Please or to access all these features

Food/recipes

For related content, visit our food content hub.

Chicken pie using Greek yoghurt instead or cream

20 replies

Anneleesa · 14/11/2026 10:36

I have Greek yoghurt to use up. I know I can’t make a chicken pie with Greek yoghurt and then bake it, because the yogurt will split. So my plan is to make the pie filling thickened with a little cornflour but at this stage minus the yoghurt, then bake the filling with a regular lid on the dish whilst I bake the pie lid separately on a baking sheet.

Then I will remove the pie dish a little early so it can come off the simmer, then stir in the yoghurt at the end and balance the now-cooked pie lid on top.

My family like the puff pastry lid to be completely puffed and not at all soggy so I often cook the lid this way.

Can anyone critique my recipe and what suggestions might anyone have for not making the pie too sour?

OP posts:
Ksjwks · 14/11/2026 10:40

Honestly I wouldn't use yogurt at all. I'd make a thinnish bechamel with milk and/or stock (and add maybe something like leeks or mushrooms) to add to the chicken. Whatever you do with yogurt it will still taste strongly of yogurt and will be weird in a chicken pie.

Boopsi · 14/11/2026 10:43

Honestly, I would just use the Greek yoghurt for something else. It will be too sour in a pie and the texture is totally different.

If helpful, I like this recipe which uses Greek yoghurt: sallysbakingaddiction.com/lemon-berry-yogurt-cake/#tasty-recipes-80573

ExOptimist · 14/11/2026 10:47

It seems a right faff just in order to use up some yoghurt and probably wouldn't taste right. Make your pie filling the normal way and use the yoghurt for something else, even on its own with some fruit for pudding after the pie.

icecreamscreams · 14/11/2026 11:29

Ksjwks · 14/11/2026 10:40

Honestly I wouldn't use yogurt at all. I'd make a thinnish bechamel with milk and/or stock (and add maybe something like leeks or mushrooms) to add to the chicken. Whatever you do with yogurt it will still taste strongly of yogurt and will be weird in a chicken pie.

Same. Crème fraiche works but I can’t see that yoghurt will

EnterCaroline · 14/11/2026 11:31

Agree with pps. I'd make a veloute instead. If you've got cucumber, garlic and crisps, make tzatziki and have a nice afternoon snack.

Truinio · 14/11/2026 11:35

I’ve never made chicken pie with cream anyway. Always use a bechamel. Just eat the yoghurt with some honey and nuts or something if it needs using up.

Ilovefoodandwine · 14/11/2026 11:38

Nope, don't do it... just thicken with cornflour if needed

HobgoblinNorFoulFiend · 14/11/2026 11:47

Use the yoghurt to make flatbreads to eat with the chicken or something else. Or make some sort of curry sauce for the chicken.

Bjorkdidit · 14/11/2026 11:49

I do use it as a catch all substitute for sour cream and cream in some circumstances but unless your Greek yogurt is already 2 or 3 weeks out of date, there's no rush to use it up anyway. But worth a shot if its full fat and you're OK with it not tasting exactly like it would with cream.

Cyclistmumgrandma · 14/11/2026 12:38

How about a chicken stroganoff??

TallagallaPenguin · 14/11/2026 12:53

I don’t think yoghurt goes in pie.

Cant you all have it as breakfast or a dessert with honey and nuts / granola / compote / fresh fruit? That uses up a lot all at once.

I “made” chocolate yoghurt the other day by melting some choc and stirring into Greek yog. It was pretty nice!

Autumnallaround · 14/11/2026 13:00

Agree with PP. I always make a basic white sauce for chicken pie. Then deepen the flavour with seasoning and white wine.

FluWorldOrder · 14/11/2026 13:01

I use Greek yoghurt to make cheese scones. 1c yoghurt, 1.5c flour, 3t. baking powder, salt. Combine and roll into a log. Slice scones and sprinkle with cheese. They only need about 12 or so minutes in the oven at 180C. Probably not as nice as scones made with butter but they’re still tasty! Best served hot with butter.

BarbaraVineFan · 14/11/2026 13:11

You could use it in a marinade and make tandoori chicken or similar

Jongleuse594 · 14/11/2026 13:42

I use Greek yogurt with curry and cumin to create an amazing chicken dish from a Dorling Kindersley book.

ThatHeartyHelper · 14/11/2026 14:07

I use left over Greek yogurt in brown soda bread/white bread/scones/waffles/pancakes, bakes in general. Okay in some dips and dressings too.

PerfectPaula · 17/11/2026 04:41

There are thousands of recipes that use greek yoghurt. Why ruin a perfectly good chicken pie by adding something that isn't designed to be in there? Especially when it complicates the cooking of it. Just make something else. Lots of chicken curries or kebabs will use yoghurt.

WibbleWob · 17/11/2026 21:30

I use it instead of crème fraiche in Jamie Oliver’s chicken and leak pie (legacy of Covid when scrabbling for ingredients.) I struggle to taste the difference, but the recipe only uses a tablespoon as I recall so not much help in using up the yoghurt!

DaniEatsBham · 18/11/2026 05:16

Your plan sounds workable to me, and baking the lid separately is the clever bit — it should stay crisp that way. The main risk is the yoghurt splitting or making the filling too sharp, so I'd keep it off the heat altogether. Let the yoghurt come to room temperature, take the filling off the heat, then stir it in a spoonful at a time and taste as you go. Full-fat will hold up better than low-fat, and a tiny pinch of sugar with plenty of black pepper helps balance the tang without making it sweet. Don't let it bubble again once it's in — just warm it through gently, pop the lid on top and serve straight away. Hope it turns out well!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page