Please or to access all these features

Higher education

Talk to other parents whose children are preparing for university on our Higher Education forum.

Are we entering an era of students mainly picking a local uni and commuting?

246 replies

mids2019 · 13/09/2026 09:04

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2026/sep/13/rise-of-student-commuters-costs-living-at-home-or-in-halls

With the expense of student loans and general cost of living pressures coupled with exponentially increasing IT impact are we now going into be in a position of students maybe by default choosing a local university.

My concern would be maybe more academic kids from poorer backgrounds maybe going for a local option rather than going for maybe a better HEI which is more distant. Obviously Oxbridge may offer cheap accommodation but the students going there are from predominantly middle class backgrounds with parents I would hazard a guess maybe would be able to support their children anyway.. I think the problem will be with other Russell group institutions including London unis, Durham, Bristol, Edinburgh etx. where there may be some distance to travel.

Is this commuting student model really a good thing?

Rise of the student commuters: weighing the costs of living at home or in halls

Changing social trends and creative timetables are making it more likely for students to stay at home while they study. Is campus life on the way out?

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2026/sep/13/rise-of-student-commuters-costs-living-at-home-or-in-halls

OP posts:
Babybirdmum · 14/09/2026 19:44

I only lived in for the first year and had to move home 2nd and 3rd because my parents were classed as high earners so I didn’t get the bursary but they couldn’t afford to pay for me in reality due to their own bills.

Badbadbunny · 14/09/2026 19:47

Crikeyalmighty · 14/09/2026 17:48

My son in London was at uni in that period - ended up giving up in year 2 , and going back into a job ( he went at 21 and luckily had a career to fall back on) it was not only all the covid issues, no seeing anyone, no seminars, no social scene but also 3 months previous of lecturers on strike - and they were all paying for the privilege - I honestly think those at uni in 2020 or 2021 should get their fees for them cancelled off - they were paying for what wasn’t delivered

Edited

I agree. The 2000 intake was also lied to as they were told by the Unis that it would be "blended learning", i.e. a mix of face to face and online but in reality most was online only, and the Uni (certainly our son's) knew it was all going to be online because they told their staff that, so most of the staff had no intention of attending the Uni at all for the 20/21 academic year and planned for everything to be online, but students were fed a different tale. Obviously except for a small number of courses that needed face to face, such as some lab/workshop work and other "hands on" things, but certainly not for those whose courses were mostly lecture based. Funny how the Unis changed their websites the day after applications were finalised/confirmed to change it from "blended learning" to "mostly online" - it's as if they were worried that students would decide not to attend and they'd lose their campus accommodation monies and have lots of empty places on courses when students deferred! The fees should definitely be waived for 20/21 at the very least.

Changeisstillpossible · 14/09/2026 19:52

Very common where I grew up, even 40 years ago. I think a third of my year group commuted.

Going away for university just wasn't considered in my family. My husband and his siblings also went locally.

CreativeGreen · 14/09/2026 20:44

I think some universities did handle 2020/21 poorly (which is I assume what people on here mean when they refer to 2000 intake?). I would note that where in-person teaching was offered, attendance was appalling, though, and students started asking (and have not stopped asking) for everything to be available online for if and when they didn’t feel like coming in - it’s been a damaging and depressing cycle

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 14/09/2026 21:19

@Walses DD is zone 1. Doesn’t seem unfashionable to me.

Moreholidaysthanjudithchalmers · 15/09/2026 02:17

It’s very understandable given accommodation costs. If you are on min English loan it won’t touch accommodation costs at most universities.
The whole model of paying for accommodation for when they aren’t there.
Yr 1 we paid 40 weeks. Private halls often want 51 weeks. When I went to uni you only paid term time only and moved out in holidays. Yr2 in private I paid full year rent. She was off 4 months over summer, £2800 just on unnecessary accommodation.
Plus low contact hours and ability to watch lectures online often means people question what are they paying accommodation for.
Different demographics going to uni now. More students who are ND and may prefer to stay home for support.
Some cultures prefer female students especially to live at home or are anti loans and only affordable way no loan is to stay home.
ULAN - Preston has lots of accommodation now. One of its marketing tools is how affordable its accommodation is.

estrogone · 15/09/2026 03:28

mids2019 · 13/09/2026 09:04

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2026/sep/13/rise-of-student-commuters-costs-living-at-home-or-in-halls

With the expense of student loans and general cost of living pressures coupled with exponentially increasing IT impact are we now going into be in a position of students maybe by default choosing a local university.

My concern would be maybe more academic kids from poorer backgrounds maybe going for a local option rather than going for maybe a better HEI which is more distant. Obviously Oxbridge may offer cheap accommodation but the students going there are from predominantly middle class backgrounds with parents I would hazard a guess maybe would be able to support their children anyway.. I think the problem will be with other Russell group institutions including London unis, Durham, Bristol, Edinburgh etx. where there may be some distance to travel.

Is this commuting student model really a good thing?

Its very normal and works well here (Australia). Living in halls is the exception not the norm.

Assuming you live in commutable distance to a reasonable size city you should not be disadvantaged.

Elbowpatch · 15/09/2026 05:29

PocketSand · 14/09/2026 17:11

@bababamamayeah you just have to agree for your skills to be used to develop weapons to kill someone - could be a baddie, could be a civilian or a child. DS2 views these disdain. Imagine what an awful place the world would be if we all could be bought.

Imagine what an awful place the world would be if tyrants could do as they wished. Unchecked.

Sesma · 15/09/2026 06:26

estrogone · 15/09/2026 03:28

Its very normal and works well here (Australia). Living in halls is the exception not the norm.

Assuming you live in commutable distance to a reasonable size city you should not be disadvantaged.

A lot of us don't live near these university cities.

mids2019 · 15/09/2026 07:36

Is it going to become a middle class luxury actually travelling some distance and living at a university?.A right of passage that will to some extent be a class defining factor?

as said before Oxbridge will be fine with their subsidised accommodation and the fact there are a wide range of bursaries coupled with the fact going into debt for an Oxbridge degree probably makes sense. For the the other 95% of students though an RG option (non local) is going to be a big decision financially.

I think one outcome of this trend is going to be the introduction of US style 'college funds ' parents save though not as fomalised. Model class.parents will want their children to experience university in the same way as they did and are going to be willing to put money aside for this especially if they don't have private school fees any more. Does this mean on average a slightly less diverse campus in future.....very possibly.

OP posts:
NoTimeForThisShit · 15/09/2026 08:18

Walses · 14/09/2026 19:30

I'd prefer our dcs to go away to uni as the social experience will be better, and it's good for them to have that independence and shared living with other young people. However, we're very fortunate to have excellent universities within walking distance as we're in London (zone 2, not a commuter suburb). The prospect of much lower living costs, and some of the best universities in the world for certain subjects, will be hard to ignore.

Inner cities are rather unfashionable places to live now for families (colleagues looked at us like we had two heads when we said we'd be raising our dcs here rather than a naice zone 5 suburb) so it will be interesting to see if better access to higher ed (and early career jobs) would make them more popular for families of teens and young adults. I have friends who proudly showed off the big detached house they could afford by moving out of the centre but now their teenage son is quite envious of the short commutes we have.

Jesus, you totally missed the point (and the tone!) of this thread🙄
We all are very happy for you being able to afford house in Zone 2 in london, well done you👏🏻

ExquisitelyDecorating · 15/09/2026 08:40

PocketSand · 14/09/2026 17:11

@bababamamayeah you just have to agree for your skills to be used to develop weapons to kill someone - could be a baddie, could be a civilian or a child. DS2 views these disdain. Imagine what an awful place the world would be if we all could be bought.

How strange. I'm very grateful to each and every member of our armed forces. I'd be ashamed to admit on a public forum I had raised a child with that attitude.

Divinedownload · 15/09/2026 08:53

mids2019 · 15/09/2026 07:36

Is it going to become a middle class luxury actually travelling some distance and living at a university?.A right of passage that will to some extent be a class defining factor?

as said before Oxbridge will be fine with their subsidised accommodation and the fact there are a wide range of bursaries coupled with the fact going into debt for an Oxbridge degree probably makes sense. For the the other 95% of students though an RG option (non local) is going to be a big decision financially.

I think one outcome of this trend is going to be the introduction of US style 'college funds ' parents save though not as fomalised. Model class.parents will want their children to experience university in the same way as they did and are going to be willing to put money aside for this especially if they don't have private school fees any more. Does this mean on average a slightly less diverse campus in future.....very possibly.

Travelling away to uni has always been fairly middle class though? Well, certainly in my world. All my middle class friends went away to uni. My working class friends stayed at home and didn’t go to uni at all. One of them did a nursing degree at our local one, and that was it out of my peers.

My family is working class. I did gain my degree after kids in my early 30s, but it was vocational. We have told our 16 year old he can go away for uni if he wants too, but he isn’t interested. He said he can go to uni here (Cov, Bham, Warwick depending on results).

He doesn’t want to leave his GF, friends, sports teams etc. He is always out, he has a part time job he fits around current studies. So, that’s his choice. I won’t keep asking lol 😂. I wouldn’t really be able to change his mind anyway, he has a lot of agency.

JasmineTea11 · 15/09/2026 08:56

The bigger relevant trend is students doing degrees and apprenticeships at their local further education colleges. Maybe I'm biased as I used to work in this sector, but i believe the quality of the teaching, facilities and support is equal to many universities (including the supposed Russell group one I attended!)
Not all students want to leave their home town for various reasons, it's not just financial. This is where the most sustainable (and equitable) growth is in the post 18 education sector, IMO.

MummyOre · 15/09/2026 09:05

We live in London.

My older dc went away to uni.
5 years ago, my youngest dd stayed at home and commuted to her uni 3 days a week.

The entire uni experience has changed.

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 15/09/2026 09:31

@JasmineTea11 There are no degrees at colleges of FE. Degree apprenticeships are like hens teeth. Hardly any dc get them and they are substantially more competitive than getting into some subjects at Oxbridge. They have hardly changed any landscape.

Benvenuto · 15/09/2026 09:48

Badbadbunny · 14/09/2026 11:21

Public transport would need to be A LOT better outside of the major cities. Our "local" university is only 20 minutes away by car, but 1.5 hours by bus involving 2 changes! I personally think 90 minutes each way is too long, even worse that there's no evening bus service on our route at our side of the city. The bus between the Uni itself and the city centre is brilliant, literally every 5 minutes, starts early, finishes late, but it's the routes out of the city at the opposite end that are diabolical, i.e. every 2 hours on Sunday, no evening services after 7pm etc - so not really suitable for commuting to the Uni unless you're living in the city centre or that side of the city. They just assume all the students live in the city centre student accommodation and have planned the bus service accordingly. Can't take a car because students are prohibited from any kind of parking permit unless disabled or a carer, so they'd have to pay public parking fees on campus which are ruinously expensive for anything longer than short stay.

Agree - you would need rail. If you live near an Intercity station or a station with frequent local services, then there’s a good chance you have access to enough universities to find one that matches your grades (although there will be exceptions to this in parts of the country). Buses can’t provide this range but they can link people to their closest local station or uni. Cycle routes can help in the same way.

The problem is that none of these things are popular things to spend money on.

Driving might be an option for an individual, but given that city centre unis especially are likely to be in areas with existing congestion problems, on a large scale shifting students from being residents to driving is going to create / exacerbate transport problems.

WearyAuldWumman · 15/09/2026 10:01

albalass · 14/09/2026 14:10

I'm from Glasgow and me and the vast majority of my school friends stayed at home and went to a uni in Glasgow in the late 90s. Going elsewhere wasn't even considered by us if you got into one of the Glasgow Unis as financially it made no sense. I think I'm right in saying that over half of the undergraduates at Glasgow uni lived at home. Three decades on and my cousins' children are all following the same path - none have moved to go to uni. But where I live now (English city) it seems the majority don't go to the local unis (Russell Group and a post-92).

Edited

I went to Glasgow in the late '70s. Certainly at that time, the vast majority of students there came from Glasgow and Strathclyde.

Badbadbunny · 15/09/2026 10:08

JasmineTea11 · 15/09/2026 08:56

The bigger relevant trend is students doing degrees and apprenticeships at their local further education colleges. Maybe I'm biased as I used to work in this sector, but i believe the quality of the teaching, facilities and support is equal to many universities (including the supposed Russell group one I attended!)
Not all students want to leave their home town for various reasons, it's not just financial. This is where the most sustainable (and equitable) growth is in the post 18 education sector, IMO.

Sadly, our city used to have two "adult education" colleges that offered a wide range of courses including part time O and A levels, diplomas, and professional qualifications. Lots of younger people did courses there too, they did full time for 16-18 and many of those also did "extras" in evening classes (O and A levels mostly). One closed down and the other converted itself entirely to the 16-18 age group, both in the early 00s when the adult education budgets were slashed. They both stopped doing professional qualifications (one had an excellent business school which just shut down!) and stopped offering any part time evening classes nor any other adult education classes. In the next nearest city we had a Poly that did likewise, but that converted itself into a Uni and now does nothing but degree courses.

Got to hope the sense prevails and places like that start to open up again. Maybe some of the universities that are struggling (some of the ex-polys) could re-convert back into Polys or colleges and start offering a wider range of courses again.

Badbadbunny · 15/09/2026 10:11

Benvenuto · 15/09/2026 09:48

Agree - you would need rail. If you live near an Intercity station or a station with frequent local services, then there’s a good chance you have access to enough universities to find one that matches your grades (although there will be exceptions to this in parts of the country). Buses can’t provide this range but they can link people to their closest local station or uni. Cycle routes can help in the same way.

The problem is that none of these things are popular things to spend money on.

Driving might be an option for an individual, but given that city centre unis especially are likely to be in areas with existing congestion problems, on a large scale shifting students from being residents to driving is going to create / exacerbate transport problems.

Problem with our city Uni is that it's a campus a few miles out of town, without a railway station. The city railway station isn't actually close to the city bus station, so that's another problem for people who may think of commuting by train, i.e. a long walk from one end of the city centre to the other. But in our case, it's irrelevant anyway because we don't live anywhere near a railway station, even though the main line is literally at the bottom of our garden and our village used to have a station until it was closed down in the 70s!

CuriousKangaroo · 15/09/2026 10:20

Yes, and I think it is very sad. Moving away for uni was brilliant for me and my fellow students. It’s a great way to soft launch into life - having to learn to budget, shop, cook, do your laundry, balance your time, do things only uni life can offer, stay out late without a parent worrying or breathing down your neck, making mistakes and learning from them. Yes you can do some of those things living at home, but it’s the immersion that really helps.

My DD is 8, and we have set up a specific savings account specifically to allow her to be able to move out for uni so she can choose the best place for her and the best course, over and above having to stay close and live at home for financial reasons. I know not everyone can do that, but I am just illustrating how important DH and I think moving out for uni is.

mids2019 · 15/09/2026 10:29

CuriousKangaroo · 15/09/2026 10:20

Yes, and I think it is very sad. Moving away for uni was brilliant for me and my fellow students. It’s a great way to soft launch into life - having to learn to budget, shop, cook, do your laundry, balance your time, do things only uni life can offer, stay out late without a parent worrying or breathing down your neck, making mistakes and learning from them. Yes you can do some of those things living at home, but it’s the immersion that really helps.

My DD is 8, and we have set up a specific savings account specifically to allow her to be able to move out for uni so she can choose the best place for her and the best course, over and above having to stay close and live at home for financial reasons. I know not everyone can do that, but I am just illustrating how important DH and I think moving out for uni is.

I don't think you are the only one with this attitude and there is a certain inevitability about parental saving IMHO.

OP posts:
Rejoinedforthis · 15/09/2026 10:29

I went to my local uni, back in 2003. My parents couldn’t afford to support me at all, and I was terrified of the debt (and it was obviously a fraction of what it was back then!) I got very good A levels and could have gone to a more prestigious uni, the one I went to was an ex-poly and initially I did feel a bit self-conscious saying where I’d gone…despite still having needed decent grades to do the course I did, regardless of it being an ex-poly!

That being said - I had a seriously wonderful time. The best three years ever. I wasn’t worrying about debt, I had a couple of part time jobs, I worked hard but played harder 😂 and I really came out of my shell. I’d been bullied through school but really found my tribe at uni, was always out at gigs and parties and had loads of friends. I was so much more confident when I finished compared to how I went in, it was night and day. That is what has helped me in life, it’s not the degree I got, it’s the confidence and self-worth I developed while I was there, regardless of the fact I lived at home. I was barely at home to be fair 😂 and when I was my parents expected me to pitch in and do my own washing etc. I can hear my dad now “this isn’t a guest house/oh hello stranger sorry I’ve forgotten your name/sorry we’ve rented out your room etc etc 😂”. I also paid off my loan relatively quickly as it was just fees and books.

I’m hoping we would be able to support DD if she wants to go to uni (she’s 4 though so god knows, the robots could be in charge by then 😂😬) but I know it’ll still be fine even if she doesn’t do the full “uni experience” in another city.

estrogone · 15/09/2026 10:49

Sesma · 15/09/2026 06:26

A lot of us don't live near these university cities.

We probably have longer commutes - its just the norm

Badbadbunny · 15/09/2026 10:56

Another aspect if people stop "moving away" to Uni is the impact on the local economy - i.e. less trade for the shops/eateries etc if students aren't living in the city, what happens to all the huge student accommodation blocks that aren't set up for "normal/family" living, i.e. with communal kitchens etc? Unfortunately lots of Uni cities, especially smaller ones, have been designed around the Uni over the past 2/3 decades and if students stop living there, it will have a devastating effect.