Please or to access all these features

Further education

You'll find discussions about A Levels and universities on our Further Education forum.

Would a vocational course still be suitable for someone who doesn't struggle with school?

17 replies

RenegadeKeeblerElf · 21/10/2026 07:43

DD is in Y11, autistic but generally does very well with academic subjects and only really struggles with things like noisy classrooms, group work where others aren't pulling their weight, or not fully understanding expectations and needing to try and figure out what is being asked. She does also get stressed around revision time as she doesn't revise well - she doesn't really need to revise as she does well without it, but she knows she 'should' and therefore gets stressed that she isn't. Overall though she does well at school, and is predicted mostly 7s , with the potential for 8s and 9s if she was to really work hard.

She is therefore very capable of doing the traditional A levels and uni route, but her passion is making things. She loves crafting and always has a project on the go - she just sees the finished design in her head and knows how to get there. She also loves theatre so her aim is a degree in theatre production, probably specialising in props and set design/build. Her plan had been to go to our local (excellent) college and do two academic A levels that really interest her, plus Textiles (her main crafting interest at the moment is customising clothes/crochet/sewing). But the school have been encouraging them to look at alternative options (the school as a whole has quite a challenging demographic and academic A levels certainly won't be suitable for all or even most).

We have now found a course at another college a little further away that she is interested in but I don't have much experience of vocational courses and want to understand more about it and whether it will be a good fit for her. Its a Level 3 extended diploma in Performance and Production Arts (it seems to focus on technical theatre rather than performance but she does enjoy performing too) - does anyone know anything about this? She likes the idea of being more practical and less pressure to write essays but I want to be sure it isn't closing doors for the future if she changes her mind about her career plans.

OP posts:
SoftIce · 21/10/2026 08:42

How about mathematics (if she is good) or English, drama or D&T, and textiles. That way she could get her practical fix and since (art) textiles is finished by the time exams come around, she would only have to revise for exams in two subjects. I think A-levels would be good to have as a backup in case a career in theatre arts does not work out.

Another possibility is to focus completely on the vocational qualification for a year. At the end of the first year she can still decide if she wants to continue with it or exit with a foundation diploma and switch to A-levels. However, an important caveat here is that if she is considering A-level mathematics, a year without mathematics would mean that colleges won't accept her on the course, so you would have to keep up the maths in some demonstratable way. I think other subjects would be fine though.

All routes would be fine for a degree in theatre arts (e.g. CSSD).

RenegadeKeeblerElf · 21/10/2026 13:46

A level maths isn't really something she is thinking about so that isn't an issue, she was looking at psychology and classical civilisations alongside the textiles. I like the idea that she can get the foundation diploma after a year then switch to A levels if she wants, that's an interesting idea to bear in mind. I just don't want her bored or in a class with kids who aren't motivated to work hard.

OP posts:
ChilliPotato · 21/10/2026 13:59

I wouldn't assume that the students doing vocational courses aren't motivated.

https://www.arts.ac.uk/subjects/textiles-and-materials/undergraduate/ba-hons-fashion-textiles-print-lcf#application-process

If you think she might want to take her interest further, it would be worth looking at entry requirements for suitable courses post A levels eg this one at the LCF (which is a brilliant place!)

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 21/10/2026 17:06

There is a LOT of essay writing on vocational L3 Extended Diplomas.

There aren't exams, but the assignments are very written work heavy.

My DD is doing one of these courses at the moment, her two best friends got straight 8s and 9s at GCSE.

In my experience you get a few who are very dedicated, lots who are a bit flaky and those you never see much of after enrolment. Mine is endlessly frustrated with slow pace, lack of seriousness and the amount of tick box busy work involved. Says if it wasn't for being severely SEN and therefore unsuited, she wishes she was doing A Levels.

My personal advice would be, do 3 academic A levels, then do either an Art Foundation (these are free) or a degree.

B0D · 21/10/2026 18:40

My DD was torn between creative arts and academics after GCSE. She had completed at BTEC in art and design alongside all the GCSEs. In the end she was went with A levels and a RG uni. Rationale it would be easier to start art foundation later on than do academic studies outside of the established trajectory,

TheeNotoriousPIG · 21/10/2026 18:42

Would a vocational course still be suitable for someone who doesn't struggle with school?
In short, yes!

I was academically able. I preferred vocational college to A-Levels (ugh!), and there were quite a few stereotypically academic students in my year. Most people went on to university afterwards, but that college was quite geared towards it, as it had a University Centre on site.

I now work for a vocational college. They might be doing things like agriculture, forestry and countryside, but most of them aren't your classic academic 'failures'. A lot of them prefer college to school. We have a few autistic students, some who have behaviour issues/avoidance issues with being in a classroom environment, but love the practical elements. Quite a few do go on to university, some get jobs in the local area, while others go working abroad for the experience.

RenegadeKeeblerElf · 23/10/2026 12:18

Thanks all, some really helpful replies here. We're going to go to the open evening and see what she thinks, but I am feeling more reassured that if she does choose this option it won't necessarily close too many doors for her.

OP posts:
Needanadultgapyear · 08/11/2026 08:46

My DD would have been a classic A-level student, she got all 8 and 9s at GCSE, but she was deeply unhappy at school and she loved theatre.
The group on her extended diploma in performing arts were some of the most motivated people I have meet.

She left with a triple D star equivalent to three A star at A-level had an offer from Italia Conti.
The deputy head at her school told her she was ruining her life by doing the extended diploma. But she is now self employed teaching and auditioning, she has work abroad and was in the room the other week for a major west end role ( just being in the room is a massive achievement).
The extended diploma was the best route for her.

RenegadeKeeblerElf · 08/11/2026 12:54

Needanadultgapyear · 08/11/2026 08:46

My DD would have been a classic A-level student, she got all 8 and 9s at GCSE, but she was deeply unhappy at school and she loved theatre.
The group on her extended diploma in performing arts were some of the most motivated people I have meet.

She left with a triple D star equivalent to three A star at A-level had an offer from Italia Conti.
The deputy head at her school told her she was ruining her life by doing the extended diploma. But she is now self employed teaching and auditioning, she has work abroad and was in the room the other week for a major west end role ( just being in the room is a massive achievement).
The extended diploma was the best route for her.

Thanks, that's incredibly helpful, and your daughter sounds amazing! Out of curiosity, did she end up going to drama school? My other daughter is thinking about applying for the cert HE at Italia Conti (and a few others) but while she is passionate about performing she also really struggled with formal education and is not sure if she wants to go back into that kind of environment.

OP posts:
Needanadultgapyear · 08/11/2026 13:49

DD did the degree program at Conti she graduated last year is making a living teaching after school dance, singing lessons, stagecoach at weekends and stagecoach holiday clubs.

She is auditioning as well and has been in the room for some pretty great roles ( just getting in the room is a huge achievement and many shows you are seen 3-5 times before you are cast).
She was super happy at Conti and made great friends there.

Tickingcrocodile · 08/11/2026 13:59

My DC is a bit younger but similar in that she is autistic and performjng arts is her special interest. I have looked into this quite a lot. My daughter is also academically capable and I come from a background where A-levels were the only route and vocational qualifications were "lesser". However, I've decided that if she wants to pursue the performing arts qualification I won't push her into other things. Autistic students in particular are more likely to do well in something they are specifically interested in.

Check out the university entrance requirements for courses directly related to performance and production but also related degrees. Eg I found some media, English joint honours degree courses that she could still be accepted onto without A levels. They might not be at the more traditional redbrick universities but I don't think that has the same level of importance these days.

SandrenaIsMyBloodType · 08/11/2026 14:01

On the flip side, both my AuDHD daughters aced school at Yrs 7-11. They both got all 9s and one 8 at GCSE. They were at different schools from each other but the teachers at both schools said that they could take anything they wanted for A level and that they were both Oxbridge candidates.

That’s not how it worked out for either of them. 6th Form was very different and A levels required quite a different skill set to GCSE. Revision, which my DDs hadn’t needed much of for GCSEs was absolutely necessary for A levels. They both got respectable A levels in the end (but not all As and A*s) but it was not a happy time and their university choices were certainly not what had been predicted in year 11.

DD1 went on to get the equivalent of a first from a Dutch university and DD2 is still at uni (also in the Netherlands). They learned a lot about their learning style from the ups and downs of A levels and have found their way, but please don’t assume that a neurodivergent young women who found GCSE easy will necessarily breeze through the demands of A levels. They are more different than you expect.

Failedcrunchymum · 09/11/2026 09:38

It actually never crossed my mind that vocational courses are viewed this way. I just see them as an option for students who like a hands-on, coursework style of learning, with practical, industry focused experience. I was a middling student at school in the 90's, struggled with Maths, excelled at languages, but didn't know what to do next, so chose A-levels, and my classes were made up of students who had a university goal and those who didn't have a clue what to do next. I then switched to a vocational course later once I figured out what I was interested in.

Mrcollinswave · 10/11/2026 06:28

I think if she's academic then A levels is always a good back up plan. Then go on and do what she loves and sounds very good at! At her age she's got lots of time to figure out what she wants.
while I was chatting to the young RAC patrol man who was fixing my car, I discovered he actually had a degree in biochemistry and had been thinking of going to medical school but decided against it as he absolutely loves working with his hands and was very happy in his job. He certainly had a good bedside manner!

RenegadeKeeblerElf · 12/11/2026 10:05

I think I'm realising that while she is intelligent, articulate, good vocabulary, expresses herself very easily verbally and in writing, has had a reading age of 15+ since the age of about 11, enjoys learning, gets good grades etc, that doesn't necessarily translate to being suitable for a more academic pathway as she gets older - she really struggles with organisation, revision, studying, and finds exam season extremely stressful and dysregulating. She also loves making and creating things, has a real gift for coming up with an idea and just knowing how to realise it, and really thrives in that kind of environment.

I hadn't considered other pathways as I just don't have experience of them - I am not at all creative or practical and thrive in academia (if I could afford it I'd give up work and just do degree after degree in subjects that interest me!), but the more I look into and think about it, the more I realise that this is probably the right pathway for her. I just wish I'd been more aware of other options when her older sister was at the same stage.

OP posts:
teafor1 · 12/11/2026 18:48

Take a look at my thread about regretting not doing A levels. We are two years ahead of you! My daughter could have done A levels but I still don’t think it was the right thing for her. My daughter isn’t following the smoothest path but hopefully she’ll find her way and have two qualifications out of it. I think they do better when they can engage in what they are doing so if this is what your daughter wants then at this moment it’s probably the right thing to do.

BertieBotts · 12/11/2026 19:05

Absolutely, why not?

I was a top set student for GCSEs but went on to do BTEC ND in graphic design because I was excited by the sound of that course and not so much by A Levels.

I did end up struggling with the workload and degree of independent organisation/time management required, to the point that I actually failed the course. This was likely due to at the time undiagnosed ADHD, it was very classic, but in 2003 ADHD meant hyperactive, and I was not. So if your DD has executive functioning difficulties, then it might be she needs more support with this aspect of the course, as I found it a huge jump from school. But I would hope that colleges are more clued up to SEN like this these days.

Most of the time courses like this will act as a university entrance qualification as well, so there's no reason she'll miss out on anything later if she decides to go to university later on. I was accepted as a mature student actually in 2010, despite having failed this course.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread