecdotally reporting things from other students?
You can’t go into a meeting with the HoY to discuss detentions that have been given to other students, you can only discuss your own child’s issues.

I think detentions for lateness are not uncommon in sixth forms.

My DD used to get detentions for lateness (she would leave home at the very last minute, and the traffic on her route was often terrible). I couldn’t actually tell you the specifics of how many minutes late got what length of detention, as I left it to her to deal with - in my opinion it was up to her to get herself there on time, so she had to suffer the consequences. I did get involved later on when she was struggling in one of her subjects, but things like lateness, homework, detentions - that was for her to deal with.
How will they manage at university if we micromanage everything?

But ultimately if she’s really not happy she should change schools if she can, but I think she needs to make this decision and contact the other sixth forms herself.