If someone already has an iPhone would they also appreciate the new iPod nano?

[said]

Desperately flailing around for gift ideas. It's the iPhone pre the new one if that matters.

Thanks

I doubt it. Unless they go jogging or something and might want to use something small for music only.

No, I don't think they would.

Do they just duplicate each other too much?

DH would. The new Nano has a video function which would be useful if the person you were buying for particularly wants this. Its been all I can do to stop DH buying one as he is a bit of a gadget freak at the best of times and wants to see how it works in conjunction with our iMac to make small videos of the dcs and the like.

Yes, an iPhone is an iPod as well as a phone, so they would be getting nothing new, just a dinky iPod.

iTunes vouchers?

ooh, I didn't know new nanos did video. That makes a small difference, but I would imagine the person in question would be getting new iphone when they can so probably limited benefit.

Well, yes the video bit appeals as he's been saying the iPhone camera is a bit shit. Maybe I should bagsy the nano for me? It smells of an "I'm all ideaed out" gift doesn't it?

No, he won't be getting new iPhone (got this one on very cheap contract through O2 contacts - taps nose)

None in question is here

Ha! Nano not None

If he thinks the iphone camera is a bit shit, then i really can't imaging a nano camera would be any better. I have the new iphone and would still say the camera is a bit shit.

Get him a new camera i just got one of these it's smaller than the iphone!

Ah, thank you. Next question/thread would be recommend a camera for me . That's one is too dear but will now investigate others.

I have an iphone and I would think it odd getting a nano, seeing as the ipod holds music anyway