Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Films
PinotPinot · 01/03/2026 18:12

I haven't seen it, but everything I've heard Amanda Seyfried (who I normally like) say about this film, is a bit....earnest, self important maybe? So I've been put off.

Maybe I'm being unfair to her because I've only really seen her in light things before. Is she doing a Matthew McConaughy with this maybe 🤔? Moving from fun and frothy to serious actor?

ScoutOfTheSoftHeartsClub · 01/03/2026 18:20

The character was certainly ‘earnest’ - with no room for a sense of humour at all. Perhaps AS was channelling that in her interviews? Ann Lee wasn’t shown to be unpleasant in any way, just driven.

But it is a musical! Of sorts. Interestingly one of the reviews notes that the film was 75% dance. And AS performs some of the songs.

I’d go for the visual spectacle - and a sometimes thrilling score.

OP posts:
OP posts:
ApolloandDaphne · 02/03/2026 10:30

I loved it, my DH less so. I liked the devotional music and worship type dance. I thought AS was very good. She was playing a very driven fervent woman which came across well. It wasn't like anything I've watched before.

ScoutOfTheSoftHeartsClub · 02/03/2026 10:44

The choreography was amazing. And worked with such complexity with the music. Interesting to read that the songs were based on historical examples, though the music wasn’t.

I know a good few musicians and composers and (without spoilering too much , I hope) I immediately longed to talk to them about the way ‘threat’ was handled sonically and instrumentally. That was really striking and impressive.

OP posts:
WinterCosiness · Yesterday 05:55

Sorry, I'm posting on this thread months later, but I only watched the film the other day, after chancing upon it when I was scrolling through the Disney channel looking for something to watch on a free evening.
I absolutely loved it. I was fascinated by the story of Ann Lee; and had to look up the Shakers afterwards. I knew a fair bit about the Quakers historically, who were very against singing & dancing; so it's interesting to see how the Shakers practiced worship in an almost totally opposite way. Funnily enough, I'm celibate, a conscious choice for mostly spiritual reasons, but like Ann Lee, I've always been a bit repulsed by carnality, and it was a revelation when I realised I'm allowed to opt out, and I find it hugely empowering as a woman; so I was intrigued by Ann Lee's steadfast dedication to abstinence. I felt she was portrayed extremely well; and I felt hugely sympathetic to her, especially her maternal grief 😔 Poor woman had so much loss.

I didn't actually realise it was a musical till afterwards 🤭 I thought the film was just portraying that the Shakers sang & danced their way through life! I found the musical scores and accompanying dance a bit of a trip! Mesmerising.

I've never seen a film like it before. I highly recommend it, especially to people with a religious or spiritual background, or those interested in ecclesiastical history, and female spiritual leadership.

The Shakers were a force for good - a belief in the equality of men & women, way ahead of their time. Strongly opposed to racism & slavery, hard workers & devout pacifists, at a time of so much war. Such good people, and it's sad there are so few left.

If you haven't watched this film, and the subject matter interests you, and you like music, I strongly recommend it.

ScoutOfTheSoftHeartsClub · Yesterday 09:35

No apology needed, @WinterCosiness - it’s good to read another review!

I completely get what you mean about the mode of storytelling simply portraying the Shakers as they lived - but it clearly wasn’t a naturalistic portrayal. Possibly I wouldn’t have called it as a musical if I hadn’t read it described thus - it’s nothing like any musical I’ve previously experienced - but the music was hugely important.

OP posts:
LaurieFairyCake · Yesterday 09:42

The second they started weeping, wailing and banging their chest I was out. HATED the noise.

so I think I managed about 20 minutes.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread