Please or to access all these features

Films

Ebenezer

52 replies

Imdunfer · 13/11/2026 17:59

Cracking good Scrooge adaptation, some of Depp's best acting ever, I think. Rupert Grint is finally learning to act as well.

It's a very traditional presentation set in the right year with good use of CGI not overplayed and pretty faithful to the book.

Lovely to see Styal Mill featuring so heavily in the locations.

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 08:58

BirdLandedonmyHead · 15/11/2026 08:50

Would ypu recommend for gcse revision.

(DDs school actually showed them the Muppets one last year as the "best" representation.)

I think so, yes, just tell them that the goose was given to the Cratchetts not the nephew and that Bob's promotion wasn't quite as good as in the film.

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 08:58

Tomatocutwithazigzagedge · 15/11/2026 08:56

Saw it last night and thoroughly enjoyed it.

I still think Blackadders Christmas Carol is the best though! 😂😂😂

Oh I forgot that one! Yes, brilliant, as is all Blackadder.

OP posts:
HRTtoHeart · 15/11/2026 09:02

Lomonald · 15/11/2026 08:53

Have you not seen/read. A Christmas carol ? his back story is one of the main points of the story.

I have read the book and nobody murders Fezziwig!

Making beggars murder Fezziwig so that Scrooge has justification for hating the poor misses the whole damned point!

Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 09:05

IndieRocknRoll · 15/11/2026 08:51

Would I be ok to take an 11 year old do you think? He’s not particularly sensitive. I’ve just seen that a PP thinks it should be a 15 🤔

I think an 11 year old would be fine.

There's absolutely no gore, no visible physical abuse. An alcoholic father only briefly shown shouting at him, no actual death scenes, though you hear Marley fall and see his body on the floor.

Graveyards in the dark, of course and earth being thrown onto a coffin in a grave. Realistic ghosts, meaning they are believable and not at all cartoonish.

I was surprised by the suggestion it should be 15, I think 12A was fine but I might be out of touch with today's 11 year olds. I perhaps wouldn't take a child prone to nightmares.

OP posts:
HRTtoHeart · 15/11/2026 09:07

Lomonald · 15/11/2026 08:53

Have you not seen/read. A Christmas carol ? his back story is one of the main points of the story.

I know it inside and out - I'm seeing it again at the Old Vic next month.

Scrooge doesn't have a "tragic backstory", he has a past with a series of decisions taking him further and further away from the young man he once was. That's why it's painful for old Scrooge to witness it.

He's not Bruce bloody Wayne watching the Joker kill his parents.

Having kind old Fezziwig give money to the poor and be brutally killed for it is an obscene corruption of a tale about humanity and redemption.

We aren't supposed to watch A Christmas Carol and think "yeah, totally justifiable reaction by Ebenezer under the circumstances."

countdowntonap · 15/11/2026 09:07

Sannabay · 15/11/2026 08:47

Fair answer lol.

I deffo want to see it thanks for the heads up.

Question. I've never read the book. Is it true that Jesus or church going is never mentioned in the novel. Just ghosts!

Save me the bother of reading it please. X

Still will always prefer singing mice and dishy MC btw.

There are some Biblical allusions in the text, but the focus is more on the secular aspects of Christmas than religious ones - although the final words are "God bless us, every one!"

Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 09:11

HRTtoHeart · 15/11/2026 09:02

I have read the book and nobody murders Fezziwig!

Making beggars murder Fezziwig so that Scrooge has justification for hating the poor misses the whole damned point!

I take your point about that scene being invented but I don't believe it alters the basic meaning of the book.

You sound as if you are being swayed by a dislike of Depp, to be honest.

OP posts:
HRTtoHeart · 15/11/2026 09:17

Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 09:11

I take your point about that scene being invented but I don't believe it alters the basic meaning of the book.

You sound as if you are being swayed by a dislike of Depp, to be honest.

I'm cynical about Depp, but I've no skin in the game.

I do really love ACC in all its many incarcerations (Muppets and the ballet being my favourites). I don't mind people playing around with it.

To fundamentally alter the text so Scrooge is reacting to trauma rather than a incremental drift from humanity to miser is to miss the whole point of the book.

Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 09:20

HRTtoHeart · 15/11/2026 09:07

I know it inside and out - I'm seeing it again at the Old Vic next month.

Scrooge doesn't have a "tragic backstory", he has a past with a series of decisions taking him further and further away from the young man he once was. That's why it's painful for old Scrooge to witness it.

He's not Bruce bloody Wayne watching the Joker kill his parents.

Having kind old Fezziwig give money to the poor and be brutally killed for it is an obscene corruption of a tale about humanity and redemption.

We aren't supposed to watch A Christmas Carol and think "yeah, totally justifiable reaction by Ebenezer under the circumstances."

I don't really care what we are "supposed" to do but I'm baffled by anyone who sees being abandoned in an 1800s boarding school by an alcoholic father and losing the only person who ever loved him or cared for him at a young age as not being a tragic back story.

But whatever, it's a very good film and far from the worst film for not being completely true to a book.

OP posts:
ThaneOfGlamis · 15/11/2026 09:22

I can't stand Depp these days, so don't think I will be watching, even though it looks good. We plan on watching pirates of the Caribbean tonight though, so I am clearly a raging hypocrite.

In any case, the muppets will always be my favourite. Michael Caine should have won an Oscar for that performance, he was robbed!

Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 09:22

HRTtoHeart · 15/11/2026 09:17

I'm cynical about Depp, but I've no skin in the game.

I do really love ACC in all its many incarcerations (Muppets and the ballet being my favourites). I don't mind people playing around with it.

To fundamentally alter the text so Scrooge is reacting to trauma rather than a incremental drift from humanity to miser is to miss the whole point of the book.

Have you actually seen the film or been put off it by things you've read?

To me, the incremental drift was clear in the film. It's interesting to hear other points of view though.

OP posts:
Sannabay · 15/11/2026 09:24

countdowntonap · 15/11/2026 09:07

There are some Biblical allusions in the text, but the focus is more on the secular aspects of Christmas than religious ones - although the final words are "God bless us, every one!"

Umm I see, not read the novel. Secular then.

Fezziwig is murdered in one adaption!!

Sannabay · 15/11/2026 09:29

Poor Fuzzy

Sannabay · 15/11/2026 09:35

ThaneOfGlamis · 15/11/2026 09:22

I can't stand Depp these days, so don't think I will be watching, even though it looks good. We plan on watching pirates of the Caribbean tonight though, so I am clearly a raging hypocrite.

In any case, the muppets will always be my favourite. Michael Caine should have won an Oscar for that performance, he was robbed!

JD wouldn't have been my pick. Can't understand that .

Pemba · 15/11/2026 09:47

I was considering seeing this, as I liked the trailers, and wanted something Christmassy - maybe to go in December. But DD showed me stuff about Johnny Depp online and what happened with Amber Heard, , and I was sad to see what a terrible man he's become (always was?). I suppose it's like a lot of stars in the entertainment industry - they're indulged and I suppose a lot of them are a bit unstable anyway with narcissistic traits - makes sense really.

I previously didn't want to know really because I always used to love him, ever since Edward Scissorhands. But now I don't want to give him any money so I won't be going. I might still watch it when it is included in streaming packages.

Plus I've seen some terrible reviews.

ShowOfHands · 15/11/2026 09:57

Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 09:05

I think an 11 year old would be fine.

There's absolutely no gore, no visible physical abuse. An alcoholic father only briefly shown shouting at him, no actual death scenes, though you hear Marley fall and see his body on the floor.

Graveyards in the dark, of course and earth being thrown onto a coffin in a grave. Realistic ghosts, meaning they are believable and not at all cartoonish.

I was surprised by the suggestion it should be 15, I think 12A was fine but I might be out of touch with today's 11 year olds. I perhaps wouldn't take a child prone to nightmares.

I'm a secondary school teacher. Many of my year 7 students would find it upsetting or difficult.

ShowOfHands · 15/11/2026 10:00

I get why it's 12A rather than 15 but I do think it very carefully gets as close to the line as possible. I took my 15yr old son and he's not sensitive but was surprised by some of the scenes.

Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 10:08

ShowOfHands · 15/11/2026 09:57

I'm a secondary school teacher. Many of my year 7 students would find it upsetting or difficult.

Good to have the professional view, thanks.

OP posts:
Sesquioxides · 15/11/2026 10:50

Knowing that Dickens was writing an allegory of Malthus’s work (Malthus was blaming the poor for their circs, to put it lightly), I hard disagree that he would have approved of beggars murdering Fezziwig. The usual plot point with Fezz added in film adaptations is that Scrooge collected a debt that sent him to the workhouse. However I feel the past was the weakest part of Scrooge’s character development in the book and didn’t visibly explain why he became quite so miserly because everything that might have explained his behaviour was not developed fully (sorry, Dickens). I can look past that one scene if the rest of the adaptation is good though. Looking forward to seeing it.

ChristmasStars · 15/11/2026 11:16

I saw it in 4D which was quite an experience!
I had read mixed reviews but I absolutely loved it. JD is amazing - I totally forgot it was him. With a couple of exceptions it's really close to the book, and given the number of changes in other adaptations I can live with that.
I did find it scary but it definitely fitted the Victorian Gothic ambiance. So well done.

Rainbow1901 · 15/11/2026 11:19

We are booked to see this next week. Old Biddies day - cheap tickets and a free tea/coffee plus biscuits too!! 😊Looking forward to it.

BeKhakiReader · 15/11/2026 19:02

Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 08:58

I think so, yes, just tell them that the goose was given to the Cratchetts not the nephew and that Bob's promotion wasn't quite as good as in the film.

I agree and would add the point another poster has made about Fezziwig being murdered. He’s not. There’s no such link between the poor and Scrooge, to justify any of his beliefs.

I saw it yesterday and thought it was excellent.

Abracadabra12345 · 16/11/2026 19:26

I saw it and loved it. My DH saw it and didn’t like the changes already alluded to but he’s a bit of a purist

RightOnTheEdge · 17/11/2026 15:34

I went to see it with my ds and dd on Sunday and we all enjoyed it.

I usually don't like it when they keep making remakes of old stories but I thought this one was really good.

I think 12a is the right age for it unless you have a very sensitive child. I don't think most secondary school kids would be scared.

tinyspiny · 17/11/2026 17:45

Went to see this today and thoroughly enjoyed it , probably the best CC I’ve seen after the Muppets , which is obviously the best one . I am not that bothered about them adding extra bits into the story as long as it stays reasonably true to the book which this does .

Swipe left for the next trending thread